This letter is from Rep. James Gregoire (R-Fairfield), vice chair of the House Committee on Corrections and Institutions.
Vermonters face a crushing healthcare cost crisis, spending nearly 20% of personal income on care and premiums. Our health insurance burden is the highest in the nation, more than double the national average. This is unsustainable. However, ramming through bad policy like S.190 is a dangerous prescription that follows a long state pattern of passing legislation that increases delivery costs and premiums.
Vermont’s health care cost issues are primarily driven by poor state policy. Montpelier repeatedly tries to fix problems by piling on mandates, but S.190 ignores local economic realities. The data is clear — since the Green Mountain Care Board’s creation, Vermont has risen from 18th to 8th in healthcare spending per capita, and to 1st in health insurance premiums. The ACA Bronze Plan premium here is double the national average. We cannot solve a premium crisis by fracturing risk pools or bankrupting the institutions that deliver care.
For years, our rural hospitals have operated on razor-thin margins. To survive, they rely on commercial insurance payouts to subsidize underfunded Medicare and Medicaid reimbursements. Stripping millions from these tight budgets directly threatens local care. A national median price target fails to account for Vermont’s rural geography and aging population. NMC already operates on a razor's edge and faces millions in losses under S.190 — this does not help rural Vermonters. While we cannot predict when a rural hospital might close, we know these critical facilities are already hanging on by a thread, and they overwhelmingly opposed this bill for a reason.
Additionally, we need to address the long-term impact of hospital consolidation. When rural hospitals face closure, it risks creating a monopoly under the UVM Health Network. While UVMMC delivers essential care, its costs range from 40% to 250% higher than our rural hospitals. For example, when regulators apply a flat 2% rate increase across the board, a higher-priced hospital receives significantly more new revenue. Although GMCB policies put financial pressure on every hospital, rural providers are more vulnerable because they already operate on very thin margins while delivering the lowest-cost care. Ultimately, a lack of competition in healthcare drives costs up for patients and lowers quality, a lesson we have already learned from how the state has handled health insurance.
Worse, S.190 fails to deliver system-wide relief by picking winners and losers. The bill accelerates arbitrary price caps only for select groups, such as public-school employees and those on Vermont Health Connect. You cannot artificially cap prices for some groups without driving up costs for everyone else; this is cost-shifting, not cost savings. Our small businesses, large employers, non-profits, and independent workers will absorb the deficit through increased premiums. We nearly triggered a collapse of the very institutions that deliver care when Blue Cross Vermont faced an acute solvency crisis, showing that fracturing risk pools risks bankrupting the entire provider network.
Healthcare policy does not operate in a vacuum, and we must face its real-world results. The reality is that the savings and cost projections for S.190 are largely guesswork. An estimated property tax reduction of $35 per $100,000 in assessed value is hardly a victory for property owners, especially when it comes at the expense of premium increases averaging $48 a month for a family of three. Because Vermont caps property taxes based on income for 70% of homeowners, a lower tax rate likely wouldn't put money back in most owner’s pockets. But rather, the state would scale back its credit payments. The savings would go primarily to high-earning homeowners and commercial properties, leaving everyday working families with little to nothing.
Achieving true healthcare affordability in Vermont requires a regulatory environment where rural hospitals can remain financially viable. Developing targeted incentives that encourage patients to utilize these lower-cost community facilities is essential for system-wide cost containment.
Governor Scott made the correct call by vetoing S.190. Vermonters deserve better than short-sighted mandates from Montpelier. While the underlying policy is complicated and the property tax components alone would take multiple pages to explain, the reality is quite simple — we cannot keep following the path that led us into disaster. True cost containment requires all of us to step out of our echo chambers and pursue real structural reform that expands choices and lowers premiums for everyone.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here