Letter to the editor: A Walk Through History, what did we forget?

Posted

A walk through history, what did we forget?

I’m responding to the “Walk Through History” letter (Oct. 10) by Linda Myers and Tim Jerman.

I’ve attended more merger related Selectboard, Joint Board and Governance Subcommittee Meetings this summer than both Myers and Jerman put together, I’m curious how they are so sure that board members “will address these issues (higher taxes, representation, identity, and accessibility) among others.”

My observations have been that the TOV has no representation in equal numbers to the Village reps although this has been asked for.

At meeting after meeting, board members do not articulate a clear answer to “Why merge? What problem is solved? How much will merger cost? Why not entertain other options?”.

Although tax impacts could have been offered long ago, only when outside parties began to estimate them, was staff asked produce this.

The Selectboard and trustees promise to extend village-level services to the entire town without saying how this will be done. Will additional taxes be needed? Will services be reduced?

George Tyler has stated, but does not publicize, that no more cost savings from consolidation or merger are to be had. Therefore, voters have unrealistic expectations from the promises that Village-based politicians have made over time: “we will make the town pay their fair share.”

Myers / Jerman introduce themselves as “old warriors” from prior merger votes. I guess that makes me a young warrior. Maybe that’s why I can easily set aside merger as a solution to the tax, representation and identity problems. I don’t have an investment in merger. I barely remember the 2007 vote.

I’m not naïve. I’m just not chained to Merger. I’ve looked at the problem with fresh eyes and see three issues, none of which merger solves well or solves at all. I also see where the Town and Village have cooperated, partnered and saved.

I propose incorporating what is working into what is needed to really solve the taxation, representation and identity problems. I call it Separate-and-Share and it’s summarized here: SeparateAndShare.com. I hope Linda and Tim will take a look.

Separate-and-Share can provide every resident more local control over spending, taxation, representation, transparency and access to government services.

Separate-and-Share is not about creating a rift but instead building a bridge, transporting ideas and people between two sometimes distant psychological and geographic shores.

We have voted to completely separate or to completely merge — repeatedly since 1958 – and those votes were close. These solutions did not seem satisfy problems in the eyes of the voters.

We need a new plan that is so appealing to both the TOV and the Village that it can pass by a wide margin. Then we can be confident that it’s the best way forward. That it will bring partnership rather than continued animosity. That it will bring transparency instead of smokescreen. That it will unchain our nested government structure into two entities that are free to address their population’s concerns.

What is naïve is believing that if after 12 years, there is no good plan, that more time will produce one. Especially when those financially impacted negatively are not given an equal say. The past 12 years HAVE seen successfully partnered departments and savings.

If the Village and the TOV separate, while continuing to partner and share, each community can provide the services it deems appropriate to the population that actually votes for and will pay for them. A far cry from the current situation, in which board members attempt to pass burdensome taxes from their home district onto those who did not vote for them.

Ken Signorello

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here