Perhaps Milk With Dignity supporters, farmers who need increased milk prices, and retail workers hoping for a living wage should take care not to fall prey to divide & conquer strategies. Potential solutions, all with the goal of improving compensation and conditions for various underpaid workers, deserve due consideration. Common goals can lead to common solutions.
Earlier this month a group of local backers of Migrant Justice's Milk With Dignity project delivered a letter to a manager of the St. Albans area Hannaford. It was addressed to the CEO of the chain and asks for a commitment to ensuring farmworkers producing Hannaford brand milk receive at least minimum wage, safety training, decent housing, and civil rights. The manager accepted the letter and listened with good grace. Migrant Justice is waiting for a response from its early November actions at 23 Hannafords.
Since that time there has been push back claiming this effort does not support local agriculture ("Milk with Dignity campaign wrong and misdirected," Saint Albans Messenger, Nov.11). The letter includes some information that does not reflect recent improvements in Ben & Jerry's supply chain since it signed a contract with Migrant Justice. And it suggests that the organization and supporters of the improvements blame milk producers - especially hard-working and substantially underpaid farmers - for the problems.
Not the case. Between 2016 and 2018 Ben & Jerry's (now owned by Unilever which has $611 million annually in sales) paid a premium to about 70 farms for better farming and labor practices. Since signing with Migrant Justice, 250 farm workers have received a total of $370,000. This aid from the corporation is far more than "politically correct" or "a marketing ploy," as the opposition writer seems to fear. It is a practical compromise, paid for by the corporation, which comes back to help both the farmer and farm employees - financially and yes, if not the apparently offensive "high moral ground," in decency and better morale. If you listen to migrant workers and farmers currently in the Milk with Dignity program, now covering about 20% of Vermont dairy farms, it is obvious the arrangement is highly likely to pay for itself in the long run and benefit consumers, as well.
In early October, when Migrant Justice kicked off its campaign to encourage Hannaford, which has approximately 40% of Vermont farms in its supply chain, supporters in Burlington heard from beneficiaries of the assistance. Jose Luis, a dairy worker from Franklin County shared his experience: "My co-workers and I have new, dignified housing, where we all have our own room and there is space to rest. We get paid vacation and sick days, and our check always comes on time." Vermont farm owner Matt Maxwell, who is enrolled in Milk With Dignity, talked about the savings he has garnered from the program. He explained that the farm now has an 85% employee retention rate which lead to "higher morale and greater workplace continuity." Clearly you don't have to re-train migrant employees - who in a study by Columbia Law School and Tufts School of Public Health reported a lack of training and 75% to 93% rate of injury - as often, and medical expenses, lost work time, and legal entanglements are more likely to be avoided.
Even if people leery of change want to look this gift horse in the mouth, there is a healthy opening here. Hannaford is owned by Dutch multinational corporation Ahold-Delhaize which reports over $75 billion annually in sales. It has a department which helps with ethical sourcing.
There's no doubt dairy farm owners deserve a decent, government dairy price support program. With most U.S. milk produced under federal or state marketing orders, regulation of milk from lower-cost regions such as the Midwest in higher cost regions like New England is critical. The pricing volatility and other factors, however, appears to be driving many Vermont farmers out of business.
In addition to petitioning corporations and government, a hard look at and action on labor practices and livable wages for retail employees is desperately needed. Postponing adoption of measures to enforce labor law and improve the minimum wage so that its actual implementation might only keep up with inflation is insufficient.
While corporations, government, and longtime suppliers understandably wary of change may not intend to divide groups seeking improvement, let us be cautious about dividing ourselves. Just because Julius Cesar gets credited with taking over Gaul with his divide & conquer strategy 2,200 years ago, doesn't mean we can't learn from history. Let us find the way forward by aiding and abetting one another.
Marilyn Hackett
Franklin
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here