ST. ALBANS CITY — A federal judge has blocked the idling of the DFA St. Albans plant for five days after Teamsters Local 597 alleged Dairy Farmers of America is closing the plant to “get back” at the union.
The union filed the complaint in Vermont’s district court on Friday, Aug. 14, and Judge William K. Sessions granted the motion on Monday, calling for a temporary stop on work to close the plant until the court can hold a preliminary injunction to get more information Aug. 20.
In response, DFA said the company has complied with the order and is looking forward to the hearing, alleging that the union has relied on fabricated evidence.
“(The decision to idle the St. Albans plant) was completely unrelated to last year’s strike activity and any suggestions that it was retaliatory is ridiculous and inaccurate,” DFA said in a statement.
The announcement to close the DFA plant came out this past June, with the company citing various reasons for the move, such as changes in the dairy market, regulatory pressures and operational needs
Teamsters 597, however, alleges that previous union strikes — held in September 2025 — were the “#1 reason, and the complaint lists multiple comments with plant supervisors, as well as an “internal corporate memo” from last fall penned by plant manager Panos Lekkas, as evidence.
According to the union court complaint: “(The memo) identifies a string of ostensible business justifications for the closure — cost reduction, capacity utilization, litigation exposure and regulatory penalties — but emphasizes that “union decertification" is the “#1 reason.”
DFA alleges the memo was created by artificial intelligence and disputes the union claim.
Upon hearing the evidence, however, Sessions labeled the situation as a “reverse Boys Markets” scenario, citing a court case from 1970 which stops union arbitration cases from becoming a “hollow formality” when work is already being done.
According to the union, DFA has already begun dismantling the facility and its equipment to ship to other locations. As a result, the union notes, “employees will lose not only their employment but their health insurance and other medical benefits.”
Roughly 80 DFA employees are expected to lose their jobs due to the closure, although a small team will continue to maintain the property.
“The employer has discriminated and continues to discriminate against employees for their lawful activity and support for the Union by closing the facility and severing their employment in order to retaliate against them for engaging in strike activity," the union alleges.
As a result of the 2025 strike, workers negotiated a 14.5% increase in wages over 22 months.
In response, DFA contests the union’s evidence pointing to “clear inaccuracies and indicators which further confirm its illegitimate nature and purpose.”
“The union failed to respond to our requests for how they came into possession of such a fraudulent document and why no effort was made to verify its authenticity before using it as the foundation for serious allegations,” DFA added.
Until the court can better consider the evidence on Aug. 20, DFA has been ordered to “cease implementation of the St. Albans facility closure and take no other action to eliminate or diminish work by the employees represented” by the union.
“The Court finds that the equities of the case, the balance of hardships, and the public interest favor Plaintiff’s position,” Session’s opinion reads.
Additionally, the document clarifies the court is not taking sides between DFA and the Teamsters union during negotiations, but rather the court is trying to prevent “irreparably injury” as argued by the union if the idling is allowed to continue while discussions between the two entities continue “as (the union’s) victory at arbitration would ring hollow without a continuing place of employment.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here