ST. ALBANS – Judge Robert A. Mello wouldn’t say whether or not he’d approve issuing an injunction against Act 46 merger activity as of the conclusion of Friday’s hearing on a trio of lawsuits challenging the state’s merger law as unconstitutional.
Lawyers representing plaintiffs in the largest of those suits, a statewide lawsuit featuring several Franklin County school boards and selectboards from Franklin and Montgomery, argued that without an injunction halting Act 46’s merger plan, irreparable damage would be done as merging districts organized transitional boards as mandated by the consolidation process.
The state, meanwhile, argued that the irreparable damage referenced by the plaintiffs was only “remote and speculative,” and that halting merger activity could potentially harm districts undergoing a merger process as it’d force them to once again delay organizational meetings while still keeping them beholden to Act 46’s July 1, 2019 deadline.
The irreparable damage in question, argued attorney Ines McGillion, would come in the form of money spent by merging districts to organize and warn meetings ahead of consolidations that, according to McGillion, the plaintiffs were confident would be determined unconstitutional.
McGillion told Mello that the costs of those meetings, whether funded through loans, supervisory union budgets or court-ordered restitution from the state, would ultimately be placed on Vermont taxpayers regardless of whether or not Mello would rule in the plaintiffs’ favor.
Plaintiffs also levied a shortlist of administrative complaints against the State Board of Education’s interpretation of the Act 46 process: inconsistent interpretation, assertion that differing debt levels between districts were not considered, the state ignored alternative governance structure proposals, that mergers were ordered where “possible” rather than “necessary.”
“We come before you like a woman came before King Solomon, asking you not to split the baby, because the baby cannot be put back together,” McGillion said. “These transitional boards will create irreparable harm and set us on a path to merger, and the plaintiffs will not be able to be compensated.”
The state’s attorneys contested McGillion’s argument that immediate, irreparable harm would come without an injunction, as financial damages asserted by McGillion were only “speculative” and physical damage alleged by the suits in the form of shifted debts, properties and governing authorities wouldn’t take place until a merged district became operational in July 2019.
The state argued further that the suits’ plaintiffs didn’t have a right to assert that harm, with state attorney Jon Alexander stating there was “no such legal protection” to “retain exclusive authority over public education of students in their district” or “exclusive spending and borrowing and taxing authority over students and households in their district.”
“If we think of irreparable harm, we think of harm that is actual and imminent, not speculative or remote based on fear or uncertainty,” said Alexander. “That is precisely the only type of harm they’ve put forth.”
When returning to the question of issuing an injunction, the state asserted an injunction would only further disrupt the Act 46 process, cutting another wedge out of the limited window districts had to organize their respective mergers.
“We’re not hampering a legal process,” McGillion countered. “We’re hampering an illegal process.”
“… where necessary”
While Friday’s hearing was focused specifically on a requested injunction for halting Act 46 merger activity, both sides levied the suits’ larger arguments against one another over whether Act 46 and Act 49, a law amending Act 46, were unconstitutional.
The plaintiffs in all three Act 46 cases argue that the Vermont legislature violated the state’s constitution when it delegated school consolidations to the State Board of Education, with attorneys McGillion and David Kelley citing Vermont statute stating that only the legislature had the right to assign and reassign municipalities.
The state defended the State Board of Education’s process by disputing that school districts equated to municipalities, and argued that, due to the sheer volume of consolidations to be considered under Act 46, the legislature had to delegate that authority to the state board. “It was a large and daunting task appropriately delegated to an entity with expertise,” Alexander said. “The board was directed to do it.”
State attorney David Boyd also cited precedent from outside of Vermont, where other state and federal courts had upheld their respective states’ authority to merge districts. McGillion immediately countered that they were arguing about whether or not this was approved under Vermont’s constitution, “not those of 49 other states.”
The court would return to the question of reassigning debt among merging districts, with Mello pressing the state on an earlier argument that, by not considering differing levels of debt and forcibly merging two or more districts with a relative debt disparity, State Board of Education was in violation of the law.
The state countered that new districts formed through the Act 46 process had, through the default Articles of Agreement, the authority to review how debt would be assigned across towns in the new school district, leaving that debt disparity ultimately in the hands of the electorate.
“There’s nothing to prevent the new transitional board or initial board… to change those articles of agreement to provide for what the electorate or the elected board thinks is a more equitable transfer of debt,” Alexander argued earlier in the hearing. “The solution in part to the debt disparity… is in the hands of the new school district and the voters.”
Alexander argued further that the board had considered districts’ debts before merging them, citing instances on record where the State Board of Education had reviewed tax information from respective districts before ultimately agreeing on a merger.
The state also argued that the plaintiffs were selectively reading Act 46 when it came to their argument that the State Board of Education had failed to order mergers only “where necessary,” as Act 46 called for the consideration of both consolidation and the implementation of an alternative governance structure as “necessary.”
At the conclusion of Friday’s hearing, Judge Mello refused to issue an immediate decision on an injunction, stating that “these issues are very important to the parties; the court wants to give them serious consideration.”
“I’m not going to give any weather reports today about what I’m going to do,” Mello said. “I’ll address the motion for a preliminary injunction as soon as I possibly can.”
While present, lawyers representing the school districts in Lamoille South Supervisory Union and the Huntington School District, two parties also suing the state over Act 46, did not present arguments for an injunction.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here