ST. ALBANS — At Northwestern Medical Center, staff have been spit on and screamed at, in the room when a patient has thrown equipment or punched a wall.
“When somebody is violent, it’s pretty scary,” said JoAnn Manahan, RN, director of the emergency department. “It’s intimidating, it’s frustrating, and it’s exhausting. It hurts us all.”
According to a report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, more than double the number of healthcare workers reported harassment at work in 2022 than in 2018 – rising from 6% in 2018 to 13% in 2022.
That upward trend is true locally here in St. Albans, where medical staff at NMC say they are seeing more and more aggressive behaviors from patients and visitors.
“Our staff have been bit and hit so hard they have been bruised,” said Danielle Boudro, RN, director of NMC’s progressive care unit.
And while these incidents of harassment and violence are personally traumatizing for staff, they often go unreported. Many nurses, for example, get into the profession because they are passionate about helping people in need.
“So it can feel a little weird to bring charges against someone you are caring for,” said Kate Laddison, NMC’s director of community relations.
“But that behavior is not acceptable,” Boudro said. “It’s not part of the job.”
While healthcare workers make up 10% of the U.S. workforce, they experience 48% of the country’s nonfatal injuries due to workplace violence, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
For emergency department staff, that risk is even higher.
In a 2022 American College of Emergency Physicians survey of E.R. doctors, 55% said they had been physically assaulted, almost all by patients, with a third of those resulting in injuries. The risks can be even higher for E.R. nurses, with over 70% reporting they had sustained physical assaults at work.
“I know a couple of people who have left bedside nursing because of this,” Manahan said. “They don’t do frontline patient care anymore.”
The burnout is real. In 2022, the percentage of health workers who intended to look for a new job increased to 44%, up from 33% in 2018, according to the CDC.
Violence in the E.R. is stark evidence of many of society’s more expansive issues: the scarcity of mental health beds, an increase in drug and alcohol abuse, the crisis of homelessness and the rising cost of living. All of this can lead to longer wait times in the E.R., which can rupture into frustration, anger and even violent behavior.
“I think people think the pandemic ended and everything went back to normal, but it really hasn’t been,” Laddison said. “We need to reset people’s expectations.”
To help protect staff and prevent outbursts from occurring, NMC and other stakeholders have started a variety of internal processes and initiatives. But what do staff need most? External awareness of the issue.
Some validation of the issue came just over a year ago, when the Vermont legislature passed and Gov. Phil Scott signed S. 36 or Act 24, a bill that draws attention to violence and harassment against healthcare workers.
Since 2011, healthcare workers in Vermont have already received the same protections against assault as police officers and firefighters, but this new 2023 law expands enforcement.
The act permits a law enforcement officer to arrest a person without a warrant if there is probable cause to believe the person committed certain misdemeanor crimes against hospital workers or against emergency medical treatment providers.
The act also enhances the penalty for the crime of criminal threatening if the offense is committed with the intent to terrify or intimidate a healthcare worker.
Sen. Ginny Lyons (D-Williston) introduced the bill with the late Sen. Dick Sears (D-Bennington), and the judiciary and health and welfare committees subsequently listened to testimony from doctors, nurses and other medical staff who have experienced violence in their workplaces.
“It was really one of the most compelling things we did last year,” Lyons told the Messenger. “We heard testimony from some E.D. nurses who are really scarred for life, emotionally, and they're still dealing with emotional recovery from this.”
Dr. Louis Dandurand, MD, medical director of the emergency department at NMC, said while the bill won’t stop workplace violence from occurring, it does empower staff to seek the help of law enforcement if desired.
“This was necessary,” he said of the new law. “It was a welcome step in the right direction in terms of healthcare workers feeling safer in the face of the more aggressive, violent behaviors.”
NMC has a strong relationship with the St. Albans Police Department, but Dandurand said staff members are usually capable of de-escalating situations on their own. If the police are called, it's after the incident has already occurred so the perpetrator can face the potential consequences.
And though hospital staff have pressed charges in the past, their faith in the judicial system to impose punishment has waned.
“The charges can get made and the patient or visitor gets cited, but then if the court system drops them every time, or makes light of them, then what's the point of the law?” Boudro said.
Since the COVID-19 pandemic, Vermont’s understaffed judicial system has struggled to keep up with its backlog of cases. That’s why it’s important for legislators on different committees to work collaboratively, Lyons said.
If re-elected, Lyons plans to take up this issue again as chair of the Senate Committee on Health and Welfare. She said she’ll work with folks from the judiciary, housing and human services committees to think about how Vermont’s larger problems play a role in healthcare violence.
And while she thinks the legislature can do more to help keep healthcare workers safe, she also knows some change won’t come from law. A societal shift is needed, Lyons said.
“Part of it is simply going to be looking at how we change the culture and what expectations people have when they're going into a healthcare facility,” she said.
When Manahan is interviewing candidates for nursing positions in NMC’s emergency department, she said workplace violence often comes up as a point of conversation.
If the candidate has worked in another E.D., they are aware it's a situation they might face – as hospitals across the U.S. are experiencing similar pressures.
“But then they want to know, what do we do to protect them? And what things do we have in place to help prevent or stop this?” Manahan said.
Before the pandemic, NMC instituted a “Code Green Team,” who will come on scene if a staff member is not able to de-escalate a situation on their own. Made up of several people, the team can calm down an agitated patient or visitor without law enforcement.
In the first half of 2024, Code Green was called to an incident 34 times.
NMC also contracts with an outside company to provide security on the grounds daily. Security has been asked to be on “standby” during an incident 90 times so far this year.
After a tense situation, staff will huddle up to de-brief, said Corey Rivers, RN, manager of NMC’s med-surg unit. Nurses check in on each other and discuss what can be learned from the event.
NMC staff learn de-escalation techniques and defensive tactics through AVADE Training, a program that tailors the learning to individual departments.
While it might be assumed patients suffering from mental illness or drug and alcohol abuse cause the most disturbances, Manahan said patients and visitors of “sound mind and body” can be just as disruptive.
It’s for this reason the hospital is also in the process of putting up new signs across the facility that remind patients and visitors that “assaulting a healthcare worker is a crime.” Laddison said the signs have been ordered and will be installed in the coming months.
NMC’s new emergency department, unveiled last year, was also designed with prevention in mind. The department’s intake space is more private, and specific beds for patients with mental illness keep them partitioned from the rest of the wing.
“We tried to create a healing atmosphere, where people can get care and find some peace,” Dandurand said.
A patient’s ability to relax, he added, is directly related to how quickly they heal and get better. Therefore, the impact of someone shouting, punching or throwing stretches beyond hospital staff, to other patients.
“It definitely changes the atmosphere,” Dandurand said. “It's not only healthcare workers who are impacted, but the whole institution.”
One person’s decision to flare-up in a moment of impatience or frustration has a ripple effect, hurting those around them and the staff who are required – and impassioned – to provide care.
Zoom out beyond the hospital, and you’ll find aggressive behaviors in a wide variety of spaces, from a busy restaurant to the DMV. And while some snowball from society’s greater ailments, it's clear the community needs to check its emotions and reestablish zero tolerance for violence.
“It’s not just hospital workers, it can be the customer service person at Subway or Maplefields,” Rivers said. “They might be thinking, ‘Should I have to put up with this?’
“The answer is, no.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here