Is retail theft out of control in St. Albans?

Posted

ST. ALBANS – As the St. Albans Police Department prepares for its expected expansion, St. Albans City Council held a discussion about public safety with Ace Hardware business owner Gordon Winters this past Monday, Dec. 11.

Winters said he wanted to visit the council to talk about the changes seen at his store in the post-COVID-era, as multiple instances of shoplifting have become a daily occurrence.

“Retail theft here in the City of St Albans is the worst that I have seen in my career,” Winters said. “We have six stores now (across Vermont). And St. Albans is the worst then in any of our stores.”

Winters told the council Monday he’s seen a marked difference in how people are committing retail theft.

Basically in the past, Winters said retail workers would typically keep careful eyes and ears on customers in the store in order to prevent shoplifting, and if someone would notice they were being watched, they’d leave.

“It’s different now, and that’s what I want to tell the council,” Winters said. “It’s different.”

Now, people will come and steal from the store often brazenly, he said, without stopping when seen or caught, leaving through the front doors and getting into a pre-arranged getaway vehicle. Winters said he can call the police to stop the problem, but they often arrive after the thief disappears, and his workers have a difficult time preventing someone when they feel “entitled to steal.”

Stuck in a hard place

Winters isn’t the only business owner concerned about retail theft. A spate of armed robberies of convenience stores in St. Albans last month – and throughout Franklin County in the last year – has reinvigorated a larger discussion about the need for more law enforcement.

“Everything changed with COVID,” St. Albans Police Chief Maurice Lamothe said. “And I can’t say definitively why, other than maybe it brought a different clientele. I don’t know if that’s the only reason. We offer some resources there that some of the other communities didn’t.”

Retail theft has also been on the rise nationally, prompting national retailers like Walgreens to begin locking toiletries behind glass. The National Retail Federation estimated that “shrink” – the industry term for retail theft – cost retailers $94.5 billion in 2021, up from $61.7 billion in 2019 before the pandemic.

As for local reasons behind the change, a few theories were floated Monday night as councilors asked for more information about what Winters was seeing at the store. 

City Manager Dominic Cloud asked Lamothe if the end of the hotel voucher program could have played a part?

Lamothe said the program likely brought people without a stable economic foundation into town, which aligns with some of the increase in retail theft seen at the end of summer. That’s not to say that people suffering from homelessness are committing the crimes, Lamothe said, but rather that people on the economic fringes brought in by the program may be using theft to cover the cost of drug addictions. 

“The voucher program brought people that may not have had a lot of economic resources,” he said.

Samaritan House executive director Ben Kaufmann, who has dealt closely with people from the program, agreed with Lamothe in that economic hardship is probably what’s driving much of the theft.

The COVID-19 pandemic drove painful inflationary increases to almost all lower- and middle-class households in the United States, and Vermont’s housing crunch only exacerbated the budgetary squeeze felt by those finding themselves unable to afford basic necessities, he said.

Quantitative studies of inflationary impacts on property crimes rates have also shown that thefts tend to rise as goods become more expensive, since more and more people look to alternatives to paying higher prices.

“There are more people who are struggling to a point where they’re going to steal,” Kaufmann  said.

To combat the issue, Kaufmann recommended the state advocate for more inpatient drug addiction services to help people work through substance abuse issues.

In the meantime, Winters said he’s considered hiring a security guard as a potential deterrent to crime.

Ace employees have also found some success publishing the faces of people who had stolen from the store via social media, to help identify who they were, although the process rarely ends with returned stolen goods. 

But what Winters would like to see is less retail thefts.

“I’m just here to tell you what I think,” he said to the council. “And see if there’s something we can do differently to make it better, because I want these criminals out of here.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here