Hydropower dam in need of fix; Swanton Village examines bladder options

Posted

HIGHGATE – A day after getting its check-up, the Orman Croft Hydroelectric Facility – also known as the Highgate Dam – suffered a major break. A 15-foot-long hole ripped along the 47-ton rubber air bladder bolted to its concrete top.

The Village of Swanton, which owns and operates the facility, is now in the middle of finding a fix for the problem.

“Without knowing the cost, or if we can even do it, we’re still in a state of wait and see,” Village Manager Bill Sheets said.

Options moving forward 

The initial breakage of the dam’s air bladder occurred in mid-June after a specialist came to make a smaller fix and inspect the equipment. But while the inspector was en route back to Utah the next day, Sheets said a seam that had been chemically sealed came undone to create a much larger gash, rendering the rubber device inoperable.

The air bladder itself is located at the top of the dam. Installed roughly 40 years ago to increase its charging capacities, the device – which essentially functions as a big rubber air sac that holds back a higher water level – plays a big part in keeping Swanton Village’s electric bills low for customers.

Without it, Sheets said Swanton’s dam can still generate electricity, but at the reduced max capacity of 6MW. With the air bladder, that capacity increases to 9.6MW per hour, giving Swanton an additional edge in the state’s electric markets.

The problem at the moment, Sheets said, is they’re still trying to get some final answers on what Swanton Village can do to address the bladder’s big hole.

The lowest cost alternative is to repair the rubber seam, as the whole bladder was replaced about seven years ago. Sheets said the village only had a year warranty for the device, but the manufacturer and engineering group – known as HTE Engineering – have sent in additional specialists to help Swanton find those answers. 

Under normal conditions, Swanton’s air bladder was expected to last closer to 15 to 20 years, Sheets said.

The village also needs to have an ongoing conversation with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. The federal agency is responsible for the nation’s hydropower dams, and federal officials will need to give the sign-off to any changes made to the dam.

For example, the village will likely need to seek out additional permits to rebuild an earlier access road to the dam that would help provide workers with access to the complicated mechanism. No matter what the situation, Sheets said the village will likely need to seek out such a permit for that road. 

In the best case scenario, they’ll use the approach to seal up the former breakage point. But if the work can’t be completed by the end of this year’s construction season, then they’ll have to remove the air bladder before winter comes.

If they left it in place, the intermix of ice and freezing water could even take parts of it downstream, Sheets said.

Instead, the village is looking for a relatively cheap and quick answer to the scenario. If everything comes back as hoped, Sheets said they could have the air bladder and the dam back up and running by September.

If the problem deepens, however, Swanton Village Trustees will have to have a much longer conversation about how they want to solve the dam’s problem. Replacing the air bladder could end up being a two-year-process, Sheets said.

“We’re hopeful that this can be repaired and FERC agrees. … That’s the hope and that’s what the engineer says is going to happen. The worst case scenario is it’s not fixable and have to engineer a situation with FERC,” Sheets said.

In the meantime, the village will wait until more information is known about the situation, Sheets said, with more expected to come down the line in roughly a week’s time when the village files its action plan with federal regulators.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here