FRANKLIN COUNTY — Dr. Richard Dickinson, Sr. is beginning to think about retirement.
After five decades looking after Franklin County’s teeth and gums, it’s time for the next generation to take the reins, and since 2001, Vermont has seen the second steepest decline in dental workforce in the nation.
Luckily for St. Albans, two of Dr. Dickinson’s children — Dr. Rich Dickinson, Jr. and Dr. Grace Branon — have already jumped into the dentistry profession, but other places across Franklin County and Vermont aren’t so fortunate.
As a young student, Dr. Rich Dickinson Jr. wasn’t sure dentistry was for him. Though he’d grown up the son of a dentist, he started his professional career as an engineer.
“My parents didn't necessarily encourage or discourage,” he said. “They thought engineering seemed like a really good baseline education to get. It was fascinating and pragmatic.”
Several years and many night classes later, Rich joined his father and sister, Dr. Grace Branon, at Dickinson & Branon in St. Albans. His father has worked in town since 1973, building a reputable practice that’s served generations of Franklin County families.
“Little kids who saw Dr. D back in the 70s and 80s are now parents or grandparents,” Rich said. “It’s cool to get to know patients and their families over several decades.”
Dickinson & Branon faces many of the same challenges as other small businesses, from hiring staff to inflated costs. As a kid, Rich pitched in by helping clean the office on weekends, and he noticed his father’s hard work when he sat with him at night as he paid the bills.
But those efforts are worthwhile, Rich said, when he sees a young patient finally relax in the dental chair or an adult regain function or aesthetic.
“It’s those times when we can give patients the information, the motivation and the treatment to give them a good outcome,” he said.
Dentistry in Vermont, however, faces a possible crisis. Like other specialist health services, it’s been hard to make the career feel attainable and desirable.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, between 2019 and 2022, the number of dentists per capita in the state dropped by 14.4%. By 2023, there was just one dentist per 1,888 Vermonters, according to the American Dental Association.
A 2023 census conducted by the Vermont Department of Health counted 19 dentists in Franklin County and zero in Grand Isle County.
Dickinson & Branon Dental Care tried to add an associate doctor to the team last summer, but she left a few weeks ago, after just about one year with the practice.
“We were hoping she would put down roots in Vermont, in Franklin County,” Rich said. “She was from Florida, and she, understandably, missed her family.”
Dickinson & Branon isn’t the only practice finding it a challenge to hire and retain dental professionals. Lianne Trombley, human resources director for Northern Tier Center for Health, said recruiting in rural areas often means a limited pool of applicants, especially for specialized roles like dental hygienists or dentists.
“Staffing shortages can have a significant impact on both patient care and team dynamics,” she said.
Not enough providers makes for fewer available appointments, causing patients to endure long wait times, drive far distances or put off preventative care — which could snowball into more serious issues down the line.
Staff who are available might be required to take on additional responsibility, which can lead to burnout and lower morale.
Dickinson & Branon takes on as many new patients as possible despite their reduced bandwidth, Rich said, because he feels a duty to be available to patients when they finally muster the motivation to make an appointment.
“We keep plugging away, working hard and trying to do a good job,” he said.
It’s a common concern for health specialists across the board. Between 2016 and 2020, the state lost 70 primary care physicians. Psychologists and obstetrician-gynecologists are also on the decline.
There are ongoing efforts to reverse that trend. Over the years, several of Dickinson & Branon’s staff have come through the tech center pipeline. One current staff member and a few former, who have now moved on to dental hygiene school, completed Northwest Career and Technical Center’s medical professions program.
As far as higher education goes, both Dickinson and Branon said they had to leave Vermont to earn their doctoral degrees in dental medicine. For today’s students, that’s about to change.
In 2027, University of Detroit Mercy in partnership with the Vermont State Dental Society will open a new dental clinic and education program in Colchester, bringing more young professionals to the state. Students will attend school in Detroit for their first two years, followed by their final two years at the Vermont campus.
“By having them here for two years, we’re sure they’re going to be turned onto Vermont and the beauty of the state and the way of life and it will be natural for them to remain,” Patrick Gallivan, executive director of the Vermont State Dental Society, said.
With a laugh, Rich shared that his father Dr. D started his dental career in Vermont because he could own cows here and go skiing. Today’s students will still find those opportunities as well as many more — though affordable housing remains a struggle.
Back in May, soon-to-be high school graduate Lilian Duffy signed to a full-time dental assistant job at NOTCH’s Swanton Dental Clinic.
She’d already worked at the clinic for the last year, earning course credit at Northwest Career and Technical Center while receiving training from professionals in the field. For Trombley, Duffy’s signing was proof NOTCH’s investment in local students is paying off.
“She is very trainable, reliable and has a can-do attitude,” Trombley said of Duffy.
Those are the kinds of soft skills Trombley looks for in applicants to NOTCH’s open positions, of which there is currently one dentist and one dental hygienist.
A consistently limited pool of applicants led NOTCH to build its own pipeline for local people to acquire the skills and credentials necessary to fill the roles. When local people become qualified to do the work, that reduces dependency on external recruitment, Trombley said.
NOTCH now offers paid co-op positions to high school and college students in dental assisting and patient care coordination.
“These roles are designed to give students a meaningful introduction to the field while building skills that are immediately applicable,” Trombley said.
Trombley also tries to entice candidates with career advancement opportunities, competitive pay and benefits, and options for child care. The federally-qualified health center also awards annual scholarships to help fund continued education.
High school students who end up working at NOTCH often complete NCTC’s two-year medical professions program. And good news for local recruiters, a lot of students are looking to pursue medical careers. Thirty-two students are enrolled in the program for 2025, and instructor Tim Hurteau said there's a hefty waitlist.
About half of enrolled students follow a track to earn their Licensed Nursing Assistant certification. The rest study a rigorous curriculum and earn industry-recognized credentials in dentistry, pharmacy, physical therapy, emergency medical services and more.
Hurteau said the program expanded in recent years to cover more types of medical careers, after hearing community feedback about the lack of providers.
“They are telling me we need kids who are ready to get out and go,” he said. “The goal is to have students get enough from us that they either hop in at an entry level position or they start their post-secondary training.”
Instructor Julie Bucknell said dentistry sometimes isn’t a student’s first choice as it lacks some of the “cool factor” of other medical careers, but shadowing an area dentist can help change their mind.
“It's hard to get buy-in from a 16- or 17-year-old … Why would I want to work in someone’s mouth? That’s gross,” Bucknell said. “But once they are exposed to the environment and see that a lot of dental hygienists work 10-hour shifts four days a week, they realize it can be a pretty cool lifestyle.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here