Highgate’s senior housing plans sink; Lack of water pushes out Cathedral Square

Posted

HIGHGATE — Cathedral Square will not be building senior housing in Highgate anytime soon. 

The Burlington-based nonprofit developer announced the news Wednesday afternoon in a joint press release put together by the Town of Highgate, the Franklin County Industrial Development Corp. and the Northwest Regional Planning Commission.

“After years of working together, Cathedral Square and the Town of Highgate have made the difficult decision not to move forward with the proposed 30-unit Highgate Village Housing Project, after determining that a public water system to serve the development is not feasible,” the release reads. 

The Highgate Selectboard asked back on July 17 for the town administration to draft a letter to let Cathedral Square know it couldn’t provide water to the project. An earlier feasibility study estimated the cheapest option to cost $14 million.

“We talked with engineers, state agencies and others with expertise in water systems, explored every lead we could find and even considered a few creative options along the way,” town administrator A.J. Johnson’s emailed letter to developer Cindy Reid explained. 

”Unfortunately, every path we explored ultimately ran into physical limitations, state regulations or costs that simply weren’t realistic.” 

Change of plans

Highgate had initially been banking on using the Highgate Arena’s water source — its own well –— to ensure the larger village core project had access to fresh water, Johnson said, but problems ultimately came down the line regarding regulatory issues, including setback rules for public water sources.

Those difficulties — as well as the high estimated costs — eventually stopped the town’s exploratory process for a cheap water option, which in turn pulled Cathedral Square off the project.

“We, and our funding partners, are very disappointed,” Cathedral Square CEO Kim Fitzgerald stated in the release. “We worked closely with the Town and regional partners on a shared vision to create some much-needed housing in this rural community. Given the significant need for affordable housing to serve our growing older adult population evidenced by our long waitlist, it’s frustrating to not be able to move ahead. If Highgate is able to develop a public water system in the future, Cathedral Square would be glad to revisit this project.”

According to the release, the developer had secured a funding commitment of over $17 million to proceed with the plan, but their funding stack too came with “time-sensitive deadlines that could not be met without a clear plan for public water.”

That doesn’t mean Highgate doesn’t need housing. The release notes that Highgate’s vacancy rate is 0%, and the latest housing needs assessment released by the Northwest Regional Planning Commission estimates there’s a need for 1,600 more housing units to serve the population of older adults with disabilities who live in either Franklin and Grand Isle counties.

To help fill that gap, Franklin County Industrial Development Corp. director Tim Smith highlighted the state’s latest housing solution, the Community and Housing Infrastructure Program, in the release, although he noted additional solutions will also likely be needed to adequately tackle the state’s housing issues.

“CHIP is a good first step toward directing investment into rural infrastructure to support affordable housing efforts,” Smith said. “For small rural towns like Highgate, we need to identify other opportunities as well, if we are going to successfully address the housing needs we are experiencing.”

The State of Vermont has yet to award any funds through CHIP at this time, as the Vermont Economic Progress Council just started to take applications this summer. Through the program, the state has set aside up to $2 billion over a decade’s time to encourage housing investments.

Planning for wastewater

With Cathedral Square out of the picture, Highgate’s village core project continues to evolve.

The initial vision for the village core project, as explored in 2021 and 2022, was to create something of a commercial hub for the village anchored by a senior housing complex and a new updated library. 

Now five years later, the plan has shifted to just a wastewater system, which is still moving forward. The project — according to NRPC senior planner Greta Brunswick — is expected to break ground next year in order to “enable new and expanded business and housing opportunities in the village center.”

Johnson said the project team met just last week to discuss how to balance the various deadlines attached to the project “to ensure the available funds are used appropriately.” The latest estimates put the total project cost at $8.2 million, and roughly $7 million has been secured via state and federal sources. 

To make up the final pieces of the funding stack, however, town officials are now considering securing a line-of-credit. Proposed by the town administration, the latest discussions have focused on ensuring there’s a financial backup to give state officials additional assurances about lending the funds.

Back in August, the Highgate Selectboard agreed they’d ultimately leave that financial decision to voters, although the timing saw a few hiccups after the town administration missed the state deadline to get the vote on the latest November ballot, which will leave it for a special election to be held later.

Highgate is also actively talking to property owners about joining the system, Johnson said. If they sign-up by the end of the month, property owners are being promised the state would cover the roughly $30,000 to $40,000 needed to install the STEP septic tank which would connect each residence to the larger system. 

In total, the new system is designed and permitted to treat 20,000 gallons of wastewater per day, which equates to roughly 82 houses. Johnson said roughly one-third of that total has been allocated at this point to people who have expressed interest.

As for the larger timeline, Highgate expects next summer will see construction of the actual treatment facility, as well as new low-pressure sewer mains up-and-down Lamskin Street, Route 78, Gore Road and St. Armand Road. 

Over the years

The Highgate Selectboard could not be reached for comment prior to presstime, as Cathedral Square’s decision to leave the project hasn’t been the first hiccup on the project. Since the village core project got off the ground, Highgate has seen four different town administrators, as well as an interim administrator.

Additionally, turnover on the selectboard has been consistent since the project started. Currently, Chair Richard Flint is the longest-serving member, followed by Merry Souza, who joined in 2023.

Due to the project’s overall complexity, the consistent changeovers on both the staff and selectboard side has likely made it more difficult for project advocates to rally support, and there is a group of people who are weary of the effort. The Highgate Planning Commission, for example, recently discussed what it would take to nix the wastewater side of the project after hearing the news about Cathedral Square.

Plans for the library have also shifted over the years, especially after the town moved forward with the demolition of the old Stinehour motel. At one point, it had been proposed to move the library there and renovate the building, although it was ultimately deemed too costly to get done.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here