FRANKLIN COUNTY — Since 2002, Vermont’s population has plateaued. Today we’re seeing the repercussions.
Police officers across Franklin County feel unsupported, and they’re looking for resources to meet the demands that come with higher crime rates. The Vermont Department of Taxes is forecasting an 18.5% increase in the education tax rate, citing a double-digit increase in school spending due to inflation, insurance rate hikes and new capital projects. At Northwestern Counseling and Support Services – Franklin County’s largest human services nonprofit – one in six jobs are left unfilled.
The issue connecting all these problems? There’s not enough people and limited resources to do the work.
For many public service jobs and the people that fill such roles, it’s becoming next to impossible to recruit and retain new workers, leaving many crucial community services, such as law enforcement and education, in a pinch to tackle a host of societal issues only compounded by the COVID-19 pandemic.
We figured those working those jobs would be the best people to explain why.
Over the last month, Messenger reporters took a closer look at the varying factors that public service workers often face trying to do their jobs, focusing primarily on three professions – teachers, police officers and social workers. We wanted to know: “What does a day in your life look like?”
Those we talked to revealed a landscape often unseen by the public. While each job comes with its own unique challenges, those once labeled “essential workers” are now stuck with high expectations and complicated bureaucracies while serving a public as likely to react in anger as empathy.
Meanwhile, their personal budgets – especially for younger workers – no longer make sense as Vermonters confront an increasingly difficult affordability crisis. Many of those we spoke to have dedicated their lives to helping people, but they often cite a lack of resources to offer real solutions to the problems they see every day.
Many feel unheard and underappreciated.
“People forget that we’re human,” Cpl. Michael Fuller of the St. Albans Police Department said. “I have a girlfriend and a kid at home. I’m a dad; I go home and make dinner and tuck my kid in just like everybody else does.”
The problem for Vermont’s future is no one seems to want to take the next shift. Even with Gov. Phil Scott’s administration pushing for more people to move into the state, the reality is living in Vermont can be a financial stretch, especially for those repeatedly told how necessary they are to a community.
“It’s a chain reaction,” said Tim Smith, the executive director of the Franklin County Industrial Development Corporation. “You can bring people here, but where are they going to find a home? Where are they going to find childcare?”
Those we talked to are trying to make it work. Time and time again, our reporters found people dedicated to their fields, unwilling to seek out higher paying jobs in the interest of helping people.
We wanted our readers to hear their voices.
Jennifer Carpenter has long been a fixture at Enosburg Elementary School. A graduate of the school herself, she has been teaching there since 1990.
To Carpenter, teaching isn’t an 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. job. It’s “24/7, everyday.”
Along with spending seven hours a day teaching her students, teachers are increasingly taking on new, different responsibilities, becoming more involved with mental and behavioral health services for students, and guiding them through a digital age in which technology in the classroom isn’t just an option, it’s a new reality.
“It is an encompassing job, because you don’t leave it…what the expectations are…it’s not so much my local admin, it’s coming from higher up. They easily forget,” Carpenter said. “They started in a classroom, and I think when their hand hits the door, they forgot what it’s like to have the demands of wanting to get these kids where they need to be by the end of the year.”
And from what Carpenter’s seen, the pay in her school district is simply not comparable to that of others. Now, she’s watched as educators have left the rural hills of northern Franklin County for higher paying jobs in southern Franklin County and neighboring Chittenden County.
At St. Albans Town Educational Center, educators aren’t any less swamped. Helen Lanthier, a Kindergarten through eighth grade literacy coach, said an aging workforce and low staffing numbers spread SATEC educators thin.
“Teachers in particular, have noticed that decrease because they’re left with unfilled positions,” Lanthier said. “We have many, even just paraprofessional positions that we haven’t been able to fill that are really meant for one-on-one student support,”
“It’s a tremendous pressure, I would say, on teachers,” she added. “You notice it, walking in the hall.”
Cpl. Michael Fuller is a team player.
An athlete all through high school, he took on a career in law enforcement to work with others toward a shared goal.
“The camaraderie, the teamwork aspect of things,” Fuller said of why he became a police officer. “Being a part of something.”
Today, as a corporal with the St. Albans Police Department, he’s part of a team whose mission at its core is to keep people safe and to enforce local laws.
But in his decade on the job, he’s seen his to-do list grow and grow.
“Law enforcement has gotten to the point where we’re expected to solve everybody’s problems, and that’s just not reasonable,” he said.
At the Swanton Police Department, Sgt. Tyler Badeau agrees. He’s been in the field for 15 years and seen police change how they use force and deal with mental health crises.
“It's gone from law enforcement to social worker,” he said.
Because of the culture and the communities’ changing needs, both the St. Albans and Swanton departments say their current staffing levels are no longer adequate.
Between Jan. 1, 2023 and the time of his December Messenger interview, Fuller had responded to 739 calls, ranging from traffic violations to domestic disturbances to robberies. For each of those incidents, there’s reporting to be done and paperwork to fill out. Fuller said he needs about 12 uninterrupted hours to catch up on his backlog – a swath of time he knows he’ll never get, because there are too many other tasks to do.
“We are fully-staffed, but that fully-staffed is also minimally-staffed,” Badeau said of the Swanton department. “If someone were to call out tonight, there would be one officer for 64 square miles. Not only is that not safe, you’ll burn your employees out.”
Leslie McCoy began working as a wellness counselor at the Fairfax Health Center after leaving her 27-year-long military career.
In the army, she mentally prepared raw recruits for the difficulties of basic training and the anxiety that comes with a new career in the military. Now, she’s helping people tackle the realities of Vermont life.
Post COVID-19 pandemic, it seems that everything just got a lot harder.
“I do think COVID really kind of — I don’t want to say messed people up – but it really changed how people view and interact with the world,” McCoy said. “There’s a lot of agoraphobia – people not really wanting to leave their home… A lot of people being cut off from others and just feeling that loneliness. It's still showing in some clients, and in maybe some of the younger and teens, maybe a little less self esteem, confidence – of course technology doesn’t help.”
On average, McCoy is scheduled to see seven people a day, referred to her through various channels. Sometimes, it’s a patient seeing their physician next door, but she also gets private referrals from those out in the community. Clients have ranged in ages from nine to 96.
Her advice for many is to focus on what they can change, because the societal issues aren’t going to magically go away. Economic trends don’t turn on a dime, and Vermont’s affordability crisis has already been a problem for decades.
Financial anxieties, however, are driving more and more her way.
“We have people who are hungry. We have people who are afraid they’re not going to be able to afford their rent next month. … Seeing people struggle and suffer, it’s really hard,” McCoy said. “I do wish I could do more for people. Sometimes, I feel like my hands are tied just because of how the social services in Vermont are right now.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here