Gutilla still seeking home detention

Posted

ST. ALBANS — A forthcoming state law is complicating Carmen Guttilla’s motion for home detention.

Prosecutors have charged Guttilla with first-degree murder for allegedly aiding her daughter, Erika, in murdering Troy Ford, whose remains walkers discovered on an abandoned playground in Highgate in early May.

The Vermont Department of Corrections (DOC) has held Guttilla without bail since her arrest then.

In late May, Guttilla’s defense team, St. Johnsbury-based attorneys David Sleigh and Kyle Hatt, filed a motion for Guttilla to be incarcerated at her Highgate residence rather than the Chittenden Regional Correctional Facility in South Burlington.

That arrangement is known as home detention. And it’s exactly how it sounds. The DOC would supervise Guttilla’s incarceration at her home rather than in prison.

Guttilla’s home detention application requests the DOC allow her to leave home for court appointments and for work at North Side Beverage in Swanton, where she worked up until the evening Vermont State Police (VSP) detectives arrested her.

The fact that Guttilla’s application requests she be allowed to go to work does not imply that North Side Beverage still employs or will still employ her.

State prosecutors oppose the motion.

One key issue on the State’s part is that Guttilla’s Highgate home was allegedly the scene of the murder.

Judge Martin Maley presided over a hearing on the motion in court here Monday afternoon.

Maley must determine Guttilla is legally eligible for home detention before the court passes her application to the DOC.

But the legislature may have made that decision for him.

The House and Senate passed H.728 during this legislative session. The bill amends Vermont’s bail laws.

A provision on the bill’s 13th page says “a defendant held without bail… shall not be eligible for release to the Home Detention Program on or after June 1, 2018.”

Despite that date the bill doesn’t go into effect until July 1.

Once it does, however, Guttilla would seem to be legally ineligible for home detention.

“That would certainly be our position,” state prosecutor John Lavoie said in court here yesterday.

“And not ours,” Sleigh fired back, participating via speakerphone.

Sleigh said the Franklin County court’s home detention procedure — a preliminary hearing, a ruling and then the DOC’s determination of eligibility — is “idiosyncratic” compared to home detention procedures in other counties.

He said Franklin County’s procedure delays the process and in light of that fact urged the court to move the matter forward as rapidly as possible.

Maley agreed to do so.

Although yesterday’s hearing was preliminary, Lavoie summarized prosecutors’ stance.

A judge has to consider the nature of the offense when mulling over a home detention application.

In this case, Lavoie said, Guttilla provided the murder weapon and said she would have murdered Ford if her daughter didn’t.

“This was a deliberate act with some pre-planning,” Lavoie said.

Lavoie said Guttilla also attempted to cover up the crime by hiding Ford’s body. First in a six-foot dumpster on the family’s back porch and then on the abandoned playground down the road.

Sleigh called Lavoie’s assertions “specious.”

“His argument will basically be that anybody charged with murder is not eligible for home detention,” Sleigh said. “That’s clearly not true.”

Sleigh also jabbed Lavoie over the way Lavoie stated the facts of the case.

Sleigh said Lavoie’s “re-reading [the court affidavit] in the light most favorable to him” was “unimportant.”

Lavoie didn’t take this sitting down because he was standing up — next to the speakerphone so Sleigh could hear him.

But he didn’t fire back. Just restated the State’s position and saved the argument for an as-yet-unscheduled future hearing.

Guttilla did not speak while in the courtroom. That’s not unusual. Defense attorneys generally instruct their clients not to speak lest they compound the defense’s legal procedure.

Guttilla was transported back to the Chittenden Regional Correctional Facility.

Her daughter is also incarcerated there. Maley ordered Erika not to speak to Guttilla during their incarceration.

Erika and Corey Cassani, who allegedly helped her dispose of Ford’s remains, are due in court here Tuesday, July 17, for status conferences in their respective cases.

To subscribe to the Messenger call 802.524.9771 ext. 101.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here