Georgia teacher on trial for sexual assault; Prosecution, defense gives opening remarks

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — “I said ‘what happened?’ and she said ‘Toof.’”

Almost three years after this exchange between a mother and daughter, former Georgia school teacher Matthew Toof is getting his day in court.

Day 1 of Toof’s criminal trial on Wednesday covered a portion of the personal dramas of those involved, presenting a hard-to-hear history of what Toof allegedly did to groom a Georgia student over a series of years to the Franklin County jury.  

Both the victim and victim’s mother took the witness stand on the first day to give their versions of the story. 

The trial, however, is scheduled to extend over five days at the Franklin County courthouse, as Toof’s defense attorney, Robert Kaplan, is expected to attempt to convince the jury the victim’s story was crafted to discredit Toof following a contentious non-sexual relationship.

(Editor’s Note: The Messenger does not publish the names of sexual abuse victims, alleged or not. The victim’s mother’s name has also been omitted due to potential identifying information.)

Opening statements

Arrested back in Dec. 2021, Matthew Toof is being charged with aggravated repeated sexual assault on a child, as well as lewd and lascivious conduct with a child, while he worked as a math teacher at Georgia Elementary and Middle School.

Out of the two felonies, the more serious charge could result in 25 years to life imprisonment, and a $50,0000 fine.

Starting Wednesday, Sept. 11, Toof’s trial opened at around 1:30 p.m. with contrasting opening statements from defense attorney Robert Kaplan and deputy state’s attorney Diane Wheeler.

“This case is about betrayal. Betrayal of trust of the community, of a school community, of a family and specifically of a student,” Wheeler said. “What she learned and what she found is that she was treated differently than some of the other children.”

During her opening statement, Wheeler explained to the jury how they would hear more details about the relationship curated by Toof, as well as the special treatment he gave to the victim, inviting her to lunch in his classroom, or walking her to the bus stop.

But as the friendship grew and Toof gained more access to the victim’s home via a relationship with her mother, Wheeler said Toof betrayed that trust with repeated sexual acts that eventually led to the rape of the child.

She also told the jury they’d learn more about what was happening at Georgia Elementary and Middle School as Toof groomed a student, and why the relationship developed as it did with so many teachers around.

“You will be able to find beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant, Matthew Toof, engaged in repeated sexual acts with (the victim. … And that was part of his plan to satisfy his own lustful sexual desires,” Wheeler said.

In comparison, the defense’s tactic centered around disproving the victim’s allegations, categorizing them as the result of a maelstrom of teenage angst and envy attached to the victim’s changing relationship with Toof. 

“This is a case that is a lot more complicated in terms of the interactions between the people than the state has suggested,” Kaplan said. 

To make his point during his opening statement, Kaplan recapped a string of complicated backs-and-forths that revolved around the changing relationship status of Toof as his marriage fell apart in 2018. 

As for the victim’s allegations, Kaplan labeled them as “extraordinary.” 

To succeed in the trial, the defense effectively needs to cast enough reasonable doubt on the truth of each individual scene described by the victim, while explaining a possible motivation for the victim to come forward. 

Kaplan said her “horrific” allegations were first made to hurt Toof, effectively setting off a community-wide “firestorm” of attention as a result.

“At that point, there’s no way back for [her] on any of the things that she said,” Kaplan said.

Afternoon testimony

The rest of the day’s testimony featured two retellings of Toof’s relationship with the family in the years previous to the victim’s confession, which was made at the tail end of 2021.

According to the victim’s testimony, she had met Toof as an 11-year-old student at Georgia Elementary and Middle School back in April 2016 when Toof was her math teacher, and the sexual abuse began soon afterward with inappropriate touching in the classroom. 

Toof began a relationship with the victim’s mother about a year later, and the resulting affair – both Toof and the victim’s mother were married at the time – was something of an open secret in the Georgia school community.

During this period, the victim said Toof became a more important person within the family, but he continued to initiate sexual acts with her, such as putting his hands down her pants and grinding, in secret.

Despite the abuse, the victim said she also grew closer to Toof over time. She explained during her testimony that she still had complex feelings toward the defendant almost three years after she first revealed the alleged history of his sexual abuses to her mother.

But she felt it was still necessary to report what had happened. 

“It hurts me to do this, but then there’s a part of me that’s passed beyond. And he knew that it was going to happen. But I’m also angry that he did this to me. I’m upset because there’s a lot of my life that I kind of just gave away to him,” she said. “And so yeah, there’s just a mix of feelings.”

The victim’s mother also gave testimony to the jury Wednesday, and she explained how the allegations blind-sided her at a time when she thought he was just acting as a good dad would to her children.

“I thought it was fatherly at the time, just very affectionate, loving, kind of like a father would be,” the victim’s mother said.

The victim’s mother started a relationship with Toof in 2017, but much of the couple’s excitement disappeared by the fall of the following year. After a few summer vacations where Toof played the proverbial father-figure within the family, the victim’s mother eventually discovered that he had another affair with a third woman. 

Despite the family rupture, Toof and the victim continued to see each other, leading to three more years of alleged abuse before the victim’s mother knew what was happening.

“It’s horrible,” the victim’s mother said in reference to her daughter. “But on the other hand, I think of it as she was trying to protect me. That was the first thing that she said that day that she told me – that she didn’t want to hurt me.” 

Toof’s trial is scheduled to extend into next week, with a jury determination expected next Thursday, Sept. 19.

#sanl

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here