ST. ALBANS — A Georgia Elementary School teacher has been charged with sexually assaulting a minor.
Franklin County Sheriff deputies arrested Matthew Toof, 39, on Wednesday after law enforcement investigated complaints of sexual assault earlier in the week.
Toof is in custody at Northwest Correctional Center and is being held without bail. He was charged with aggravated sexual assault and lewd and laviscivious conduct with a child.
Law enforcement said allegations lodged against Toof span a six-year-period — from 2016 to 2021 — when Toof was a school teacher.
At a Dec. 12 emergency Georgia Board of School Directors meeting, 50 Georgia parents turned out to let their concerns be known about the former administration, who they said shrugged away complaints about Toof in the past.
Parents told board members, Interim Superintendent John Tague and GEMS principals they are scared for students who are currently attending the school.
Toof also coached the Bellows Free Academy-St. Albans boys basketball team for close to a decade before leaving the position this fall.
Multiple reports about Toof’s behavior had been filed with the Department for Children and Families (DCF) before his arrest last Wednesday, according to court records. Court documents lay out how teachers had seen Toof behaving inappropriately with a minor as far back as 2016, but earlier reports did not meet the criteria for Chapter 49 of sexual abuse, which include criminal acts that involve sexual molestation or exploitation of a child.
Georgia parents at the Dec. 12 meeting said DCF failed by dismissing complaints about Toof from individuals who were not the victim, according to a Dec. 13 WCAX article.
Officers interviewed the victim of Toof’s alleged behavior Tuesday, who stated in an affidavit that he had been “grooming” her since at least sixth grade, which aligned with earlier DCF reports.
Det. Sgt. Mark S. Lauer’s affidavit provides details on the Tuesday interview with the victim, which laid out a detailed pattern of sexual behaviors – which include rape – occurring over a six-year-period while Toof acted from a trusted position. Deputies arrested him the day after the interview occurred.
If proven guilty of repeated aggravated sexual assault with a child, Toof could be sentenced to 25 years to life in prison and fined up to $50,000. The penalty for the second charge, lewd and lascivious conduct with a child, is two to 15 years in prison and fined up to $5,000.
Toof’s next appearance in court, a bail hearing, is scheduled for Wednesday, Dec. 15. He is being represented by public defender Rosanna Chase.
A Dec. 10 statement provided to the Messenger from Franklin West Supervisory Union Superintendent John Tague reads that the district learned of the arrest on Dec. 8. They will be cooperating with law enforcement and supporting children and families.
“Student safety is always the district’s highest priority,” the statement reads.
At the emergency meeting, the GEMS board voted to direct Tague to create a procedure to ensure that any report that involves inappropriate behavior by a staff member involving a student be reported to the building administration and superintendent, according to draft meeting minutes.
Editor's Note: This story will be updated as more information becomes available. Latest update: 6:13 p.m. Dec. 13. Staff Writer Alek Fleury contributed reporting.