GEORGIA – The coalition of Georgia, Northwest Regional Planning Commission (NRPC) and Vermont Agency of Transportation (VTrans) officials penning an infrastructure plan for Georgia’s South Village Zoning District held their second public hearing last Wednesday, inviting residents to comment and vote on different layouts that coalition’s planning process had imagined for the district.
As residents of the South Village filed into the Georgia Elementary and Middle School’s gymnasium, they were handed remotes that would allow them to cast votes for different aspects of the Georgia South Village Master Transportation Plan, the official name of the district’s infrastructure plan.
VTrans was absent that night, but town and NRPC officials were on hand with representatives from VHB, the South Burlington-based engineering firm contracted to handle the technical drafting of the plan.
“None of this is going to happen quickly, but it’s excellent to get everybody here together and talk about the pros and cons of each plan,” said selectperson Steve Lamos, one of two selectboard members on the committee. “So, when we finally do implement it years down the road, it’ll be what everybody wanted – or as much of what everybody wanted as it could be.”
Most of the night’s discussion was led by VHB Managing Director David Saladino.
“The overall goal of the project is to identify a plan that gets the town closer to the vision that was established earlier in 2009 in the overall South Village Strategic Plan,” Saladino said. “[We’re] looking at dense future development, accessibility and livable, walkable space in the village.”
He explained that their current work is pulling from an array of studies in the past, primarily the 2009 strategic plan for the district but also pedestrian and wastewater plans previously drafted for the town. While some of those plans extended across the whole of Georgia, Saladino noted that much of that work was focused on the South Village – a district extending from Interstate-89’s intersection with Route 7 and stretching to the Georgia-Milton town line.
“Our charge is not to make this another plan to put on a shelf,” Saladino said. “It’s visionary – it’s looking out 20, 30, 40 years – but if you don’t have that established, it’s harder to make those short-term decisions without knowing what the long-term goal is for the region.”
Saladino started with the district’s layout, pitching a pair of plans that either consolidated development along Route 7 itself or spread that development to a road running parallel to Route 7. Both images prominently featured greenspace and imagined a development level on par with traditional downtowns.
Saladino also shared the immediate baseline improvements that would occur “regardless of where we end up” that addressed many of the original complaints levied by town residents and VTrans.
In those baseline improvements, the median near the Georgia Public Library was either shortened or completely removed, and a dedicated right-turn lane was added to the I-89 off ramp. Some problems with erosion were also addressed, and the right-turn slip-lane branching off 104A was removed.
Baseline improvements also included the extension of sidewalks along Route 7 and added a pedestrian crossing near Route 7’s intersection with Ballard Road.
“This will never be like a Burlington or big metro area, but it’s immediately adjacent to an interchange halfway between St. Albans and Burlington,” Saladino said. “There’s reasons to believe that things could happen over the next 20, 30 years… that promotes these goals.”
When turned over to a vote, about 24 percent of those present preferred the option that focused development off of Route 7 along a road that hypothetically ran parallel to the highway – a method that created a grid-like structure in the village and prevented Georgia from taking ownership of the district’s stretch of highway.
Another 15 percent said they’d prefer development centered on Route 7. The rest – the majority of those present – answered either “I’m not sure” or that they preferred neither.
Conversation then moved to the intersection with Ballard Road, one of several problematic intersections that VTrans had aimed to focus on with the study.
Baseline improvements for the road included the extension of a sidewalk wrapping north around the intersection’s corner and leading toward the Georgia House of Pizza. A crosswalk was added at the pizza place, linking the new sidewalk on Ballard Road to the sidewalk already paved near the Dollar General.
Two other alternatives were presented to residents, one that tightened the intersection and added lights – “making it a tighter crossing for pedestrians” – and another that added a roundabout, which Saladino admitted was the “kind of thing you either love or hate.”
“If you like the idea of roundabouts, there’s an opportunity to have a roundabout here and up at 104A… to bookend the village,” Saladino said, suggesting that, if the town committed to two roundabouts, it’d allow the village to “make a statement” to through traffic.
He added that, while current traffic loads didn’t necessarily warrant the need for a roundabout, additional development in the district could spur an increase of traffic that would ultimately make a roundabout practical.
Residents voted in favor of the first alternative, which tightened the intersection for pedestrian traffic and added lights to better control it.
Saladino then drifted the conversation toward what would likely be one of the more controversial discussions of the night: What to do about the Route 7 and Route 104A intersection, identified as a “high-crash location” by VTrans with enough traffic to make additional controls “fairly well warranted.”
According to VTrans, that intersection was currently ranked as the 83rd highest crash location in Vermont. Twenty-one crashes were reported at the intersection in the period of time observed in the study, NRPC’s Bethany Remmers reported. While there were no fatalities in those 21 accidents, four did result in minor injuries to those involved.
Georgia Fire Chief Keith Baker admitted that, while the fire department would occasionally be called to the intersection for accidents, they were rarely serious.
“I’m not saying it doesn’t happen there,” Baker told the audience. “It’s usually reasonably minor crashes.
“It’s a place we go to, but if you look at other places… I’m not sure it’s worse than other parts of town.”
Saladino introduced the default improvements to the intersection, which removed the slip-lane and islands in the intersection while also tightening the intersection and rerouting Route 104A to make it connect to Route 7 at a perpendicular angle to better control the passing traffic.
Those baseline improvements also saw sidewalk extend to an area just south of the intersection.
The two alternatives saw either the addition of a traffic light or the reconfiguration of the intersection as a roundabout, the latter of which found a noticeably loud champion in Georgia planning commissioner George Bilodeau.
“You won’t have a fender-bender at a roundabout,” Bilodeau said. During the first meeting for the Georgia South Village Master Transportation Plan, Bilodeau had passed out handouts asserting roundabouts’ ability to stymie traffic accidents, and he asserted later in the night that the current chaos at the Route 7 – Route 104A intersection “would be eliminated with a roundabout.”
Other residents were more skeptical, however, as they interrogated a vision for a roundabout with questions about maintenance during the wintertime and what kind of costs would be incurred by the installation of a roundabout.
While Saladino noted that lights in the intersection could lead to backups toward the interstate, he admitted that a roundabout would be far more expensive – a proper lighting fixture and realignment of 104A would cost an estimated $500,000, while a roundabout fell somewhere between $2 million and $2.5 million.
He added that some 10,000 cars passed through the intersection daily and hinted that further development would only lead to denser traffic.
When put to a vote, 19 residents voted in favor of a lighted intersection, while 11 favored the roundabout.
The next vote, which would decide how the Route 7 intersection with I-89 would be restructured, was decided almost immediately. When presented with alternatives that would either do nothing, signalize the northbound intersection and add a right turn lane, or realign the exit with Skunk Hill Road and branch the intersection’s on-ramp off Skunk Hill Road, residents overwhelming voted for the latter.
A final vote was held over the movement of the Georgia Park and Ride, which Saladino reported was already too small to handle the amount of use it saw.
But when presented with alternatives that either connected the Park and Ride to the nearby Maplefields’ parking lot, or an alternative that left the Park and Ride where it was, residents suggested a third alternative: should the interstate off-ramp be realigned with Skunk Hill Road, the Park and Ride could be moved north of the Maplefields to land currently occupied by the off-ramp.
This alternative, proposed by State Representative Carl Rosenquist (R – Georgia), would address residents’ concern that attaching the Park and Ride to Maplefields would favor Maplefields over local businesses further down Route 7.
Voters overwhelmingly voted in favor of moving the Park and Ride, with those in the audience voicing preference for Rosenquist’s suggestion that the Park and Ride be pushed north of Maplefields.
Since at least 2009, Georgia’s South Village has been viewed as the town’s growth center, a sentiment shared by town officials in the weeks leading into the first public hearing for the village’s Master Transportation Plan earlier this April.
VTrans has also signaled out the area for its high volume of accidents, noting that, between 2012 and 2016, there were 90 accidents in the south village district. Because of this, VTrans, which currently maintains the highways bisecting the village, awarded NRPC the $50,000 grant that funded most of the current transportation study.
A finalized plan is scheduled for September or October, with a public presentation planned for November.
To subscribe to the Messenger call 802.524.9771 ext. 101.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here