Franklin West Supervisory Union weighs decision to form a district

Posted

FAIRFAX/GEORGIA/FLETCHER — Keep as a union or form a district? Franklin West Supervisory Union begins to seriously weigh its response to Act 73.

At a supervisory union meeting Oct. 14, board representatives from Fairfax, Georgia and Fletcher — the three schools that form the union — sat down to learn what the effects on each town would be if they were to merge into one district. 

If the schools choose to combine, the district could see $8 million dollars stay in local pockets. 

“The intent of the presentation was to just present all three boards with possibilities surrounding Act 73,” FWSU superintendent John Tague said. “Area school boards are making resolutions and sharing them to the task force saying ‘Here’s what we think would be a good final solution for our school.” 

Enacted back in July, Act 73 establishes a process for Vermont to transform its public education system so it features larger school districts and a statewide tax rate. The bill also established the School District Redistricting Task Force to recommend new district boundaries and configurations to the legislature. 

This isn’t the first time this year FWSU has put its finger on the touchy subject. Back in April, the idea of transitioning to a school district was brought up as the legislature worked through the remaining pieces of Act 73. Then again in September the boards touched on the idea before longer conversations in October. 

Vermont’s local boards are running into a deadline if they want to get a resolution into the task force’s hands, however. 

The redistricting taskforce has a Dec. 1 finish line when they must turn over their recommendations to the legislature. That means Fairfax, Fletcher and Georgia school boards have to weigh the pros and cons and come to a consensus together at the next supervisory union meeting Nov. 19.

Pros and cons

Tague said the estimated $8 million in savings by becoming a school district comes from not having to pay tuition anymore. 

Sending students from Fletcher and Georgia to high schools around the state costs a lot. The Georgia and Fletcher boards have both seen tuition hikes take up sizable portions of their budget in recent years.

Georgia especially felt the effects last year when tuition increases counted for 40% of their fiscal year 26 budget increases. 

“The original point was it’s something they might want to consider,” Tague said. “If I know how to spend less money, it’s my responsibility to share with the boards so they can use that to figure out how they govern their schools.” 

Still, moving from a supervisory union to a district holds a host of sticking points. 

For one, the idea of school choice would be eliminated. All Fletcher and all Georgia students would head to BFA-Fairfax for their high school years. 

“Staying a supervisory union would maintain choice for folks in Georgia and Fletcher. That is the biggest reason that people would oppose that situation,” Tague said. “Many people move to Georgia for the school system … and similar for Fletcher. Eliminating that choice is potentially loss of local control.”

But, with all the uncertainty around Act 73 and what it means for the three Franklin County schools, Tague said getting a voice in now is important. 

“My belief is that choice will change if we get to place new districts and new structures,” he said. “This would be an opportunity to define what that change would look like.”

Other potential pros and cons come in restructuring the district and expenses. 

In Tague’s preliminary numbers, there’s still an unknown in special education costs, technical centers, transportation contracts and federal grants. Fletcher and Georgia could be converted to host a different set of grades, for example, opening up more academic and co-curricular opportunities for an increased student population. But Fairfax’s high school could face space limitations as it welcomes more students to its campus. 

As conversations flow through the local board, there are some anxieties in the Fairfax camp as well, with clerk Matt Hogan saying his town is between a rock and a hard place. 

“Fairfax feels like we're in a difficult spot because we'd be essentially saying you have to give up school choice and that's a big part of the people who move to those towns for,” he said. “As a Fairfax resident, I don’t think I should say to Fletcher or Georgia you need to give up and come to my school for high school.” 

If the other two towns shoot down the proposal to merge, Hogan said the school is in the same situation it was last year and the year before with tough to swallow budgets. 

Still, Tague told the Messenger, with so much in the dark, it’s an almost impossible decision to choose what’s best going forward. 

The potential new district maps posed by the task force are all over the place for FWSU. The map that groups schools by technical education centers for example, throws Fairfax and Fletcher into Chittenden County classifications, but it could all end up moot. 

“There’s possibilities they do all of this work as a task force and then end up with no decision, no changes made or possibly there’s a drastic change made,” Tague said. 

Until the maps are presented by the legislature, and Montpellier determines where things end up, Tague said FWSU will continue to carry on the way they have. 

“There’s so many potential possibilities it would be hard for any school district to say we’re married to this proposal,” he said.

act 73, school district, franklin west supervisory union, school choice

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here