Franklin split on eve of school vote

Posted

FRANKLIN — An informational meeting in Franklin Tuesday night dwelled on worst case scenarios as the town contended with the fact that, pending the closure of Franklin Central School (FCS), there were no formal analyses informing the closure and no plans in motion to open an independent school in its place.

Voters from the Town of Franklin were recently asked to participate in a warned vote next week to potentially sell FCS’s assets to the town and convert the Franklin Town School District into a “non-operating school district” – a vote that would effectively close FCS as a public school.

Tuesday’s informational meeting was warned to provide a background for the upcoming vote and allow the school board to answer the questions those articles spurred in the preceding month, with school board chair Bob Berger warning early on that “some answers may not exist.”

Berger, speaking for the board, led the presentation with questions related to the first article: “Shall the legal voters of the Franklin School District sell all the Franklin Town School District’s assets to the Town of Franklin?”

Berger explained that, as of this moment, there had been no study examining the financial impact to Franklin’s taxpayers should the town take ownership of school property. He added that there hadn’t been any discussion related to the amount for the purchase or a clear identification of which assets would be included in a sale.

He said, however, that it would be the selectboard that would take over as the public body “in charge of caring for and raising revenue to support the school building,” meaning that costs related to the building would ultimately fall on the town.

An agreement with an independent school leasing the property could lead to some shared governance, but like any other relationship between a landlord and renter, some of the maintenance and management would still fall on the town as the rightful owners of the building.

“Any agreements between the town and a future entity using the building are speculative at this point in time,” Berger told the audience. “The short answer is: We don’t know.”

Berger also explained that, should the district’s assets be sold to the town, Franklin would assume sole responsibility of the building.

Meanwhile, the sale of town assets would not prevent the forced consolidation of Missisquoi Valley Union (MVU) High School’s member districts of Franklin, Highgate and Swanton, meaning that Franklin taxpayers may still have to help financially support school assets in Swanton and Highgate but would receive no financial help from those towns for maintaining Franklin’s school building.

“Therefore, the Town of Franklin would be solely responsible for the costs for its school, and in addition share in the costs of the other schools,” Berger read.

While the Franklin selectboard has largely been supportive of efforts to stonewall a state-mandated merger, members expressed some reservations over the fact that the town hadn’t properly explored the financial impacts of assuming ownership over FCS’s assets.

Others expressed discomfort with the lack of information in general.

“I can say, as the selectboard, we’ve talked about the property transfer… and there’s a lot of uncertainty,” selectboard chair Peter Magnant admitted. “We’ve got less than a month and we don’t know the ramifications.”

Magnant reiterated his support for keeping Franklin independent of a merger, saying that a consolidated school board split between Franklin, Highgate and Swanton would lack the same motivation for maintaining Franklin’s past high performance.

“The more I hear about things, the more I’m concerned,” selectperson and MVU teacher Brooks Sturtevant said. “I think we should slow things down for a little bit.”

The second article warned for an Oct. 2 vote would convert the Franklin Town School District into a non-operating school district, closing FCS as a public school and authorizing the school board to tuition its students to any other public or private school of their parents’ choosing.

Berger warned that there’s nothing in place that would require parents to tuition to an independent school in Franklin.

While a school board would still exist in a non-operating school district, its sole responsibilities would be to build a budget for taxpayers to vote on. That budget, Berger explained, would be based on tuition charged for Franklin students and assessments from the supervisory union for the costs of special education and business functions.

Even if the Town of Franklin would vote against such a budget, Berger said they’d have to pay it anyway, as they’re required to pay tuition for the district’s students.

“The bills still need to be paid,” he said.

The school board would have no legal influence over the policies of the schools it tuitions to, and Franklin wouldn’t have a place on their school boards, leading Berger to warn the audience that “we would not have any representation on that board for your children.”

If an independent school was opened, there’s no guarantee it’d be beholden to the people the way a public school board is.

An independent school would be governed by an unelected board of trustees that isn’t subject to open meeting laws or public record laws, which means, Berger read, that “any decision by the private board of directors can be made without the opportunity for public input and in a meeting that is not open to the public.”

Berger also noted that that board of trustees wouldn’t be required to provide special education services until 2022 and wouldn’t have to participate in federal free and reduced-price meal programs.

There’s also no mandate requiring an independent school to enroll every student in its respective town.

Franklin resident and former MVU school board chair Jay Denault responded by explaining that it would be possible to incorporate an independent school in Franklin as a non-profit organization that names “every single resident of Franklin a member,” therefore giving them control to appoint the board of trustees.

Berger countered that this was “speculating on a nonexistent entity,” as no one in Franklin’s community has yet to step forward to lead the effort and provide resources needed to open an independent school in FCS’s place.

He added that the school board and supervisory union could play no part in that process, as they were forbidden from doing so as public officials.

The process of opening an independent school

Tuesday’s presentation included a brief walkthrough of the incorporation of a school, something the Executive Director of Vermont’s Independent Schools Association reportedly describes as “an extraordinarily difficult process.”

Berger, reading off the slide, said “the process takes at least a year and… your school will not be the same little school you have now.”

The process would have to be led by “strong private community commitment, expertise and funding,” which, Berger noted, was still absent in conversations relative to Franklin.

“None of the resources available to public schools would be available to start up,” Berger read. “Private fundraising would be needed. They would need to have their own attorney, headmaster and business office functions.”

An independent school would need approval by the State Board of Education before it could receive tuition, Berger explained.

In the case of Franklin, that process would likely require a legal challenge against the state, as, according to Berger, the State Board of Education likely wouldn’t accept Franklin’s coming vote to convert its district into a non-operating school district this close to the issuance of its state consolidation plan.

Because the State Board of Education was tasked with building a state merger plan based on a school district’s present status, as opposed to a potential future status, it would still consider Franklin Town School District a public school district.

This means that, should the State Board of Education follow through on the recommended consolidation of MVU’s member districts, Franklin would still be required to merge.

A lawsuit filed over recognizing an independent school in Franklin would be a separate legal challenge from the class-action lawsuit Franklin is currently signed on to, Berger warned, meaning another set of legal expenses and challenges.

Several of those in attendance noted that selling school assets to the town could jeopardize Franklin’s place in that class-action lawsuit, which challenges Act 46 over the fact that forcing a town to cede school assets to a unified school district would be in violation of the state and federal constitutions’ Taking Clause.

Berger also warned that, should the town follow through on closing FCS but fail to have an independent school approved by the State Board of Education, “the town would still be responsible for maintaining the building.”

Those expenses would be on top of the tuition paid by Franklin to other schools.

Teachers employed in an independent school would no longer be considered public school teachers, meaning they’d lose access to Vermont Teachers’ Retirement and health insurance.

Longtime teachers paying into the state’s retirement plan “would stand to lose that benefit,” and Berger warned that he doubted teachers would fare as well on the private health insurance exchange as they had under the statewide health insurance plan.

Denault argued that it’d be possible to draft a healthcare and retirement plan for teachers at an independent school.

An independent school would not be required to keep FCS’s current staff, nor would it have to require its teachers have a license or be experienced in their relevant field.

Despite closing FCS, Franklin’s students would still attend MVU for secondary education, meaning that “Franklin secondary students would still be part of a merged district,” Berger warned.

An approved independent school would not be able eligible for federal grants, though it could still receive funds for special education, Berger explained.

Response from the town

Sentiments from Franklin residents were split between pursuing an independent school and slowing the process down.

Proponents of incorporating FCS argued that this was more of an “insurance policy” than a guarantee that Franklin would close its school, suggesting that, because of the 2020 deadline noted in the upcoming articles, they’d have time to double back should the State Board of Education decide to not pursue a merger or should Act 46 be successfully challenged.

They also expressed they were more comfortable with “placing their eggs in several baskets,” as Franklin resident Jim Jewett suggested.

Others, such as resident Pam Greene, said they were voting on the measure to “send a statement to the state.”

Still, others present voiced reservations with how rushed the proceedings seemed, stating they weren’t comfortable with what seemed like a greater loss of control over their school than they’d experience under a forced consolidation of MVU’s districts.

“I’m pretty sure that the biggest concern with Act 46… has been about losing control,” Tom Gates observed. “What I just saw from this presentation is that we’re going to give up even more control… by going the independent route.”

School board member Devin Bachelor asked that residents consider the message they’d be sending to their current staff at FCS, who would have no guarantee of an independent school replacing FCS should voters agree to close the school.

“I think the rational, reasonable person would start to look around,” Bachelor suggested. “I fear the damage will be done… and that the cost of this particular tactic is too high.”

Berger said at least one staff person has asked for a letter of reference to use while searching for a new job.

Area farmer Tim Magnant concurred, adding that the decision to close the school could seem like Franklin was “turning their backs on our allies” in Swanton, Highgate and Sheldon, all of whom have protested their respective mergers recommended by the Agency of Education.

“It would be counterproductive for us to turn our backs and not work with those communities,” Magnant said. “We need to keep that in mind.”

Stay informed. Be involved. Subscribe to the Messenger.

Additional reading:

Franklin joins Act 46 lawsuit

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here