Franklin County educators oppose Senate education bill; Lawmakers go back to drawing board

Posted

ST. ALBANS — Franklin County educators are largely opposed to the Senate’s version of a bill that seeks to transform Vermont’s education system. 

In a letter to the community this week, all four of the county’s superintendents said the bill “does little to address the core drivers of skyrocketing costs.” 

“Until our elected officials demonstrate the courage to confront these fundamental cost drivers and craft equitable solutions, we're simply rearranging the deck chairs on a sinking ship,” John Tague, Lynn Cota, Bill Kimball and Julie Regimbal wrote. “Our children deserve better than this political charade.”  

Educators in the Maple Run Unified School District swiftly signed on to the letter too, adding their names to a copy hanging in the district boardroom. 

“It really touches me that the staff would rally this support after the letter the four superintendents wrote together,” Superintendent Bill Kimball said. “I am so grateful to work with my Franklin County colleagues to support students.” 

Other education leaders across Vermont reacted adversely as well, leading to Senate President Pro Tempore Phil Baruth (D/P-Burlington) making a series of procedural moves Thursday morning that brought the House version of the bill to the Senate floor instead. Senators are spending the afternoon making amendments to the bill. 

Rep. Casey Toof (R-St. Albans Town), who sits on the House Education Committee, said the bill — H. 454 — has seen many changes since it left his committee in late March. But more are still needed for it to garner his support. 

“Two things for me, and I’ve been pretty open about this with my colleagues. We need a foundation formula set, and we need some sort of timeline that has maps by next January,” he told the Messenger Thursday morning. 

“The governor had a proposal. The House changed it. The Senate changed it. And now I don’t know what it’s going to look like,” he added. 

The bill, as being considered Thursday, proposes massive changes to Vermont’s school governance and finance systems that would phase in over multiple years, including school district consolidation, class-size minimums and the creation of a new foundation funding formula.

The Senate version had quickened the transition to the new funding method and given the power of drawing district lines to lawmakers. 

“The House proposed an experienced and skilled subcommittee… to guide the drawing of new school district boundaries. The Senate replaced this with an all-legislator task force, lacking the essential expertise and politicizing an evidence-based process,” Franklin County’s superintendents wrote in their letter. “The absence of educator voices in this bill draft is a serious concern.”  

The superintendents also opposed the Senate’s funding formula, which would have increased funding for all of Franklin County's school districts, except Maple Run. However, residents in those districts could have seen tax increases of up to 30%. 

“This approach will force some schools to make deep cuts, eliminating valuable programs for students,” the superintendents wrote. 

While Toof said he appreciates the work of Franklin County’s superintendents, changes to the education system have to be made this year. And those changes should reflect what’s best for students and taxpayers, not necessarily those at the top. 

“It’s got to be students, taxpayers and then you worry about the rest,” he said. 

At his weekly press conference Wednesday, Gov. Phil Scott urged legislators to get a version of the bill to the point of a conference committee to work out disagreements. A conference committee includes three representatives from the House and three Senators. 

The bill would then come back to both chambers for final votes. Scott said he would use his power to call legislators back into session after they’ve adjourned for the year if they do not pass an education reform bill first. 

education reform, franklin county, school districts

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here