Four Girls Dairy in Fairfax is Vermont's 2025 Dairy Farm of the Year

Posted

FAIRFAX — Ask dairyman Peter Rainville what’s most important to him and he will say family. There’s no denying that he loves his cows almost as much, but to him, family comes first. That’s why he continually strives to improve the efficiency and sustainability of his farming operation to create a better work-life balance.

It’s something that resonated with the judges for the 2025 Vermont Dairy Farm of the Year award and led to his selection as this year’s recipient of this prestigious honor. They also cited his well-managed herd and adoption of innovative technology among the reasons this farm was chosen.

The 55-year-old father of four daughters is the sole proprietor of the aptly named Four Girls Dairy in Fairfax, Vermont. The bucolic 247-acre hill farm is a standout with its well-maintained barns and tidy farmyard, “curb appeal” that impressed the judges who noted that “the entire farm is clean and welcoming, which is a great representation of dairy to the community.”

University of Vermont (UVM) Extension and the Vermont Dairy Industry Association present this award annually to an exemplary dairy farm, in cooperation with the New England Green Pastures Program. It recognizes a farm that demonstrates overall excellence in dairying through its quality milk production; outstanding pasture, crop and herd management; and sustainable environmental practices, among other criteria. The winner is selected by a committee comprised of past award winners.

According to UVM Extension’s Whitney Hull, the awards program coordinator, seeing that a small farm can be successful made an impact on the judges who viewed it as a model to potentially attract a younger generation interested in dairy farming. Although only Ashley, Rainville’s youngest daughter, still lives on the farm, her sisters Sarah, Marie and Hannah all live close by and help out on the farm whenever they can as they are passionate about keeping the farm going for the next generation.

“Peter and his family work extremely hard to produce top quality milk by paying attention to detail of both the cows and equipment and are always looking for opportunities to improve all aspects of the farm,” adds Rebecca Manning, a project manager at Ben & Jerry’s, who nominated the farm for the award. She has known Rainville since the early 2000s when she farmed with her family in Swanton.

The Franklin County farmer grew up on a dairy farm, developing a love for farming and a strong work ethic at an early age. He farmed first with his parents and brother in the town of Georgia, six miles up the road.

In 2000, Rainville and his growing family moved away from his family’s dairy farm and bought what was known as Homestead Farm from his aunt and uncle. The farm dates back in the Rainville family to 1945 when his grandparents bought the farm when they emigrated from Bedford, Quebec, Canada. The uncle who sold him the farm was one of 15 children (the youngest of whom was his father) raised on the farm that is now known as Four Girls Dairy.

Although fluctuating milk prices, environmental concerns and changing consumer preferences can make it difficult for a dairy farmer to stay profitable, it is the unexpected situations that can really challenge a farm. 

For Rainville, it was an early morning fire in April 2008 that tested his resilience. It destroyed the tie-barn where 86 cows were housed, killing 48 of the animals.

“My emotions were all over the place,” Rainville says, but admits that it was a turning point.

Although a setback, he did not want to give up farming so took time to assess the situation and decide how best to move forward. First, he relocated the surviving cows to his cousins’ farm so he could continue to milk them there. Later, after making the difficult decision to sell the herd, he spent six months visiting farms in Pennsylvania, New York, Wisconsin and Quebec to observe and learn from other operations.

One thing that stuck with him was how many of these farms embraced new technology, employing automated milking systems or milking robots to reduce labor and free up time for other farm work and family. Although his farm is small in comparison to most farms using robotics--he milks only 60 cows—Rainville felt that the financial investment would be worth it.

However, it was something his mother said at the time that helped cement his decision.

“She asked me, ‘do you want to live or live in the barn?’,” Rainville recalls, noting that “the decision to go with automatic milkers allowed me to not miss the girls’ games and school events. The cows are always milking. I don’t need to be in the barn. If something goes wrong, I get a phone call.”

His adaptation and adoption of technology on the farm also impressed the judging committee. “Peter would be the first to admit he was skeptical about putting in robots,” one judge commented. “He would say that he started as a tech skeptic, but he’s now a convert and advocate.”

In 2009, he purchased a Lely Astronaut A3 milking robot from local Lely dealer Paul Godin, the first one sold in Vermont, which helped establish a dealership in the state. It was installed that summer in his new 180-ft. x 78-ft. free-stall barn that replaced the old tie-barn that burned. 

The system has not only minimized milking time and labor, but helps with recordkeeping and management decisions as it collects data on lactation, udder health, number of milking visits, total daily milk production and other statistics on each individual cow.

“The cows are less stressed and not nervous,” he says. “They can go in to get milked whenever they want. Some cows get milked twice a day, others five times.”

His cows, primarily Holsteins, consistently average 80 pounds of milk a day for a rolling herd average of 24,000 pounds. Butterfat is 4.5 percent and protein, 3.3 percent. The farm ships its milk to the Dairy Farmers of America Cooperative in St. Albans, earning premiums and numerous milk quality awards over the years.

His forward-thinking approach to dairying also led him to enroll in Ben & Jerry’s Caring Dairy program in 2011 when it launched. The program supports the implementation of innovative solutions on dairy farms that promote animal care and mitigate the environmental and climate-related impacts of dairy farming. Participants work toward certification to the Global Animal Partnership animal care standard, a high animal welfare standard for dairy, verified through third-party audits.

The farm underwent an audit with Novus International in 2024 to analyze cow comfort, facility design and management practices to identify what needed to be changed or improved.

“One of the biggest surprises was finding out that the cows were not lying down as much as I thought. The longer a cow lies down, the more comfortable she is,” he explains. “The more a cow is chewing her cud, the more milk she is making.”

The audit also indicated that more ventilation was needed in the free-stall barn, something that Rainville plans to address. He also changed the lighting in the barn for safety and the well-being and productivity of the cows. To enhance cow comfort, he widened and lengthened the stalls. He uses dry sawdust for bedding.

“Animals drive everything on the farm,” Hull notes, “so the question is how to support comfort. Every innovation drives that home.”

The dairy farmer raises his own replacements, working with Premium Select Sires to breed for the “total package” as he says—strong feet and legs and good teat placement for the robotic milking system.

Heifers are bred at 14 to 15 months though Rainville says that he considers the animal’s size more than actual age when making the decision to breed. He strives for a calving interval of 21 months.

Calves are fed colostrum for their first two feedings with one dose of Tri-Shield First, a colostrum-derived paste, to protect them from scours, a major cause of death in newborns and young calves. They are housed in individual outdoor hutches until weaned at 12 weeks, then put in an indoor pen with three or more calves for about a month before being moved into the first group of heifers.

The farm grows all its own forages, supplementing with purchased grain, including 120 acres of grass, yielding 3.5 to 4 tons of dry matter per acre and 45 acres of corn yielding approximately 20 tons of silage per acre. Cows are fed a PMR (partial mixed ration) of corn silage, haylage and grain with additional grain when they enter the robotic milker.

“I have enough land to support the crops to feed my herd,” Rainville says. “I don’t want to have to find feed.” However, he is always looking for ways to improve his forages. 

He’s worked with the UVM Extension Northwest Crops and Soils Team to increase the quality and quantity of his forage, focusing on improvement strategies in the field and the barn. The team currently is conducting an on-site trial to evaluate the impact of cutting height and harvest frequency on productivity of perennial forage stands.

“Through this collaboration he has pursued the recommendations of the group to mow grass higher and purchase a merger, increasing the health of his fields and his cows by putting up higher quality feed,” Manning says.

She adds that “Peter has rejuvenated perennial grass fields to increase biodiversity while also increasing yields and digestible fiber. He trialed the use of a manure urease inhibitor with his manure applications to minimize nitrogen volatilization. His focus on the land is evident in his soil health scores and the carbon stored in the soils on his farm, an estimated 5,778 metric tons.”

Rainville also is involved in an ongoing trial with neonicotinoid seed treatments and has had success with wide-row interseeding of cover crops to improve soil health and decrease the risk of surface runoff.

“I interseed when the corn is short,” Rainville says. “Otherwise the seeds won’t germinate. The first year it worked well. The second year, not so much.”

In 2022, Ben & Jerry’s selected the farm for its Low Carbon Dairy project. It is one of seven farms in Vermont, all in Franklin and Grand Isle Counties, participating in the pilot project, which aims to reduce on-farm emissions by 50% through adoption of sustainable and cost-effective practices for regenerative agriculture, animal welfare, renewable energy and manure management, among other areas.

According to Manning, Rainville was the first participating farmer to install solar to help lower his carbon footprint. The 72-kilowatt roof-mounted solar system on his main dairy barn that houses the cows and the robotic milking system not only minimizes his reliance on fossil fuels but provides an additional source of revenue for the farm.

In 2023, Rainville applied for a Dairy Farm Innovation and Alternative Management grant through the Northeast Dairy Business Innovation Center and was awarded $20,000 to purchase and install a Lely Juno robotic feed pusher. Providing consistent access to feed for his cows has significantly increased his milk production.

These changes have allowed Rainville to spend less time in the barn and more time with his family including weekly dinners at the farm. His devotion to his daughters extends to his willing participation in their TikTok channel, Rainvillerizzz, where “Farmer Pete” can be found showing off his dance moves with Hannah and Ashley as well working with the cows or sharing tender moments with his three-year-old granddaughter Claudia, Marie’s daughter.

To help promote the dairy industry, Rainville has hosted corporate groups such as Ben & Jerry’s as well as school tours and visitors from the U.S., South America, Asia and more recently, exchange students from France. He’s also hosted UVM Extension workshops for other farmers, including one to share how he optimized forage quality and increased home-grown forages in his cows’ diet.

“I like when people who have never been on a farm visit so we can show them what we do,” the dairyman says. “Some people have never touched a cow. A cow licks their hand, and they are thrilled. And everyone loves the calves.”

“For years, Peter has been a great advocate for Vermont dairy,” says Manning. “His willingness to welcome all visitors and discuss how he farms and the way of life it provides for his family is second to none.” 

The Rainville family will be honored at an awards banquet at Eastern States Exposition in West Springfield, Massachusetts, in September, along with the Green Pastures winners from the other New England states. Other finalists for this year's award, listed alphabetically, were the Miller Farm, Inc. (Peter and Art Miller), Vernon, and Taft’s Milk and Maple Farm (Bruce, Mary, Tim and Margaret Taft), Huntington.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here