Focused on forests: Franklin County forester Charlie Hancock on past, present of forest stewardship

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — Bending down to look at a small yellow Trout Lilly flower, Franklin County forester Charlie Hancock said spring is a good time to see how forests tell their own stories. 

Through the centuries, Vermont’s forests have been shaped and altered by the actions of people living in and around them. From near elimination in the 1800s due to logging and grazing, to management for sugaring and recreation in the 20th and 21st centuries, forests bear the scars of past and present use. 

Walking the trails of the St. Albans Town Forest in late April, Hancock said it his job to help public and private landowners adapt their forests to short-term challenges and an ever changing climate in the long term. 

“Now, what we’re tending to see more of is as these [ecological forestry] principals get employed on the landscape, we have examples we can point to,” Hancock said. “We can go to forests and show where these things have been employed and certain ways and use them as demonstration sites.” 

Forest connections

As the county’s forester, Hancock knows a lot about trees. He cares about state and federal forests, but for his work, it’s the private land owners who matter most. 

“Vermont is 80% forested right now, and about 80% of that is in private land ownership,” he said. “When we think about the importance of our forests and their management, and what the future of our forests is going to look like, it’s going to be driven by private landowners.” 

A county forester’s job is to assist those landowners, and serve as a resource no matter the size of the forest. 

It could be someone with 100 acres in Franklin, or someone in St. Albans with less than an acre, but if they have trees, and tree health issues they want to talk about, Hancock said he’s there. 

“We always talk about objectives. That sounds a little clinical, but it’s the idea of what do you love about your forests? What do you want from this? What makes you feel good about owning it?” Hancock said. “And then we say, ‘Okay, so here’s what you’ve got as a resource, here’s what you want from it, here’s what you love from it and here are some options that you might have going forward to help meet those objectives.’” 

Understanding the connection between landowners and their forests helps him establish a forest management plan which has ripple effects for the short term and for years down the road. 

“Some of the most fun I’ve had out in the woods over the years is going out with families who have owned land for a long time, where you’ve got maybe the grandparents who’ve sugared there for 50 or 60 years and you’ve got the grandkids in elementary school,” Hancock said. “They’re learning about it and they’re seeing what the management of their forest means and what it’s going to mean for them.” 

“The work that we do out in the woods today, it’s often not for us. It’s for the generations that come after us,” he continued. 

Hancock said he and Vermont’s other county foresters help maintain the state’s signature green coloring. Not too long ago, Vermont’s forest cover was almost completely wiped, and the effects are still felt today with less than 1% of today’s forests considered old growth. 

Flash back to the early 1800s and 80% of the state was cleared of its forests to make room for sheep herders. Focused on large grazing lands and an economy of timber extracts, taking care of what was in the forest was less important than what to take out. 

In Montgomery, milling and the wood industry were major components of the economy. Hancock said the town churned out 1.5 million butter tubs a year to ship around the world and produced different kinds of packaging cases including for Victrola record players. 

By the turn of the 20th century, there were 16 mills producing wood products in the Montgomery area. When the 1940s rolled around, however, the timber industry was on its way out. 

Ask around to forest landowners now, and Hancock said surveys show ownership is less about the material products they can get off the land, and more about the aesthetics and the intangible feelings that come with. 

“When you look at surveys that are done of forest landowners in terms of why people own forest land, the top two or three answers have nothing to do with anything we take from the forest,” he said. 

That’s not to discount the working lands economy of Franklin County, Hancock added, those tapping their trees or logging still play an important part in the county, however, the thought process behind forest stewardship has changed. 

“We still have a very strong working lands economy and culture up here,” he said. “Which is really important because that connection to our forests is what drives our commitment to managing them for health and productivity over the long term.” 

In big picture terms, Hancock said how the lands are being managed and what they are being managed for is the key difference between the Vermont attitude today versus the past. 

An ‘adolescent teenage forest’ 

A flip from logging and timber industries to the dairy industry and westward expansion helped bring back some of the trees in Franklin County’s forests, but the biggest contributor was a new understanding in forest management. 

“Going through that period of what really was kind of extractive logging certainly got a lot of wood out,” Hancock said. “Probably wasn’t the best form of forest management that we were practicing back then, but the forests continued to come back.” 

A new form of management philosophy and technique blossomed in the early 20th century when Gifford Pinchot became the first chief of the U.S. Forest Service. He encouraged managing forests to create “the greatest good for the greatest number of people.”

“How do we manage this in a way for sustained yield, essentially,” Hancock said. 

As the practice of forestry continued to evolve, the idea of ecological forestry took root. This means mimicking natural disturbances to shape forests into more of what they would be like without human intervention.

The 80% of Vermont forests which have grown back post-logging are jokingly referred to as “adolescent teenage forests,” Hancock said, they are in a human equivalent of their 20s or 30s — young in the grand scheme of forestry. 

Because of their young age, Vermont’s forests are not so structurally complex. Many are not home to a diverse set of species, which influences the wildlife and forest structure seen in older stands. 

“You can look at parts of Franklin County where you’ve got stands dominated by Red Maple,” Hancock said, pointing up at a grouping of trees in the St. Albans Town Forest. “The forests haven’t in a lot of cases transitioned into that later successional state where a more diverse weed of species comes in.” 

In Georgia’s Silver Lake Woods, for example, the town’s conservation commission noticed the area has stands of similar aged trees, some with disease and invasives in the mix. Over the course of a few months, commissioners created a forest management plan to add diversity and create a mix of trees in age and species. 

The plan essentially is to encourage the growth of an old forest, while thinning out the disease to mimic a more “wild” forest. 

Still, forestry work is not done in a vacuum, there are outside effects always pushing on stands around the county, and Hancock said it’s become part of a forester’s job to make forests more resilient for the future. 

Some of that work can be done through creating a more diverse forest structure; going in and doing the work to get a new class of trees established and provide future development for a diverse wildlife habitat. 

“I think this idea of resilience, physically what we’re doing, what we’re building in our woods, and then how we’re managing our forest to set them up to be more resilient is critically important,” Hancock said. 

While Vermont’s trees are tough, Hancock said they’re also facing pressures from a changing environment which invites disease, invasives and literal tree movement. 

“How do we manage our forests so that the forests themselves are more resilient in the future?” he said. 

A new landscape 

One of those small visual examples of climate change, Hancock said, is watching trees leaf out earlier than they historically would. Doing so creates a cascading effect for other plants in the understory. 

“Broadly, big picture, one of the biggest challenges we see right now is the impact of climate change,” Hancock said. 

Or, take a look back at last year, he said, to see weather patterns changing. 

Periods of drought put stress on trees, while high intensity storm events with lots of water or high winds blow down groupings. A change in temperature also plays into the spread of invasive species. 

“With the changing climate and warming temperatures, we’re seeing them spread much faster,” Hancock said. 

Take the Hemlock wooly adelgid, an insect which feeds, unsurprisingly, on Hemlock. The insect has moved north through the Appalachians up into Southern Vermont. One of its limiting factors has been cooler temperatures, Hancock said. 

Hotter days encourage the insect to move north and contribute to the range in which trees can grow. Hemlock trees are also moving northbound. 

“None of this happens overnight. It’s not like we’re going to wake up tomorrow and now have sugar maple here,” Hancock said. “But if you look at patterns of where species are and how plant species move – because they do – we could be setting ourselves up for some of those colder adapted species, like sugar maple, maybe not being prolific in certain parts of Vermont.” 

“All these things play into the outside forces that are acting on our forests that influence what tools in our toolbox we use to manage them for the myriad of uses and things that we love about them,” Hancock continued. 

Vermont’s forests also find themselves in the middle of the state's desperate need for more housing and development. Allowing development and the woods to co-exist has been a tough nut to crack. 

There are two parts to that question, Hancock said, which are important to address. One is the land use question, and the other is, what are we building with? 

“How can we use these principles of what a lot of folks call bio-regionalism to source the products we need as locally as possible?” Hancock said. 

From a foresting perspective, sourcing locally both helps the carbon footprint and management practices. Essentially, it gives foresters an understanding of the effects the state’s development is having on its own forests. 

“If we can source our products from forests which are closer to home, which we know are well-managed, we can have a bigger impact on what the management of our broader land base is,” he said. 

Sourcing materials from offshore, Hancock said, gives a false "illusion of preservation.” 

If Vermonters don’t look at where they’re sourcing materials from, this illusion is created that the state is preserving important natural resources. In reality, Hancock said, the burden is shifting elsewhere. 

Land use is a whole other deal, and Hancock said it is mostly on the table for lawmakers and zoning boards to figure out, but the forestry service can play a part in the design. 

“In terms of our forests, we have some really great research that’s been done … which we can learn from to figure out where are our most highest priority forests? Where are these large intact blocks of forest which have the greatest diversity of values?” he said. “And from that we can look at how we can protect those forests and those resources.” 

The other part of conservation is keeping forests as forests, Hancock said. Making sure land owners who pay property taxes keep an economically viable forest. Remember, 80% of Vermont’s forests are privately owned, so landowners play a large part in conserving the forests themselves. 

“When you start looking at policy decisions which have an impact on what we can do and where, it's an important discussion to have with as great an amount of engagement as we can get with folks to chart this path forward,” he said. 

Vermont's forests are embedded in city centers and smaller rural communities dotted around the state, Hancock said. Forests are part of Vermonters’ identities and lives. 

“These are the forests that define the place we call home,” he said. “I think that's just really, really important in terms of how we see ourselves as a state and of what our future is going to be. We’re really lucky to live in a place like this, and it also highlights the importance of what we do as stewards for it.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here