ENOSBURG FALLS — Attention, education, and perseverance are values said to carry forward those who possess them. And yet despite several years displaying all of the above, the Enosburg Falls village board continues to be borne back by trouble with its hydro plants.
The renovation of the village’s central plant, which villagers call Hydro Plant Number One, has struck the latest in two years’ worth of rocky complications, while at the same time, repairs to the village’s second plant, the Kendall Plant, remain similarly delayed more than a year after that plant inhaled an actual rock.
The day before the village board’s most recent meeting, the morning of Aug. 13, the village manager, Jon Elwell, received an email from Kingsbury Inc., the company renovating Hydro Plant Number One.
The village’s contract with Kingsbury stipulates the company’s renovations are to be substantially completed by Aug. 31. But Kingsbury’s email brought a new expected completion time: early October.
Elwell told the village board at its Aug. 14 meeting that he had since had several phone and email exchanges with Paul Brecht, who engineered the renovation project for the village. Brecht then convinced Kingsbury to move 10 days quicker, meaning a substantial completion date closer to Sept. 20.
Elwell told the board he wasn’t surprised to hear Kingsbury’s work would be delayed. There were “a few things hanging out there,” Elwell said, “including, in fairness, a few things that were not entirely in their control,” like delays in equipment manufacturing.
“But I did not want to hear that they were going to be five weeks over the construction deadline,” Elwell said.
Elwell told the board Brecht is still negotiating with Kingsbury for an earlier completion date, and also that Brecht will attend the board’s next meeting, Aug. 28, on which the Messenger will also report.
Brecht’s engineering firm, the H. L. Turner Group, studied the village’s hydro facilities in 2012, and concluded that the plants could become inoperable within five years if not for immediate renovation. In 2016, at the farther end of that supposed five-year lifespan, village officials moved swiftly to make those renovations happen, including a four- to five-blade turbine upgrade for Plant One, per the Turner Group’s recommendation.
That began a year of contractual and engineering waltzing between the village board and the Turner Group. The village board agreed on a five-blade turbine upgrade. The Turner Group backtracked and said it would be astronomically expensive. The Turner Group recommended a simple upgrade to the village’s four-blade turbine. The village board agreed. The lowest bid came in $1 million above the Turner Group’s project cost estimates.
The Turner Group said it could negotiate with that low bidder — Kingsbury — to bring down the cost. The village board agreed. The Turner Group and Kingsbury proposed a two-phase approach to the project, with the second phase, the actual renovations, entirely dependent on the outcome of the first, a study of the hydro facilities.
The village board agreed, allotting an extra $56,000 from the village’s electric department, only to find the Turner Group asking for an additional $50,600, which the village board also appropriated from its electric department.
What could the village government do? Brecht told the village board “there’s just too many unknowns,” and that no contractor would bid on the project as-is.
The village ultimately paid $65,000 for phase two, after phase one determined Plant One was in worse shape than expected.
As Walter Scott, the chair of the village board, put it, the board was “down to two options. Fix it, or sell it.”
Kingsbury began renovating the plant in July 2017.
The Kendall Plant is in similarly high water. A rock avoided the debris racks designed to keep foreign objects from damaging these plants, and smashed off several of the Kendall Plant’s turbine blades in May 2017.
The plant sustained $300,000 worth of damage, all but $1,500 of which the village’s insurer covered before dropping the village as a client. The village has since contracted a new insurer.
Elwell told the board divers from Fairbanks Mill, a hydroelectric construction company, just finished inspecting those debris racks, and that their conclusion was no surprise: the racks need repairs.
The racks are “submerged in water, 24/7,” Elwell explained to the board. “Like anything in life, they aren’t going to last forever… They’ve been serving us pretty well for about 26 years.”
Fairbanks’ divers suggested regularly inspecting the rack, at least every two years if not annually.
Fairbanks concluded that the debris racks need replacing in 6-8 years. Otherwise, the Kendall Plant situation could happen again: a rock or other damaging object could slip through and smash up the turbines.
The Kendall Plant remains offline, pending repairs. The Canadian company handling the repair, Norcan Fluid Power, has manufactured the plant’s new generator and its new turbine, both of which Norcan agreed to deliver by the end of August — with the plant’s new gearbox, manufactured by Zylom, which Elwell said refuses to commit to a completion date.
The other two parts “are there,” Elwell said, passing photos of the turbine and generator. “They’re on blocks.
“They’re just sitting in a warehouse, waiting for the gearbox.”
Elwell said Zylom has suggested the gearbox could be shipped, with the generator and turbine, toward the end of September.
But that isn’t certain, either. Local developer Jim Cameron was in the audience at the village board meeting. He asked if the parts are manufactured in the U.S. Norcan manufactured the generator and turbine in Canada. Elwell said he wasn’t sure where Zylom manufactures the gearbox.
Cameron said the federal government’s tariffs have caused problems for him as a contractor. As Cameron put it, they’re “a pain” — steel costs are up 40 percent, and flooring for one of his projects is stuck across the Canadian border.
Hopefully, Elwell said, the Kendall Plant’s parts float past the same situation.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here