Enosburgh Selectboard and VTrans meet to discuss Sand Hill Road bridge options

Posted

ENOSBURGH — The Town of Enosburgh's Selectboard is in the early stages of deciding what to do with a lonely bridge near the bottom of the town line. 

Bridge 45 on Sand Hill Road crosses over the Tyler Branch and is in need of some repairs. While discussions are still in early stages, Vermont Agency of Transportation scoping project manager Laura Stone came to the board Sept. 21 to get the ball rolling. 

Normally, scoping engineers and management teams from VTrans come to a consensus on a project and present a recommendation to the board. This bridge, however, required more attention. 

“We met on this structure internally and we really felt we needed to have a conversation with the town before we felt comfortable making a recommendation,” Stone said. “Everybody was all over the place on what we thought we should do with this structure.” 

Issues with the existing bridge include timber rot, cracked abutments and signs of salt damage and erosion around the base of the structure. Traffic over the bridge is relatively low with 57 vehicles per day, according to VTrans. 

Stone came to the board to present a number of options, looking for the board to weigh-in on which suits the town best. The bridge is town-owned meaning there would be a town share in any project the selectboard ultimately goes with. 

Possible fixes 

The first option is for the town to do nothing. Leave the bridge as it is. Stone said that plan is not recommended by VTrans as it could pose a safety hazard. The town would pay nothing in this plan. 

Similarly, Stone said the other plan is a strategic disinvestment. VTrans would come in, remove the existing bridge and abutments, open up the channel and leave the open space as it is. Again, the move would cost the town no money, as long as a piece of legislation VTrans hopes to pass in the coming season comes to fruition, which would lower the town share percentage in disinvestments to zero. 

“For a bridge that sees less than 60 vehicles per day, when we started talking about this internally, we had some folks from our management team who said, ‘Well hey why shouldn’t we be disinvesting this? This is a whole lot of money to spend on a bridge that doesn’t see a lot of traffic,’” Stone said. “But also it’s your bridge, and you guys get to make the final decision on what you want to do here.” 

If the selectboard were to choose to keep the bridge standing, VTrans has another four options each with varying degrees of money the town has to throw in. 

Option one is a truss rehabilitation. Cleaning, repairing and replacing deteriorated truss members and strengthening of parts, a deck replacement and repainting are included. Work from this design would add 40 years to the bridge’s life. The awkward approach to the bridge would remain. This plan would cost the town $58,774.

Option two is a new bridge on alignment. Costing $218,791, VTrans would keep the bridge where it is now with the awkward approach, improve the structure, and lengthen the bridge to meet modern standards. The construction would add 75 years to the bridge life. 

VTrans can also do the same work to lengthen the bridge and bridge life, but take it off its current alignment. Taking it off alignment would fix some of the steep, winding path approach to get on the bridge. It would add more roadway work and therefore cost the town $353,474. 

Lastly, and most expensive is a completely new bridge, on a new alignment with Horseshoe Circle, instead of Sand Hill Road. Because a new roadway would be constructed, the town would pay $590,150. 

Leaning to disinvest or rehab

After learning the costs, selectboard members launched into questions around traffic from the nearby Brookside Campground – their website says to not take RVs over the bridge – and the work that goes into each plan. 

“I’m not speaking for the whole board, but truss rehab would be an option I’m looking at or disinvest,” selectboard member Larry Gervais said. “I mean, for the traffic that goes through there, for the taxpayers money, you’re not going to get bang for your buck in return at all.” 

Selectboard members also said they know there are people who walk, snowshoe, or drive snowmobiles over the bridge, and Stone said there’s a possibility VTrans could rehabilitate the bridge to pedestrian and snowmobile standards but close it off to other vehicles to keep recreation open. 

But overall, the selectboard was concerned about the price of the projects.  

“I think the consensus here, at least for some of us, is that one of the first two options is not enough traffic to justify the higher amounts for taxpayers, that’s the way I see it,” Chair Dean Wright said. 

There’s still some time before the selectboard has to make any official decision on the bridge. 

Based on the September meeting, Stone said VTrans will make their recommendations and come back at another warned meeting to talk through alternatives. This meeting was to get more feedback before a formal recommendation.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here