Engineers brought in to fix smell; Creamery gets another 2 weeks

Posted

ST. ALBANS CITY — After one stinky year with the St. Albans Creamery, St. Albans City Council seems to be on its way to a solution.

Engineers with both organizations are now prepared to meet, review the data and come up with some recommendations to tamp down on the intermittent smell reeking of “dead animals” that sometimes escapes the creamery's boundaries.

During the latest November city council meeting, creamery representatives and municipal officials set a deadline of “two weeks” to set up a meeting to discuss the data.

“We’ll get a meeting together and develop a scope. I’m not asking the co-op to agree to the recommendations,” Cloud said. “I just need access, right? Allow our guys to come in and have a look around.”

Back-and-forth

The creamery’s mysterious stink started getting the city’s attention as early as January this year, after the facility added a new reverse osmosis system to improve its wastewater filtration. The problem with the new equipment, however, was that it would sometimes release a hydrosulfuric smell.

Those who have gotten a whiff have compared it to “dead animals” or “raw sewage.”

DFA health and safety engineer Rod Harvey agreed with the smell description, explaining that its source could be decaying organic matter releasing methylmercaptan and hydrogen sulfide.

“It could be something else, too. I can’t make a definitive link between every complaint and what chemical is causing it,” he said.

Since the problem arose, the City of St. Albans has worked with the creamery to identify the source of the smell, with creamery engineers installing additional equipment and sensors to find and resolve the issue over the last year.

Despite the efforts, the problem has continued for the City of St. Albans. After one stinky summer, they were looking to label the smell as a public health nuisance, potentially setting up a situation for the city to fine the creamery if the smell remained.

At the city’s November meeting, much of that back-and-forth came to a head, and city officials came to the table Monday night with an engineering firm, Sanborn, Head & Associates, waiting in the wings to take up the work if DFA couldn’t find a solution.

“Having our engineer that’s going to report to us, we feel it’s very important at this point, because I think we’ve been kicking this down the road,” Ward 6 Alderperson Chad Boudreau said.

As Cloud explained, in the past month the city tracked 17 complaints in 21 days, as neighbors and city workers still encountered the smell. Cloud had set up a phone line to collect the complaints.

“I’m hoping tonight we might be able to shift the tenor and direction of this discussion,” Cloud said. “I was optimistic that we would be able to engage in a problem solving approach and as the city increased its pressure to find a solution. … But we’re moving backwards.”

As for DFA, St. Albans Creamery representatives used the council meeting to bring another round of engineering data to the table to explain what they’ve discovered.

And by the end of the discussion, attorney Peter Raymond agreed on the creamery’s behalf to set up a technical meeting between the city and creamery so they could better work together.

“I don’t think we can commit to two weeks for them to do the inspection, but certainly to have a sit-down about it,” Raymond said.

Finding a solution

To explain where the smell originated, DFA introduced Harvey to speak on some of his most recent findings, as well as the overall process of locating and identifying the smell at the creamery since it became an issue.

As he explained, back in January engineers set up six sensors around the property, including a few concentrated on the creamery’s north side, to catch the organic chemical compounds likely causing the smell.

With that said, the sensors don’t pick up every smell. Each one is looking for a particular chemical, and sulfuric smells can still be detected at extremely low concentrations by people even if a sensor doesn’t detect anything. 

If a sensor does go off, however, then engineers can better identify the day’s events to understand where it comes from, Harvey said, and in October ,it seemed to be originating from the creamery’s sludge trucks, as higher readings correlated with days when the creamery hauled sludge away from the facility. 

Such low levels of exposure also aren’t dangerous, Harvey said.

“Any of the compounds that are being generated from any plant operations that we can detect are well below any public health level,” Raymond said. “So we’re not at a point where there’s going to be any impact on public health with any of the operations as they currently stand.”

Based on Harvey’s numbers, sensors measured hydrogen sulfide levels at detectable levels for only 18 minutes in the last 32 days.

After the discussion, city officials still wanted to bring in their engineers for a more extensive review.

“Sanborn Head requests the ability to get into the plant and do some studies and develop some recommendations," Cloud said. “We can’t cover the cost of improvements, but we could cover the cost of putting the plan together.”

If the meeting in two weeks doesn’t help resolve the issue, the City of St. Albans could still choose to declare the creamery a public health nuisance, opening up a legal front in the ongoing discussion.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here