‘Do the right thing’ Sen. Sanders shows support for union workers at St. Albans DFA plant

Curtis Clough
Posted

This story was updated at 4:30 p.m. with new information from the Dairy Farmers of America and Rep. Becca Balint (D-Vt.)

ST. ALBANS CITY — In a show of support for Teamsters Local 597 union, Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) told Dairy Farmers of America to reverse its decision to idle the St. Albans plant. 

Sanders’ backing comes following the union's complaint that Dairy Farmers of America is closing the creamery to “get back” at the union for a strike held last fall. 

“My message to DFA is: do the right thing, reverse your decision to idle the St. Albans plant and creamery,” Sanders said Wednesday outside the St. Albans plant. “Ensure that dairy farmers do not face yet another cost increase on their balance sheets in these tough times. Protect Franklin County’s agricultural community.” 

Surrounded by about 30 of his fellow union workers Wednesday afternoon, Ted Westover, a steward at the plant, said he’s been working there for nine years. Following the strike, when workers went back to their jobs, he said the atmosphere of the place shifted entirely. 

“Certain unwritten rules were started by the management team, and it was difficult,” he said. “We want to get back to work. We all enjoy our work.” 

The change in attitude from management, union president Curtis Clough said, shows the union-busting attempt at hand. After the two-week strike meant to help workers take better care of their families, Clough said, DFA is now following a textbook example of retaliation over the event. 

“Let me be clear about this: The Teamsters will not allow DFA to punish our members for exercising their rights,” he said. “If DFA thinks they can get away with this, they are picking a fight with the wrong workers, the wrong community, the wrong union and the wrong state.” 

In a statement, DFA said the decision made this past June to idle the plant was unrelated to the strike and instead due to an analysis of the dairy market and long-term business plans. 

DFA set the official plant closure date for this past Monday, Aug. 17. Roughly 80 employees are expected to lose their jobs due to the closure, though a small team will continue to maintain the property. 

Sanders and Sen. Peter Welch (D-Vt.) sent a letter to DFA president Dennis Rodenbaugh yesterday expressing concern over the impact to the Franklin County community. The two senators said without DFA meaningfully engaging with the union they can only conclude the decision is retaliation. 

“Without a sufficient explanation, it would be reasonable to conclude that the decision to idle the plant is illegal retaliation for last year’s strike. That is unacceptable,” the letter states. 

This afternoon, DFA responded to the letter, again stating the decision was based on the Northeast dairy market. The sole rationale behind the decision, Rodenbaugh wrote, is to “protect farm families from the financial damage of an unviable plant.”

“Abiding by your request to maintain the plant’s operations and tremendous level of ongoing financial losses would inflict direct and irreparable financial harm to Vermont dairy farmers and all DFA farmer-owners and their families in the surrounding region,” Rodenbaugh stated. 

Rep. Becca Balint (D-Vt.) also released a statement this afternoon describing how the St. Albans plant has been a fixture in the New England region for years. Its closure would have a strong ripple effect, Balint said. 

“It’s no secret that our dairy economy has already been under considerable pressure,” she stated. “This would create ripple effects across Vermont and the region for producers and consumers alike, at a time when costs are already sky high. Dairy Farmers of America should honor their contractual commitments with these workers under the law.”

During Wednesday’s press conference, Sanders said the closure left workers, farmers and community members concerned and searching for answers. 

While talking to union members following Sanders’ press conference, a worker said his grandfather was an original member of the St. Albans co-op. 

“Please, help farmers and workers keep this place. This is a travesty,” he said. 

If the plant is to close, Clough said DFA will take Vermont milk and ship it out to other facilities in other states like Massachusetts and New York to be turned into other dairy products. 

In the court’s hands 

In July, the teamsters union said they would "pursue every available avenue to push back against [DFA’s] anti-competitive and anti-worker agendas.” 

Last Friday, they sued to stop the plant’s closure. 

While the teamsters argue the strikes were the the “#1 reason” for the closure, DFA alleges the memos used as proof in the lawsuit were created by artificial intelligence. The document is not authored by the individual identified in it and contains inaccuracies, DFA said in a statement. 

“Proceeding with claims built around a document that has been identified as fraudulent raises significant questions about the credibility and merit of the lawsuit, and the motives behind it,” DFA stated. 

In Wednesday’s letter, DFA again stated the union’s allegations are false and information around the closure is being mischaracterized by union representatives. 

“We will continue to engage with the union in good faith, but we will not compromise our obligation to protect farmer-owner value from coordinated attacks, misinformation, or demands that are completely void of economic and market realities,” Rodenbaugh stated.

In a response to a reporter’s question over the company’s AI claim, Sanders said it’s up to the courts, though he cautioned that someone has to tell AI what to write. 

“I suspect that document, in fact, reflects what DFA is thinking,” he said. 

The fate of the closure now rests in the hands of Judge William K. Sessions. The hearing is scheduled for Thursday afternoon. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here