Dam to generate 130kW more

Posted

ENOSBURG FALLS — The contractor renovating the village hydroelectric facility, Kingsbury Inc., promised to “substantially complete” the renovations by Sept. 18, and to be entirely finished with the project by Sept. 25, about 3-4 weeks late.

At the village board’s meeting Tuesday evening, trustees opted not to fine the company for its lateness — unless Kingsbury works past those dates. The village’s contract with Kingsbury allows the village to fine the company $500 each day the project runs later than Aug. 31.

But the trustees seemed to agree doing so could complicate a project that has already been rife with complications, though they also agreed to impose the daily fine if the project is not substantially completed by Sept. 18, and/or entirely completed by Sept. 25.

Per the contract, “substantial completion” means, basically, that renovations are complete to the point that workers can use the hydro facility again. Kingsbury told village officials renovations to the facility’s roof, for example, will continue for a week beyond the substantial completion date.

John Lavigne and Paul Becht are engineers with the H. L. Turner Group, the engineering firm that has designed and coordinated the project with the village. Both Lavigne and Becht attended last night’s meeting.

As Lavigne put it, come Sept. 18, “You may be generating power, but there may be roofers on the roof.”

Lavigne and Becht advocated that the board accept the delay. Lavigne in particular focused not on the delay, but on the project’s overall outcome: the possibility of an additional 130 kilowatts (kW) of electric generation from Hydro Plant Number One.

The increased capacity could be well timed. The village is now beginning the lengthy process of federally relicensing its hydro facilities. The village’s current license allows 600 kW of generation, a maximum the hydro facility rarely generated before the renovations. Village officials estimated the facility generated an average of 350-400 kW then, due to its equipment’s degradation.

Lavigne gave an especially enthusiastic presentation last night. He said he anticipated one looking at the hydro facility’s exterior and asking, “Where did my $2 million go?”

Lavigne said it went inside the facility. The facility will no longer run with a four-blade turbine, but with a more efficient five-blade. The plant’s stress-cracked flood gates have been replaced with curved rather than flat plates, again for greater efficiency. And the system is now controlled through a, yes, more efficient computer system, allowing remote operation of the plant.

Lavigne focused on those and similar upgrades, directing the board’s attention to the outcome of the project, which Lavigne asserted fulfills the village board’s original goals: to increase both the plant’s capacity and its longevity.

Lavigne estimated the plant’s capabilities are 70 percent of what engineers might expect with a $4 million budget, rather than the roughly $2 million the Village of Enosburg Falls spent.

When Lavigne finished, moments passed.

Guy Breault, one of the village’s five trustees, told him, “You’re one good salesman.”

Lavigne seemed offended, though Breault also seemed to have made the comment without any intended hostility.

“I like to think I know my business,” Lavigne said.

Jon Elwell, the village manager, was more openly critical of the delay. He told the board he disagreed with the “premise” of Kingsbury’s letter informing village officials of the delay. But Elwell also recommended the board not impose the daily fine unless Kingsbury works beyond the above-mentioned dates.

When Sam Vaillancourt, another trustee, asked why the board should not impose the daily fine, Elwell said he felt trying to maintain an “efficient” relationship with Kingsbury better served the village’s interests, versus taking “time-consuming and possibly litigious” action.

Breault said he had no problem with the delay, and made the motion that the board take no action unless the project is not substantially completed by Sept. 18, and entirely completed by Sept. 25 — in which case the daily fines come into play. Trustee Leonard Charron seconded the motion, and the board unanimously approved it.

The village has not generated its own power since shutting down its second hydro plant, the Kendall Plant, in May 2017, after a rock substantially damaged its turbine’s blades. Village officials intended to compensate for Hydro Plant One’s lack of generation during these renovations by running the Kendall Plant, which is now undergoing repairs of its own.

Meanwhile, the board scheduled a special meeting with state and federal officials on Nov. 6, at which those officials will brief the board on the process to relicense the hydro facilities.

A Turner Group study, conducted in 2012, concluded that Hydro Plant One could become inoperable within five years if not immediately renovated. The village board began contracting those renovations in 2016, and Kingsbury began work on-site in July 2017.

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here