‘Control, quality, cost’ Could county governance be beneficial to Vermont?

Posted

VERMONT — Each day in municipal offices statewide, a small staff juggles a long to-do list: plow the roads, organize land records, issue permits, maintain parks, mitigate floods. The list continues. 

As populations expand and state demands multiply, some towns are searching for help and banding together to share the workload and enhance services. 

County government in Vermont is almost non-existent. The state’s 14 counties serve more as labels than government entities. Counties have just four elected officials, including three assistant judges and a sheriff. Almost every other local public service is provided by towns, like infrastructure, zoning and parks and recreation. 

But as the Green Mountain State faces more challenges, is regionalization through a county governance system or something similar the way to go? 

“One of the benefits for more regionalization is it would take some of the burden off the towns to do things that don’t necessarily have to be done at the local level,” Catherine Dimitruk, executive director of the Northwest Regional Planning Commission, said. “Having a more regional approach could allow the state to accomplish some of its long-term goals.”

A legislative committee is currently studying if county government could work in Vermont. Although recommendations aren’t due to the full body until 2026, the fact a study exists shows Vermont is thinking to the future.

Franklin County Senator Bob Norris (R-Sheldon) is a member of the committee, and he said the group came about last year to look at how towns and cities affected by severe flooding could get aid more quickly. 

“We want to see if we can expedite the process in FEMA for disasters in local communities or through the state because it’s just another hoop to jump through to send aid directly to the state or municipality,” Norris said. “We’re trying to look out for the best interests of our constituents.” 

Although the idea came after municipalities have struggled in getting aid directly from the state or the federal government, Norris said the legislature came to realize without a county system there are some barriers in disaster relief. 

The committee has only met a handful of times, hearing from people about the disasters and learning the context behind it, but will continue to meet this year. 

“There’s always obstacles to overcome. Vermont doesn’t have a strong county government so what it's going to look like, I’m not quite sure or if it’s even possible,” Norris said.

Nicholaus Nadeau, native Vermonter and current interim town manager of Fairfax, was previously a town administrator in Maine, where county government does exist. He said he sees three reasons why residents might fight against a larger regional approach: control, quality and cost. 

“It has to be very clear the cost savings, how you're going to ensure the quality is going to stay the same, and how are you going to make sure local folks still feel like they have control,” he said. “If one one out of any three of those doesn't really make its case…then Vermonters are, naturally so, going to reject it.” 

Keeping control 

Vermonters have already voiced opposition to some larger regionalization attempts in the past. 

Act 46, the education reform bill which saw smaller, local school districts merge into larger districts, passed the legislature and was signed by Gov. Peter Shumlin in 2015. The act was designed to improve quality and equity of education and provide property tax relief. The act saw the creation of the Maple Run Unified School District, for example. 

It didn’t unfold smoothly, however, with many local school districts fighting mergers in the state’s supreme court, including a few now-defunct Franklin County school boards. It wasn’t smooth with voters either, who had mixed feelings across the state about the consolidation efforts. 

“You'd [now] have towns like Stowe and Elmore in the same school district,” Nadeau said. “Well, Elmore is a schoolhouse of like, two dozen kids or less, and Stowe is arguably the richest community in the state of Vermont. What are the similarities there? How are they going to be treated the same?”

That loss of control is felt acutely, especially in smaller towns, he added. Residents of municipalities on the outskirts of a regionalized border could be further removed from administrators and staffing than before a larger system was put in place. 

“Who gets to decide where the county hub is in these regional lines?” Nadeau said. 

However, during emergency situations, Vermonters must now lean on elected officials — neighbors in the community — to navigate complicated venues for coordination. 

Counties with a governance structure would be able to send out notifications using a county alert system, which notifies multiple municipalities in situations like flooding, which wrecked havoc in Vermont the past few years. 

County seats would also be able to coordinate a multi-town approach to recovery and navigate federal relief services instead of selectboard members with a lack of experience. 

“Every municipality has an emergency management director or coordinator, and so at the local level, you have folks on the ground with some sort of training and an inclination of their duties and abilities and responsibilities for a situation that arises,” Nadeau said. “But in an emergency, you need a top down structure, and that's [county government] the best by far.”

Not only could county government be quicker for disaster responses, but federal money and resources from disaster stricken areas are often made for county-level services, not a handful of small population towns to receive directly. 

Quality and cost

When services are administered on a local level, attention is directed specifically to local residents and not spread across a region or county. 

When taken to a larger regional level, gaps might start appearing — part of the reason why municipalities have been switching policing services. Georgia, for example — which does not have its own police department — went from the Franklin County Sheriff's Department to Milton Police and then back to the sheriff’s. 

“Let's use St. Albans, P.D. as an example,” Nadeau said. “I am not going to speak for them, but, can you offer the same quality in another municipality? If Fairfax becomes a problem child, and they're covering us, it puts a lot of burden on them, and their taxpayers might be like, ‘Why are we caring so much about, insert whatever municipality we're covering?’”

When looking at it more generally, Nadeau said people might worry that without their own dedicated service, the quality of that service might go down. 

However, this hasn’t stopped smaller municipalities from reaching out to nearby towns who offer a service they can’t support with their residents alone. The Fairfax Fire Department, for example, is in contract with Fletcher, who just renewed their service, and the Enosburgh ambulance service is contracted all the way to Franklin.

Many towns in Franklin County have engaged in some form of small-scale regionalization in order to achieve quality they might not get if they were to do it alone. 

On a larger regional scale, Nadeau said a county governance system provides an overall shell for municipalities of all sizes. Instead of one larger town looking after some smaller towns, the shell would create a system with equal resources in the area.

“One of the benefits is, blanket services to those folks in that municipality, probably at a cost-saving effort, versus a couple trying to take up the charge themselves,” he said. “It could have improved quality from a municipality that isn't able to offer those services.”

Cost-wise, the most important factor each municipality would consider is “does it make sense?”

In order for a regionalization or county governance system to work in Vermont, Nadeau said one of the most important things to consider is whether the costs outweigh the service or vice versa. 

Many towns who utilize another municipality’s services agree it makes sense for them to support the service monetarily because that ends up costing less than sustaining full-time staff of their own. 

“I think financially it’s very difficult for towns to stand up their own police department,” St. Albans City Police Chief Maurice Lamothe said. “It’s an expensive operation to run and equally as difficult in finding officers and members to run the department.” 

Logistically, he added, it could be easier for towns to look toward their neighbor to offset police operations because they don’t have to worry about supplying anything but financials. 

“It does tend to work well with some towns,” Lamothe said. 

Current regionalization work

Vermont’s closest thing to a regional or county system is its 11 regional planning commissions formed in the 1970s. These planning groups provide assistance in community development often through leadership and technical expertise. 

For example, NRPC is currently meeting with Franklin County municipalities to address new exemptions to Act 250 as they relate to housing. NRPC is working with the towns to designate housing targets and setting boundaries to the exemptions in each town.

Although these commissions work at the regional level, Dimitruk said their powers had to be approved by the towns which make up their regional board. 

“I think Vermont has a strong tradition of local control and any form of regional government or county government needs to respect that,” she said. “In regional governance, it’s important that municipalities have the autonomy to choose to participate.” 

That being said, Dimitruk said she thinks municipalities today are overwhelmed. 

Regardless of their size, municipalities are required to have road and public works crews and other important roles. As the state puts more goals down, it gets more complicated and harder for these crews to do what they are being asked of. 

“A lot of times we have this conversation because municipalities are overwhelmed with responsibilities placed on them,” she said. “So it’s important to not only look at how to do it more effectively at a regional scale, but are municipalities being asked to do the right thing? Do they have to do all these things or can we back off?”

Many towns in Vermont band together to offer “mini” regionalization attempts to help out their neighboring municipality. These can be in emergency services like police, or in recreation.  

Nadeau said the idea of municipalities offering services to help each other has been effective and positive in the state’s current system. 

The current method allows the towns to retain their local control, while also finding alternative ways to fund their programs or gain extra service. 

“If they have the ability and the desire to help others, then, I mean, that’s incredible,” Nadeau said. “It helps sustain their budget, right? It’s going to help a smaller municipality where maybe it wouldn’t be cost efficient to start their own [service] but needs more [of it].”

St. Albans Town and Georgia residents can access programming at the St. Albans City Pool, for example. Georgia has no formal recreation department but sets aside $10,000 in its budget to offer pool vouchers to residents.

Regionalization’s future in Vermont

While the legislature explores the idea of county regionalization, Dimitruk said Vermont should look at the systems it has in place first. 

State statues which govern how municipalities work and define their powers can be tweaked to make cooperation even easier, she said. While municipalities are given the mechanism to make these “mini-regionalization” decisions, they aren’t easy. 

The other way to make it easier for municipalities, she added, is to take a step back and look at what needs to be done on a municipal scale and what can be done on a regional scale. 

The legislature often sets statewide goals and then tasks the 250-plus municipalities to actually make it work. Dimitruk said sometimes it doesn’t always work out the way the state wants or takes a lot longer. 

Flood mitigation, for example, is not effective as a statewide goal, because each area is different, Dimitruk said. However, it would be beneficial as a regional step. 

“When you look at it, quite often the projects that are important to downstream communities need to be done by upstream ones,” she said. “They look to upstream towns to put in time, research and advancement to benefit their own community and neighbors down the river.” 

Instead of turning toward a county government, she said, the state could shift its eyes toward a council of government. A council of government is similar to a regional planning commission, except it’s governed by elected officials from the community. 

These elected officials are able to coordinate services and planning between local governments to benefit towns on a more regional basis. 

“They can easily take on projects and programs that are a local requirement or responsibility and take it on a regional scale,” Dimitruk said. 

Dimitruk added this form of governance has shown promise especially in New England states. In Connecticut, for example, there are nine regional councils, putting towns with similar demographics into planning regions. 

These regional councils are recognized as county equivalents allowing them to apply for funding and grants made available to other states which have county governance. 

If the state were to move forward with a council of government, it could allow municipalities to retain control and choice by electing their own officials, while also empowering communities to work together on a regional basis, and be able to receive more funding, more quickly than a town standing alone.

“I think something like that has promise for Vermont,” she said. 

#sanltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here