MONTPELIER – The Senate Committee on Education voted to advance an Act 46 bill to the Senate that would allow most school districts ordered to merge under Act 46 to delay that merger another year.
With the amendment recommended by the Senate’s education committee, H. 39, the partial delay bill overwhelmingly passed by the Vermont House of Representatives, would allow the school board of a district consolidated under state orders to potentially vote to extend their operational deadline from July 1, 2019, to July 1, 2020.
That vote, however, could only come from a merged district’s elected school board, meaning the district would had to have held their organizational meeting and, following that, school board elections.
Where districts were ordered to merge into an existing district, the existing district’s school board would have the authority to delay their consolidation into 2020.
Districts that don’t vote to delay their consolidation a year are expected to be operational on July 1, 2019, the original deadline prescribed by Act 46.
The amendment makes exceptions for districts whose consolidations depend on a positive vote from an existing district. In those cases, specific deadlines remain per the State Board of Education’s original consolidation orders.
The committee approved H. 39 with a 5-1 vote after a week’s worth of testimony from education specialists and school board representatives from across Vermont.
H. 39 still requires a positive vote from the Senate and a signature from Gov. Phil Scott. Without its passage into law or an order from the court to the contrary, districts consolidated under Act 46 are required to be operational on July 1, 2019.
While the committee’s proposed amendment has been billed as a compromise, answering requests for delay with requirements that merging districts take their first steps toward a merger, the amendment’s proposed delay mechanism was still met with challengers, including the Agency of Education (AOE).
“It is unfair to ask public officials to endure hyperpoliticized school governance climates for another year, unless a clear benefit to students can be identified,” AOE argued in its written testimony.
Proponents have argued that the complicated process of a school merger requires more time than the window allotted under Act 46 and that Act 46’s original deadline would likely set a merger’s operational date before the courts could resolve several lawsuits challenging Act 46 as unconstitutional.
Members of both the Franklin and Montgomery school boards argued just that when providing testimony before the Senate’s education committee.
Opponents, meanwhile, have pointed out that districts had been given four years since the passage of Act 46 in 2015 to organize their respective mergers and argue a delay would only complicate the process further.
In Franklin County, organizational meetings for districts ordered to merge under Act 46 were postponed before much business could be conducted, with the Franklin Northwest Unified Union School District’s meeting warned to resume March 21 and the Enosburgh – Richford district’s organization ordered by the Secretary of Education to resume April 9.
The Northern Mountain Valley Unified (NMVU) school district, which is now under orders to include districts from Montgomery and Sheldon, technically organized when the district was first consolidated by Bakersfield and Berkshire in 2017.
NMVU’s board has yet to meet since the State Board of Education ordered its consolidation with Montgomery’s and Sheldon’s school districts last November.
Stay informed. Subscribe to the Messenger today.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here