BERKSHIRE — Chittenden County Sheriff Deputy Sgt. Scott Costella has been temporarily reassigned to other duties following a traffic stop in Berkshire which led to a Franklin County dairyworker's deportation.
On July 19, Costella pulled over a vehicle which did not have a front license plate. Costella texted Border Patrol for backup which resulted in Genri “Alex” Jimenez’s arrest and eventual deportation to Mexico.
“A man who was living and working in this state has been separated from his partner and his family,” Chittenden County Sheriff Dan Gamelin said in a press release late Monday. “This is serious and I am not going to talk around it.”
Gamelin submitted a complaint to the Vermont Criminal Justice Council’s Professional Regulation Subcommittee July 28 after advocacy group Migrant Justice requested records of the incident.
“Vermont law enforcement has no role in enforcing federal immigration law. We do not conduct immigration stops and we do not ask about status,” Gamelin stated. “Our Fair and Impartial Policing Policy sets real limits on what we share with federal immigration authorities and when. Those limits exist for a reason, and every deputy in this office is accountable to them, including me.”
Migrant Justice, an immigrant farmworker advocacy group, is arguing the actions taken by Costella violate the policy, which prohibits local law enforcement from helping federal authorities in civil immigration cases, unless there is threat to public or officer safety.
Gamelin said he brought in the subcommittee to investigate the incident not only because state law requires him to, but because he does not want the only people looking over the situation to be those who work in his office.
“If our Fair and Impartial Policing Policy was not followed, I want that finding to come from someone with no stake in protecting this office, including no stake in protecting me,” he said.
A Chittenden County deputy so far north might seem odd at first. The Town of Berkshire told the Messenger it has no contract with the sheriff's office. So why so close to the border?
As of 2025, the Chittenden County Sheriff’s Office was one of six Vermont law enforcement agencies involved in a federal program called Operation Stonegarden meant to help shore up the Canadian border.
According to the federal Government Accountability Office, the Swanton Sector had one of the greatest increases in apprehensions between fiscal years 2019 and 2024 with 19,773 apprehensions in FY24 a “1,165 percent increase since fiscal year 2019.”
Under Stonegarden, local law enforcement can accept thousands of dollars in federal grants to work overtime shifts patrolling the northern border area in cooperation with U.S. Customs and Border Protection and Border Patrol.
Operation Stonegarden is a federal grant program handed out by the Federal Emergency Management Agency and maintained by CBP. In previous years, the state of Vermont received up to $800,000 in funding.
A total of $85.5 million in funds were available to states for fiscal year 2026.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here