Facebook banned the highly altered, algorithmically generated videos known as deepfakes from its platform this week. But what may be a bigger problem for our politics has a less menacing name: cheapfakes.
There’s no question deepfakes are frightening. It’s possible for anyone with some money to spare to use machine learning to simulate an individual saying something they never said or doing something they never did — and difficult for those rooting out the dissimulation to stay ahead. The Washington Post reports that start-ups are selling images of false faces to companies that want to increase diversity in their ads and even to a dating app that wants the pictures for a chatbot.
What have flooded our conversation are low-effort edited versions of existing video: that viral clip from last year of House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., distorted so she appeared drunk.These are also examples of media fiddled with deliberately to fool people and leveraged as digital smears against the individuals they depict. Yet because Facebook’s policy affects only video that is the product of artificial intelligence or machine learning, they don’t violate its latest set of rules. Instead, these cheapfakes get similar treatment to traditional misinformation such as made-up news stories: demoted in users’ feeds if a third-party fact-checker rates them as false and labeled with a warning screen. But they are not banned.
It makes sense that Facebook would rather forbid a single, scary technology than take on the more complicated category of manipulated media generally. Drawing lines, and distinguishing between legitimate parody and harmful lie, will be difficult. But to confront the specter that actually faces our democracy today rather than just a ghost of deception to come, all platforms need to accept the larger, more difficult challenge. That will mean examining the entire spectrum from gently to egregiously edited — and focusing on a video’s effect rather than the method of its production. Otherwise, our democracy will soon discover that cheapfakes come at great cost.
The Washington Post
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here