FRANKLIN – The University of Vermont (UVM) Extension’s 2018 Summer Farm Meeting brought farmers and state officials to Franklin last Thursday with presentations highlighting some of the ways area farmers are stymieing the flow of phosphorous into their respective watersheds.
Organized by UVM Extension’s Northwest Crop and Soils Program in collaboration with watershed groups like the Friends of Northern Lake Champlain (FNLC), the Summer Farm Meeting is an annual gathering of farmers, researchers, environmental groups and state officials.
The meeting serves as a forum for some of those groups to present projects and research related to conservation-minded agricultural practices, as well as a way to connect farmers with resources that may help pursue some of those practices.
This year, farmers and officials collected at Bridgeman View Farm, where owners Tim and Martha Magnant had applied many of the best agricultural practices encouraged, and in some cases required, by the state.
FNLC led the morning’s presentations with a report on a two-tier ditch system that was discussed in a Messenger article last Friday. By carving flat benches into the banks of a ditch that cut through the Bouchard Family Dairy, the system essentially created an artificial flood plane between the ditch and abutting fields, creating a safety valve that, FNLC hypothesized, should reduce the threats of erosion and runoff during periods of high flooding.
Discussion about the ditch would bookend Thursday’s meeting, with an opening presentation from FNLC and Agrilab’s Brian Jerose in the morning and a closing visit to the pilot ditch at the Bouchard farm in the afternoon.
Jerose and FNLC’s chair Kent Henderson encouraged farmers to consider similar installations on their own farms, with Jerose asking that farmers “be thinking about your own fields” when presenting information about the ditch during last week’s meeting.
The stream cutting across the Bouchard farm eventually drains into the Rock River, where, according to Department of Environmental Conservation biologist Angela Shambaugh, phosphorous levels had remained steady since at least 2011.
The Rock River Watershed was recently declared by the Agency of Natural Resources (ANR) as an “impaired watershed,” meaning the watershed was identified for “accelerated and targeted agricultural practices” to address its water quality.
The river weaves between Franklin, Highgate and Quebec before ultimately draining into Lake Champlain, meaning that many of the farmers present during Thursday’s meeting have farms within the river’s watershed.
Shambaugh, who followed FNLC’s presentation on the ditch with a more stats-minded depiction of that watershed, reported to those farmers that phosphorous levels held steady in the watershed, something that didn’t really reflect “all the hard work you’ve done.”
That the phosphorous levels were steady rather than spiking, however, was reportedly good news for the watershed, as it meant that some of the watershed’s excessive runoff was being managed.
“There’s been a lot of work done in the watershed,” Shambaugh told the farmers at Thursday’s meeting. “We’ve been seeing that.”
Meanwhile, she reported that they were tracking other sources of phosphorous more closely now, such as roadways and forestry, meaning their phosphorous tracking “was no longer solely dedicated to agriculture.”
Shambaugh hypothesized that the reason phosphorous levels stayed so level in the watershed likely had more to do with time, stating “[phosphorous] doesn’t move out fast” before suggesting “it might just take time.”
“Everybody is doing everything they can”
Dr. Heather Darby, an agronomist with the UVM Extension and the Northwest Crops and Soils Team leader, repeated a presentation she previously gave to the Vermont legislature that, at that time, was meant to discourage a bill that would have declared Lake Carmi “in crisis.”
The presentation highlighted the fact that farmers in the Lake Carmi Watershed were already going beyond the required agricultural practices (RAPs) imposed on Vermont farmers, and that, by pursuing those practices, farmers were actually starting to pull some excess phosphorous out of the watershed.
While many of those in Franklin’s farming community referred to the speech as a “turning point in the conversation,” where farmers once maligned for Lake Carmi’s water quality were now being thanked for their adoption of more environmentally-minded practices, the bill declaring Lake Carmi “in crisis” was ultimately signed into law.
Darby reiterated a lot of the information she presented to the legislature, explaining that most of the farmers in the watershed were practicing no longer tilling fields and planting cover crops – both practices that should mitigate the runoff of phosphorous into the watershed.
She also reported that, between the 13 land operators remaining active in the watershed, none were operating dairies and most had the “highest level of nutrient management plan.”
According to Darby, soil testing at each of those farms had shown that 73 percent of the farmed land in the watershed were at optimum levels of phosphorous or less. Only 2 percent of the farmed acres in the Lake Carmi watershed were declared “excessive.”
“This was really, really good news,” Darby said. “This was a sigh of relief.”
Phosphorous is an important nutrient for crops, as it provides a source of energy for most of a plant’s vital processes. In some places, phosphorous is applied to make up for a dearth of phosphorous caused by over-farming, according to the Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS).
That some farms in the Lake Carmi watershed were reporting low amounts of phosphorous somewhat worried Darby, she said, as it suggested that some farmers “aren’t actually fertilizing enough.”
“As an agronomist, we encourage farmers to actually work toward this,” Darby said, pointing toward a set of data labeled “optimum.” “Once you’re in optimum, you’re in maintenance mode.”
With much of the agricultural phosphorous being managed in the watershed, Darby reported that the focus was now the “legacy phosphorous… from 100 years before” that remained in Carmi, referring to the phosphorous loads collected from more historic sources.
That farmers had largely stemmed their own phosphorous runoff, and in some cases had crops that were already starting to pull some excess phosphorous out of the soil, meant that, as far as addressing legacy phosphorous went, “our starting situation right now is good,” Darby reported.
“We’re not done,” Darby said. “But we’re not starting with some sort of disaster… I feel like we’re in a good place.”
The focus for agricultural practices now, Darby suggested, would be focusing on “keeping phosphorous on the fields.”
This is where a lot of the practices already pursued by farmers might play a role, she explained, such as the reduced tillage and cover-cropping like those already practiced by the Magnants in the corn fields that surrounded the barn that hosted Thursday’s meeting.
While most farms in the Lake Carmi Watershed were already transitioning or had already transitioned to the best practices outlined in the RAPs, or had gone even further in some cases, as Darby explained, presenters that day had a few suggestions for next steps.
“Everybody is doing everything they can,” Darby said. “We just have some new ideas.”
One of those ideas may have been the two-tier ditch presented by FNLC earlier that day, but Darby referred primarily to the manure injector that the UVM Extension had parked in front of the Magnant’s barn that day.
She announced that the UVM Extension had secured funding for their own injector, which could be loaned to area farmers looking for a better apply manure and insulate their fields from the loss of nutrients like phosphorous.
“You have an engaged group not just on the lake,” Darby said, before sighing. “A farmer’s work is never done.”
“… keep telling your story.”
Vermont Secretary of Agriculture Anson Tebbetts attended Thursday’s meeting around lunchtime, offering a few updates from the state on the ongoing dairy crisis plaguing American farms.
Since 2014, a global oversupply in milk production has led to four years of depressed milk prices, creating an economic crisis for farmers that’s led many of the area’s dairies, including some in the Lake Carmi Watershed, to sell off their herds and, in some cases, close their farms.
Tebbetts, after praising Darby’s presentation for showing how farmers were responding to environmental pressures, directed his conversation toward that dairy crisis, noting that there were options like the margin protection program (MPP) that could help at least somewhat insure struggling dairies.
He also suggested that there were going to be international pressures on farmers going forward, referring primarily to a series of tariffs imposed by U.S. trading partners, including Canada and Europe, that targeted U.S. agriculture as a response to steel and aluminum tariffs instated by President Donald Trump.
“Who knows what the end game on that is,” Tebbetts said, before citing the fact that 18 percent of U.S. dairy production is exported. “You’re not only in a regional market, but a national market and then an international market.”
His primary focus was the current formula that established national milk prices, however, stating that “we can all accept that the current system is unacceptable.”
Tebbetts mentioned a meeting he’d be attending the following week in Albany, where farmers and agriculture officials would be meeting to discuss the dairy crisis and that formula in particular.
That meeting will be covered in this weekend’s edition of the Messenger.
In the meantime, Tebbetts encouraged farmers to continue being public with events like this or the recent Breakfast on the Farm events, imploring farmers to “keep telling your story.”
“It’s more than a way of life,” Tebbetts said. “It’s who we are.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here