Carmi crisis plan unveiled

Posted

FRANKLIN — Three state agencies released a “crisis response plan” for Lake Carmi on Wednesday.

Representatives from those agencies – the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources (ANR), Agency of Agriculture, Food and Markets (AAFM) and Agency of Transportation (VTrans) — summarized the draft plan for the lake’s residents at a meeting here Thursday evening.

The gist of the plan is no different from state agencies’ prior Carmi plans. Even Perry Thomas, who heads the Vermont Dept. of Environmental Conservation (DEC)’s lakes program, said the crisis response plan is largely a renaming of the Carmi TMDL implementation team’s “action plan.”

But Thomas and other agency officials said a big change has happened outside the plan itself: new channels of communication between state agencies, specifically the ANR and AAFM.

At many prior official meetings about Carmi, members of the public claimed those agencies’ objectives were at odds, that the agencies’ lack of communication dulls either’s efforts.

But the law behind the crisis response plan requires interagency communication, including sharing data. At Thursday’s meeting here, AAFM Secretary Anson Tebbetts said new communication is already changing each agency’s efforts. For example, Tebbetts said the AAFM has shifted its spending based on previously unavailable data from ANR.

The last time Tebbetts spoke at a Carmi meeting, almost a year ago, the audience verbally attacked him, accusing him of cowardice in the face of dairy industry “mobsters.” This time, Tebbetts took the floor to applause.

“I was here about a year ago,” Tebbetts said as the applause died down, “and I think the temperature’s a little bit better.”

He said that showed public upset over Carmi’s condition has become an open dialog between legislators, the Governor, state agencies, farmers, campers and residents.

The Lake Carmi crisis response plan is available on the DEC’s Lake Carmi page, dec.vermont.gov/watershed/cwi/restoring/carmi under the “Updates” tab.

The plan is 66 pages, much of which is appendices and a history of Carmi’s water quality.

But the plan outlines six pages of primary projects beginning on page 6, projects in agriculture, groundwater, natural resources, roads and lake management.

At the top of the list is an up-to-date database of agricultural projects installed by farmers in the Lake Carmi watershed. An end goal of the database is an annual quantification of the average total phosphorous load reduced through these practices, a number many residents requested at the past year’s Carmi meetings.

Another key project is hiring an agronomist entirely dedicated to the Carmi watershed. The DEC and AAFM plan to fill the position this August according to the crisis response plan. The agronomist will basically assess the watershed’s data and help farmers adjust their practices accordingly, improving nutrient management plans, offering financial assistance and technical support and designing farm-specific phosphorous reduction plans, a pilot project for the AAFM.

The DEC plans to team with the Town of Franklin and install 11 monitoring wells in residential areas around the lake to determine phosphorous concentrations in groundwater. The DEC will monitor water levels at those sites on a weekly basis and take samples on at least seven dates.

The DEC and the Franklin Watershed Committee (FWC) plan to monitor restoration projects, three near Marsh Brook, three near the Sandy Bay Brook, to determine the projects’ effectiveness in controlling phosphorous discharge. DEC workers and FWC volunteers will sample each site biweekly.

VTrans is studying issues with two culverts, one on Vermont Route 120 near Riley Road and the other on Vermont Route 236 near Dewing Road.

The DEC is planning another major lake management project in addition to the in-lake treatment system, reconfiguring the Mill Pond dam. The DEC plans to issue a report on possibilities for the dam by October, which could include a new management system, a new dam design or the removal of the dam altogether.

The crisis response plan describes the lake’s Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) of phosphorous as a “phosphorous budget,” the maximum amount of phosphorous the lake can safely hold. That number is 22 parts per billion. Right now the lake averages 40 parts per billion.

Marli Rupe, a DEC water quality specialist, asked those in attendance at Thursday’s meeting for patience when it comes to cyanobacteria blooms.

“We’re going to have algae blooms this year,” Rupe said. “We’re going to have algae blooms next year. And the year after that. And for many years. We have to be patient.”

Audience questions were few in comparison with prior Carmi meetings.

One resident asked Tebbetts about a report the state auditor issued Monday basically saying the AAFM needs clearer evidence that its water quality programs work. Tebbetts said that the auditor, Doug Hoffer, wants concrete data, and that the AAFM is working to provide it going forward. Tebbetts also noted the AAFM is due for an audit in 2021.

Another resident asked why the State is not funding upgrades or repairs to septic systems around the lake. Thomas said Act 168 allows the State to loan funds for on-site septic repairs; Tebbetts urged those concerned about septic system upgrades to file a comment saying so.

The ANR, AAFM and VTrans are taking comments on the crisis response plan through Aug. 9. Officials urged those at the meeting to file those comments online.

 

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here