BFA system flawed, needs reassessing

Posted

BFA seniors and families have been raising a serious concern at recent school board meetings. The college application process has begun, but students have been unable to complete and submit their applications, because their high school transcripts were not ready. At issue is a decision to change from the traditional letter grade transcript format to a new system that reflects progress under a new, state mandated proficiency-based learning model, which has proven difficult for BFA to implement.

When a draft transcript was finally released, concerns were not diminished as students discovered errors and inaccuracies while questioning the methodology used to calculate overall grade point averages. Time is of the essence for these students, and they are counting on the school administration to make corrections that should have been addressed long before the start of the school year.

While the lack of a transcript is an urgent concern that needs to be addressed as soon as possible, it has surfaced a set of longer- term concerns that should matter to all of us, including current and future BFA students, families, teachers, administrators, and taxpayers.

A 2014 mandate requires Vermont schools to adopt the proficiency-based learning model by 2020. While the merits of the proficiency model are considered laudable by many, even the best of ideas will not succeed if they are not properly implemented.

While the new model requires a specific approach in terms of how students learn and master proficiency in various academic areas and skillsets, it does not require that schools eliminate the traditional method of reporting letter grades. But, BFA made the decision to implement an entirely new progress reporting system that has replaced traditional letter grades. Additionally, students, parents and teachers have had to adapt to four changes in software systems for reporting grades. These issues have led to confusion and a lack of consistency in the way progress has been reported.

To succeed, students deserve and need to have a progress reporting or grading system that is designed to clearly, accurately, consistently and fairly communicate learning progress & achievement to students, families, post-secondary institutions and prospective employers (credit goes to South Burlington High School for this statement).

The state-mandated move to a proficiency-based system is a paradigm shift; it’s not simple tweaks to an existing system; it’s a heavy lift. Three years into the proficiency-based model, I am worried that we have been asked to do too much, too fast with too little support.

We should be concerned by the results of a recent VT NEA survey of about 1,000 teachers, because

69% of respondents said parents did not have a clear understanding of their children’s learning

72% say students’ work ethic had decreased

47% said content knowledge had decreased

51% of respondents said they did not receive adequate professional development in transitioning to proficiency-based grading

56% said they had inadequate resources to implement it

Since the transcript grade reporting issues surfaced at a September Maple Run School Board meeting, I’ve heard from dozens of community members including students, teachers, parents, and citizens. A common theme is that while they have tried to adapt to and understand the new system, it’s been difficult and confusing. When concerns have been raised with the administration and staff, many people feel they have not been understood, or worse yet, that their concerns have sometimes been dismissed. Parents and students have repeatedly been told not to worry about this big change and to trust that it would all work out in the end.

It’s past time to become more accountable to our students. As community members, we trust and expect our school board and school administration to hold this accountability. Parents, students and community members need to pay attention and raise questions and concerns when they arise.

Seniors should be focused on planning for their post-high school future, instead, they are waiting for transcripts. Many colleges review applications on a rolling basis, and while our seniors unnecessarily wait for their transcripts to become available, they are falling behind seniors from other high schools. Whether continuing their education or seeking employment, our students deserve an accurate and usable record that reflects the work they have done in high school.

We cannot change what has happened, but we can learn and adjust how we move forward. I am urging the Maple Run School Board and BFA administration, to launch a third-party review of the proficiency-based progress/grade reporting system. It should be conducted by a neutral third-party (not an education consultant with a bias for or against the proficiency model).

To fix this new system, it is inherent that stakeholder (students, families, teachers, guidance counselors, college admissions officers, BFA administrators and community members) voices and experiences are heard and understood by the people charged with implementing the system. Meetings facilitated by a skilled outside mediator may be exactly what we need to learn, improve and build on the foundation we currently have.

I’m neither for nor against the proficiency learning model, but I am for a proficient and effective implementation of our education model. Students in the class of 2020 are the first guinea pigs and they are suffering the consequences. It is urgent that the transcript issues be addressed immediately (early application deadlines at some colleges are as early as November 1). And, for all the students that are coming up through the ranks at BFA, today’s issues must be addressed so that they do not find themselves in the same position when they become seniors.

This is about our kids and their future. We need to fix it.

Liz Gamache

St. Albans

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here