Back-to-back champions: Comets outlast Lakers, as Gonyeau and Shedd combine for the win!

Posted

CASTLETON - The No. 1 BFA-St. Albans Comets won 2-1 over the No. 3 Colchester Lakers in the D1 Vermont State Championship softball game on Friday, June 12.

The undefeated Comets entered the game looking to repeat as D1 champions. Those hopes hung in the balance several times as Colchester base runners reached third and even loaded the bases with no outs, threatening to score the necessary runs to win the game.

Once again, the BELIEVE mantra came through as the Comet pitching duo of Megan Gonyeau and Irie Shedd, a senior and a freshman, combined in the circle for the razor-thin win.

Gonyeau, who closed her career with the Comets with a 27-1 record, said, “I’m going to remember playing with my best friends and ending on such a high note. I’m going to remember the support of my community, my friends, and my family. I’m grateful for all of this.”

Shedd, playing in her first varsity title game, spoke of the experience: “I knew we were facing a good team, and I was nervous, but I had composed myself by the time I got to the mound.”

When asked about dealing with the runners in scoring position late in the game, Shedd said, “I know I have a good defense behind me, but my mindset in the circle is to not let them hit the ball or make any contact.”

Colchester's Bethany Henvy faced off against the Comets' 2026 Vermont Softball Gatorade Player of the Year and senior veteran Megan Gonyeau as the game began.

Gonyeau got off to a good start, striking out the Lakers' leadoff batter, but Colchester got runners on base in the next two at-bats. Crisp, accurate throws from third to first retired the next two batters to end the half-inning.

Chatham Brouillette worked a leadoff walk for the Comets in the bottom of the first. Nora Tatro advanced Brouillette to second on a sacrifice bunt, and Brouillette advanced to third on a passed ball.

Jillian Smith singled, scoring Brouillette for the game's first run; the Comets took a 1-0 lead into the second.

Gonyeau struck out the Lakers' leadoff batter and got the second out on a slow roller to the pitcher in the top of the second. Cheeseman smacked a two-out single for Colchester before Brouillette caught a line drive to second to end the inning.

Gonyeau showed patience at the plate with a lead-off walk in the bottom of the second. Emma Parah picked up a two-out RBI single on an infield pop-up, giving the Comets a 2-0 lead after two.

Colchester halved the deficit in the top of the third, capitalizing on several Comet miscues to plate a run.

A walk gave Colchester runners on the corners with no outs, and a comebacker caused a look back to third and bases loaded for the Lakers.

Gonyeau won a lengthy battle with a strikeout for a much-needed first out for BFA. A second K brought an out, and a pop-up to Marah McGinn at first ended the inning, stranding three Colchester base runners.

Although the Comets didn’t add to the lead in the bottom of the third, Gonyeau struck out three batters in the top of the fourth, quickly returning the Comets to the plate and keeping the score at 2-0.

Freshman pitcher Irie Shedd replaced Gonyeau in the top of the fifth. After a lead-off walk, Shedd induced two ground balls for outs, including a hard-hit ball that was scooped up by Brouillette for a highlight-reel play to McGinn at first. Shedd showed her grit, striking out the batter and stranding the runner at third.

The Lakers made the most of small ball and a Comet miscue to get runners on the corners with no outs in the top of the sixth. Shedd worked out of the jam, earning a strikeout to end the inning, and once again stranding a Laker runner at third.

The teams took the field in the seventh with the Comets holding a slender 2-1 lead. Shedd struck out the leadoff batter, but a triple put the Lakers' tying run within in reach. Shedd proved her mettle with a strikeout to end the game, as the Comets secured the coveted D1 title win.

Comet coach Bert Berthiaume spoke of the tense contest: “I’m always nervous, but today, with all the runners they had at third base–we just kept finding ways to escape all of these jams that kept us on our toes.”

When asked about the strength of the pitching staff, Berthiaume said, “It’s appropriate that Megan and Irie finished this championship season together.”

Having two top-tier arms in the steamy weather was a win for the Comets.

“Megan was awesome and got out of some trouble and found a way. It was going to be hard pitching seven innings in this heat,” said Berthiaume. “I was very pleased with Megan, and then Irie came in, and she was awesome as well. I’m very fortunate to have the one-one-punch of those two.”

Speaking of the Comets’ defense, Berthiaume said, “It was either a big strikeout or a good defensive play, or picking a girl off at first base. Chatham made a great play in the seventh inning. Everyone found a way.”

Coach Berthiaume closed with gratitude for his coaching staff: “I have to give credit to all of my coaches. Kevin McGinn, Ann Sargent, Meghan Connor, and my JV coaches, Molly Smith and Elise Archambault. Also, the community. These kids play travel ball and get a lot of training. I want to thank the Little League coaches, too. It’s a community thing, and hopefully the community can take pride in it.”

Comet catcher Nora Tatro shared her thoughts on working with Gonyeau and Shedd, saying, “I was thinking about the next pitch–what to throw–one batter at a time.”

When asked about the value of having a varsity coach who takes time to keep an eye on the youth programs, Tatro, a senior, said, “I remember seeing Coach Berthiaume at my Little League state championship all-star game and thinking about how I’d play for him one day. He’s always believed in us, and it’s wonderful we could finish on this note.”

Gonyeau spoke of working with Tatro: “We’ve been together for a while, and I don’t even have to tell her what I want to throw. She just knows.”

Brouillette, who was also part of the Comet hockey title, was celebrating her second championship of 2026.

“Most people don’t make it to one championship game, so I’m blessed to have won championships in both of my seasons. It’s an awesome feeling, and I’m so proud of my team. It’s been a great season,” said Brouillette.

Brouillette was part of two trips to the Little League Regional Championship and would have made a third trip, but Champlain Little League lost to Colchester in one of the seasons.

“Anytime you play Colchester, you know it will be a good game,” said Brouillette. “I’m actually friends with some of the girls on that team, and to play against them is a great feeling.”

Brouillette also responded positively to a question about Coach Berthiaume’s investment in ‘scouting’ the talent at the youth level.

“His support is huge, and I think that’s why we have such a good program and such strong teams,” said Brouillette. “Coach Berthiaume knows how to grow the program and play the game.”

Shedd agreed with Brouillette, saying, “It was good seeing Coach at the Little League tournaments and knowing he watched me pitch. It shows that he’s into the sport. It’s good to know he’s involved with it and cares about it so much at every level.”

bfa comets softball di championship champions title game softball

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here