Are Vermont towns waiting for ruin?; ‘It’s almost negligent not to step up...’

Posted

ST. ALBANS CITY — Vermont’s median home price doubled in the last decade as new builds stagnated. But what will it take to reverse the trend?

Using St. Albans City as his example, City Manager Dominic Cloud is encouraging his fellow municipal managers to be a part of the solution.

“The town is the only one that cannot walk away,” Cloud told a crowd of development professionals last Thursday. “Only the town has to consider the cost of doing nothing alongside the cost of doing something. No other entity has as much skin in the game as the town.”

Taking on risks

The crowds Thursday at the 11th annual Vermont Development Conference filled the Hotel Champlain in downtown Burlington. Consisting of professionals in the construction, legal and financial industries, many were ready to hear about some of the latest efforts to build and develop new projects throughout the state. 

Cloud got a place on the speaking schedule. As one the state’s more proactive city managers around housing development, he had a pitch to his fellow managers. 

They could do more on housing, and they might be the only ones who can.

“No other entity has access to programs like tax increment financing and the new CHIP program. No other entity can borrow at half the cost of others, use special tax revenues to offset a loss and amortize the loss over decades,” he said. “When you consider how many tools the legislature has given towns, it’s almost negligent not to step up to the ballot box.”

Few debate the need to expand on Vermont’s housing stock. Similar to other states, new housing builds in Vermont stagnated over the last two decades due to the aftershocks of the Great Recession, and housing costs have spiked as a result.

Vermont’s towns, however, tend to be pretty risk averse at taking on large development projects.  When balancing many moving parts needed for a new build, every complication increases the likelihood of a project failure, and so most local governments have relied on letting development happen organically instead of opening themselves up to the possibility of angry public feedback.

Franklin County town officials, for example, regularly chafe at introducing any project that comes with the potential of raising taxes, and few towns rely on debt to fund major builds.

But Cloud offered an alternative regularly used by St. Albans City. By leaning on state tools provided to towns, cities and villages, local government officials can effectively take the steps necessary to bridge funding gaps and create private-public partnerships that get new housing projects to the finish line.

If voters get on board, then it’s even easier to get the project done. But then, it’s the town and selectboard’s role, however, to practice political leadership to get them there, he said.

“When a community has multiple projects that cannot attract private investment to be viable, that community is dying, and the long-term health, vitality and welfare of the town is the most fundamental responsibility of the town,” Cloud said.

Building funding stacks

After spending two decades restricting new housing, finding a way out of the jumble created from low housing stock has been a consistent challenge for Vermont state officials. 

Most market activity has focused on the upper end of housing builds that remain outside the purchasing power of most Vermonters, and while there has been some success in utilizing public dollars to catalyze new builds, the state government’s regulatory burden often curbs interest from private dollars.

But as Reid Commons — St. Albans’ newest senior living development — illustrates, Vermont does know how to use its funds to build new housing.

Cloud used the development, as part of the wider Fonda project, as proof that public money can help bridge funding gaps to build new housing. In each of his examples — the American House, the Fonda Site and Congress & Main — he showed how an early purchase of land or a small loan can often result in multimillion dollar projects and increased tax revenues for Vermont’s towns.

“Now, when we do a project, we create the vision. We provide the canvas, buy the land. We clean the land, and we provide very competitive terms to the developer to come in and do their thing. We de-risk it in every way possible,” Cloud said.

But what about the public? After hearing Cloud’s presentation, Manchester Town Manager Scotty Murphy asked him how he manages relationships with both City Council and the larger contingent of St. Albans City voters, who must vote on major bonds.

“I believe my job is to create big bold ideas and to give them the opportunity to say ‘yes’ and they don’t sign off on every project,” Cloud said in reference to council. 

As for voters, Cloud said he sees the ballot box as a potential strength. While complicated programs and funding mechanisms aren’t always completely understood by every voter, securing their support makes it more difficult for naysayers to derail a project’s momentum.

“We sell the plan to the voters, and we put our own personal credibility and reputation on the line,” he said. 

During his presentation, Cloud gave some concrete examples, clarifying how public city dollars filled the gap in each of the three major projects by covering infrastructure or brownfield costs. A trusted private developer can then do much of the heavy lifting, coordinating the various parties and getting permits pushed through. 

For bigger projects, a coordinating developer can also rely on secondary public funding sources, such as grant programs or tax credits to fill gaps and create funding stacks.

Cathedral Square’s $19 million Reid Commons building, for example, relied on a mix and match of several of those programs, such as affordable housing tax credits and grants to cover efficiency upgrades, to make up the difference.

Altogether, Vermont’s Agency of Commerce counts 39 different programs — available at both the state and federal levels — that can fund developments in downtown and village centers, with a wide range of entry points depending on the project.

“Our job is to be the conductor, not to play every instrument,” Cloud said. “We know who to call, and we represent the community, and after the experts have put together the plan, we sell the plan to the voters.”

New development tools?

In the past, St. Albans City also relied heavily on its tax increment financing district, commonly known as TIF, as a major financial tool to fund new projects and cover infrastructure costs.

These days, the new approach will likely be CHIP, or Vermont’s Community Housing and Infrastructure Program. The Vermont General Assembly created and approved the streamlined program this past summer in order to give towns access to similar funding mechanisms first used by TIF.

Through the program, towns can borrow funds off of future state education revenues as long as they have a housing development approved by the Vermont Economic Progress Council, which can lend up to $200 million every year through CHIP over the next decade.

Compared to TIF, CHIP was made to be easier to use for towns, as the district requirement was nixed in the new law. This allows any municipality with a plan to move forward with a private-public partnership some access to funds to build public infrastructure for new housing almost anywhere.

During the conference, David White, president of White and Burke Real Estate Advisors, Inc., advocated strongly for municipalities to utilize the new program to solve financial gaps associated with housing projects.

“The bottom line is CHIP works, even though it hasn’t started,” White said. “It works, and we know that because it’s really a simple, efficient version of a very successful program.”

CHIP, however, does come with some restrictions. To spur new affordable housing, the new program makes it easier to borrow funds if the project is dedicated to keeping rents at a lower rate, with additional regulatory burdens going into effect if the project pursues apartment rentals set closer to market rate.

New builds can also be a mixed-use development, although a project would need to have 60% of new developed space dedicated to housing.

Additionally, municipalities with TIF districts can't use CHIP for properties already inside a district. To adequately weigh the risk absorbed by the TIF program, CHIP-funded housing projects can only be placed outside of TIF districts until the entire debt is paid back on the initial investment. For many municipalities which used TIF, including the city’s estimated timeline of 2047, that will likely be decades.

“So where do you begin?” White said. “CHIP projects can be initiated either by municipality or by the developer. I can imagine a developer who owns a piece of land in the community and says ‘I really want to do something here … Can we talk about the possibility of using CHIP?’”

As for municipalities, they may have an instance where they have a blighted, or burned down, property in the middle of town, he said.

“The municipality could then work with an existing property owner, maybe acquire it and then go out with an RFP to try to attract developers, etc. etc.,” White said. “It becomes important to agree on where you’re going. What type of project is this going to be? How many units is it going to be? Will it have a commercial component or not? What is the developer bringing to the table? What’s the municipality bringing to the table?”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here