Compelling Question: What matters most and who gets to decide? This editorial is a response to the St. Albans Messenger’s July 17-18, 2020 Weekend Edition’s front page article, “Police debate comes to Maple Run.” Rather than debate the views expressed in the July 17-18 article, perhaps we should transform the close-ended question that asks whether SROs should or should not be placed in the school setting. Instead, would it be more appropriate to create a list of open-ended, solutions-based questions that welcome multiple perspectives to recognize the advantages and address the concerns? According to an article posted on the bestschools.orgwebsite, which takes a fair look at both sides of the debate concerning SRO placement in schools, “A number of recent, high-profile incidents have cast the SRO program in a negative light. But the publicity surrounding these incidences should be regarded as an opportunity to rethink our SRO program from top to bottom: from policy standards to training standards; from community relations to student relations; from school-wide intervention to case-by-case intervention.” That said, perhaps the new compelling question should be, “How can our community help to foster an environment where SROs can make a positive difference for all students?” Should we start asking the questions we need to ask ourselves to create evidence-based solutions that our children deserve? For example, 1. Creating Relationships: How can we help SROs to nurture positive relationships with our students so students may see SROs as valued community leaders? Since their job calls for daily interaction with students, routine engagement of disciplinary incidents, and the ability to demonstrate discretion in navigating a variety of issues, what type of training should be in place to transform their role at school? 2.Setting Clear Boundaries: How can we as a community employ the expertise of SROs in the school in an equitable manner? How can we clearly outline the role of the SRO to avoid the school-to-prison pipeline? How can we assure the fact that the SRO will intervene in legal issues and not school-related issues? What distinguishes the relationship with the student community is a clear and distinct line between disciplinary and legal matters. 3. Protect Our Children and Staff: How can we continue to invite the suggestions of SROs to make schools safer places and learn how to minimize the incidences of school violence/school shootings? Let us not forget the original intent of SRO placement in the schools. Sadly, we live in an age where we need to conduct lockdown drills as much as fire drills. 4. Modeling Accountability: How can we include SROs in the process of modeling positive self-direction skills, especially to our students who thirst for direction and guidance? How can we recognize the countless examples of SROs who routinely work to make the lives of students not only safer but better? 5. School Culture: How can we include our SROs to support our school culture and enhance our school pride? 6. Educational Assets: How can we invite SROs into our classrooms on a frequent basis as guest speakers and/or advisors who can objectively share their experiences and perspectives? Many of these questions have been thankfully addressed at our schools but I think we all can agree that there is a need for improvement. Asking the right questions can foster a healthy dialogue, which can lead to a trusting environment. A healthy dialogue and trust can lead to solutions that are inclusive and elicit vision, resources, consensus, skills, incentive, and action planning from and for a community to embrace. For example, during the academic year of 2018-2019, the BFA Faculty, Staff, and Administration participated in a ‘process check-in’ during two in-service meetings. This process check-in examined several issues challenging our school. “School Safety” was one of the top four concerns that was compiled from the 219 responses gathered during the process check-in activity; a clear indication that the presence of an SRO was not only needed but highly valued as a resource to advise us to our next steps regarding school safety recommendations. These concerns were actively discussed thanks to the SRO who facilitated the cohort’s dialogue. Professional recommendations were then proposed and our school is currently working on these proposals. In addition, this past year, our SRO at BFA and the St. Albans Police Department coordinated their efforts with our school leaders to facilitate our graduation traditions that were not so traditional this year. To say our SRO went out of her way to create a positive difference at our school would be an understatement. Our roles in the public and the private sector have changed significantly in the past 20 years. We are all trying to find the best way to evolve and maximize our potential to improve our schools, innovate and support our businesses, and teach the lessons of responsibility and respect to our children. To say ‘yes’ or ‘no’ to a close-ended question which determines whether SRO’s should or should not continue their presence in the schools is an easy way out. Our children deserve more from us before we make a decision that could have some dire unintended consequences. Instead, perhaps building bridges by asking the right questions and having a healthy dialogue based on trust should be the appropriate answer to the question about SROs in our schools. At the very least, our children will be able to reflect on how we as a caring community took the effort to create a solution that would help us to avoid a school-to-prison pipeline, foster appropriate relationships, model how active citizenship can invest in social capital, and show our children how to respectfully problem solve. Thank you for your consideration and thank you to all of the SROs out there who have been willing to play a positive role in our schools.
Respectfully,
Jeff Moulton
Georgia Resident
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here