Another month to stop the stink; City Council gives DFA more time

Posted

ST. ALBANS CITY — After getting another update from DFA, St. Albans City Council is giving the creamery another month to stop the stink.

Councilors voted to table further discussion Monday night after hearing from DFA representatives, requesting more information by November — including data from engineering consultants — in order to find a path forward.

“We need you guys to understand that there is a smell,” Ward 6 Alderperson Chad Boudreau said. “I don’t care what that says. We’re still getting complaints.” 

DFA’s difficulties

Complaints about noxious odors coming from DFA’s downtown plant started to get the city’s attention this past January after city workers took note, leading to discussions between the city and DFA in order to abate the issue. 

The problem, however, came to a head this summer. When the odor began to appear with more frequency, neighbors and businesses in the area complained, eventually leading to the point in August when the city released a notice to DFA that it was planning on declaring the creamery a public nuisance due to the odor.

Since that time, DFA has been working on tracking the smell in order to answer the city’s objections, with company representatives appearing before City Council in September to obtain another month's worth of lead time to find and eliminate the source of the odor.

Complaints, however, have continued throughout the fall. DFA representatives made their second appearance in public session Monday night with data points to show how DFA monitoring hasn’t found evidence of hydrofluoric chemicals in recent weeks.

City councilors, however, expressed some frustrations. While DFA’s data could demonstrate the lack of an odor, councilors have still received complaints.

“We’re trying to reconcile here how we have no spikes on days that we have reports of smells,” Boudreau said.

As for the city’s evidence, the city administration released its chart of complaints received and tallied by city officials, and they included a number of letters written to them about the smell.

“Our monitors are giving us a whole bunch of qualitative data, and they’re saying things like: ‘It smells like a rotten decaying body. It smells like a dead animal. It smells so bad, I’m nauseous.’" City Manager Dominic Cloud said.

Finding the source

During last month’s union strike — when workers picketed in front of the plant — Cloud and St. Albans Fire Chief Matt Mulheron visited them to talk about the smell, and they noted a few potential stinky sources in a city memo.

Councilor Tim Hawkins asked DFA plant manager Panos Lekkas to answer if any information received through those means revealed a problem, and Lekkas explained how engineers were dealing with an apparatus called an equalization tank involved in treating raw milk.

During the back-and-forth, Lekkas connected a few of the smell complaints to times when the equalization tank had been full. In wastewater treatment plants, such tanks tend to hold sewage and pump it out at a slower pace to avoid overloading a system.

To say whether or not it was the source of the smell, however, was difficult to determine without talking to DFA’s engineering consultants, Lekkas said.

Councilors figured it would be worth giving the company more time in order to find that answer, requesting the company come back during Council’s November meeting for one more chance, before the city moved forward with declaring it a public notice.

“The more we can do in the next 21 days, the better off we’re all going to be,” St. Albans City Mayor Tim Smith said.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here