Air bladder deflated; Swanton Village starts process to find dam alternative

Posted

SWANTON — The Orman E. Croft Power Dam is going to need a new bladder. Or at least something like it. 

After a 20-foot gash made the last rubber air bladder inoperational, federal regulators are asking Swanton Village find an alternative solution, Village Manager Bill Sheets told trustees last week.

“(Federal Energy Regulation Commission) fears that if you had a catastrophic failure with 15-feet of water behind the dam, it’s a life-safety issue,” Sheets said. “Based upon the lack of confidence in that technology, we believe that FERC would never allow us to replace that rubber dam with the same one.”

So, it’s back to the drawing board.

Losing capacity

The village had planned to repair the air bladder, preparing in August to get construction crews in place to make the fix, but that plan is now off the table after having had more conversations with federal engineers.

Instead, workers with PC Construction started removing what remains of the device this past week. Initially installed in 2018 as the largest bladder of its kind at the time, workers have been using a crane and platforms to detach and remove the 47-ton device while standing on platforms attached to the concrete dam wall for the past week. 

“We remain deeply disappointed it didn’t last as long as we had hoped,” Sheets said.

The first few steps will require the village to start pulling in more information to identify an alternative device for the top of the hydroelectric dam, in order to continue to make the best use it, Sheets said.

The dam itself still works, generating up to 6.5 MW of electricity via spinning turbines that were expanded and added over the years, but the air bladder allowed village workers to raise the water level while controlling how much water pressure pooled behind the dam. Due to the device, the hydroelectric facility could generate up to 9.7 MW at peak production times.

Other dams without air bladders often have similar capabilities, relying on various hydraulic gates and smaller bladder mechanisms that allow engineers to vary their electric output by controlling how fast water moves past the turbines.

What that exact mechanism could be for Swanton’s hydroelectric dam, however, is a big question mark right now, Sheets said.

The first steps will be finding an engineering firm – via a request for proposal – to act as the consultant and knowledge expert for Swanton Village moving forward.

Long-term solutions

Sheets expects the process to identify a solution for the village’s hydroelectric dam problem to take three to five years, as there are many options to examine in order to determine the best long-term solution.

Everything will be done with a cost analysis in mind, Sheets said. Swanton Village’s electric department functions as an enterprise within the municipality’s operations, and the air bladder failure creates a hole in expected revenues. 

To account for the change, Sheets said the village expects to go in front of the Vermont Public Power Supply Authority to request a rate change in 2026. When setting electric rates, VPPSA takes known and measurable expenses into account, and the village requested and received a 3% increase in rates when voters passed the electric department building bond this past Town Meeting Day. 

With the air bladder down, the village will need to take a renewed look at those numbers. The exact increase is to be determined, with VPPSA’s help.

“We anticipate our rates increasing, just like every other company in the State of Vermont, even absent the failure of the rubber dam,” Sheets said.

With that said, there’s a lot of variability to what Swanton Village could choose to do with the dam, and Sheets said they’ll be looking at a large range of options — including and not limited to — doing nothing, selling the dam, adding hydraulic gates to its top and/or creating a smaller air bladder system.

“This (project), in and of itself, is enough to keep our team busy every day, but in all honesty, it’s an opportunity to do this methodically and correctly and continue to operate as an economical and 100% renewable, very reliable public utility,” Sheets said.

Prior to the recent rate change, Sheets said Swanton electric hadn’t raised rates in close to a decade for its 3,800 customers.

Other dam stuff

While Swanton Village seeks out a solution for its dam problem, the administration will also be juggling a few complications spurred by the bladder’s failure.

Starting this year, Swanton’s hydroelectric dam had been operating under its former FERC license while moving through the re-licensing process, and Sheets said the village has filed paperwork to suspend the process in light of the new situation.

There’s also the question of how much renewable energy Swanton Village might need to buy. As the administration moves through the engineering process over the next few years, the dam facility will generate a portion of its former capacity, creating a potential gap in service that requires the purchase of energy.

During their Sept. 8 meeting, for example, village trustees approved one such purchase of renewable energy as the region’s lack of rain had lowered the water level under the dam’s normal capacity.

In Vermont’s current energy markets, Swanton Village is a local producer of renewable energy, allowing it to avoid needing to purchase expanded energy credits to offset non-renewable generation. Over time, that leads to long-term savings of roughly $6 million, Sheets said, if Swanton continues to provide a renewable source of energy to its customers.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here