Acid levels down in Richford water

Posted

RICHFORD — Levels of haloacetic acid in the Richford water system have dropped to an average of 0.033 to 0.034 milligrams per liter, well below the federal limit of 0.060 milligrams per liter.

The newest results were announced at a public meeting Thursday night at town hall. The tests were done on samples taken from multiple locations in the village on July 20. The sample taken at the water plant itself showed the lowest concentration of the acids: 0.0305 milligrams per liter. The samples from the village had concentrations between 0.033 milligrams and 0.034 milligrams per liter.

Residents in Richford became concerned about the level of haloacetic acids after a required test in May led to an average test result of 0.062 milligrams per liter. At that point, the town was required by law to notify residents of the elevated levels and possible health impacts.

Haloacetic acids are a byproduct of using chlorine to kill bacteria and viruses, referred to as biological contaminants. The cholorine interacts with organic molecules in the water to create the acids, explained the Agency of Natural Resources (ANR)’s Amy Galford, who oversees compliance with rules governing byproducts of chlorination for the state of Vermont.

The use of chlorine to kill bacteria and viruses in water was an important breakthrough in public health, she explained, preventing the kind of disease outbreaks that still occur in places without water treatment systems.

However, the chlorine interacting with organic matter in the water can create “small amounts of certain chemicals,” she said. “Chlorine reacts with things, that’s why it’s useful.”

ANR’s Ben Montross, who is in charge of insuring the state’s public water systems comply with the rules, compared the organic matter in the water to tea, which is made when organic molecules in dried leaves dissolve in water.

Similarly, the organic matter mixing with the chlorine to create haloacetic acid is molecules, primarily from plants, that have become dissolved in the water of Stanhope Brook, where the town gets its drinking water.

Water from the brook is first very slowly filtered through fine sand, explained Ray Solomon, an environmental scientist with the state who works on drinking water systems and has worked with Richford since its system was first installed. He described the sand filter as “a technology that’s very tried and true.”

The sand filter, however, can’t remove the individual organic molecules, he added.

The water is then chlorinated to kill any bacteria and viruses in the water. It is placed in a holding tank to allow the chlorine time to work and to build up a ready water supply. The chlorine remains in the water as it is pumped out to residences and businesses in case there is a leak in a pipe through which bacteria might enter the system, Montross previously explained to the Messenger.

At the same time the chlorine is killing the bacteria, it is also interacting with the organic molecules to create the haloacetic acids.

A member of the audience asked if the town might want to store less water, so that the water is sitting for less time before being used, thus giving the acids less time to form. Solomon said that could be one approach, but that the flip side would be that there would be less water available in the event of a fire.

Another member asked if the town could flush the system more frequently at times where there was more organic matter in the system, such as in the spring when snow melt washes organic material into the stream or after heavy rainfalls that do the same.

Montross agreed that is also a strategy that can be used to reduce the amount of haloacetic acid in the system.

The town has purchased new equipment, at a cost of $2,000 noted selectboard chair Linda Collins. That equipment lets the town water plant operators measure how much organic material is dissolved in the water. When a large amount is present, the water operators are drawing water from a reservoir instead of the brook. By reducing the amount of organic matter mixing with the chlorine, they reduce the creation of haloacetic acids.

Higher temperatures also encourage the creation of more haloacetic acids. Galford said peak levels are often found in August.

In May, the levels of haloacetic acids in Richford’s water were well above the norm for Richford: 0.118 milligrams per liter. This is what pushed the year-long average over the limit of 0.060 milligrams per liter, state officials explained.

Asked what had caused the spike, Galford said she had looked at the weather from around the time of the test. There were two storms, one with an inch of rain and one with a half inch. That was followed by several days with temperatures in the 80s. While she could not say with complete certainty that the combination of runoff and hot weather caused the spike, Galford suggested it was certainly possible.

Several people wanted to know why the test for haloacetic acid is done only once per quarter. The answer is that the tests are expensive. Galford put the cost at approximately $150 per test. Daily testing would cost the town more than $53,000 each year.

Another solution suggested by an audience member – using activated carbon to remove the acids – would also be expensive. The carbon would have to be added to the current system, explained Solomon, because carbon can’t eliminate bacteria and viruses.

“The activated carbon system will increase your water bills tremendously,” said Solomon. In addition to the cost of designing and installing such a system, they’re expensive to operate because the carbon needs to be changed frequently. How frequently would depend on the design of the filters.

Individuals can remove the haloacetic acids from their water by using a commercially available carbon filter either attached to the tap or in a pitcher. To be certain it will remove the acids, buyers should look for an NSF/ANSI rating of 42 and 53 on the label, said Montross.

Potential health impacts

Montross first mentioned the use of Pur- and Brita-type filters in response to a question from a woman who is caring for a family member with cancer. “I just want to know what’s going to protect my family,” she said.

Sarah Vose, the state toxicologist, explained that the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) set the levels after studies on animals found those exposed to haloacetic acids were more likely to get cancer.

“There’s much weaker associations in humans,” said Vose. Because “the way cancers formed in animals was relevant to humans,” the EPA set a limit of 0.060 milligrams per liter in drinking water based on a lifetime of exposure.

“Every exposure does increase your risk, even if it is only a little bit,” said Vose. She put the odds of contracting cancer from exposure to halocetic acid at 1 in 100,000.

The risk of drinking untreated water is much greater than the risk of drinking haloacetic acids, Vose said. The acids are rarely found outside of drinking water, she noted.

In addition, the acids will not build up in human tissue. While in the body, they can cause damage within cells, but the acids are broken down and removed by enzymes, she explained.

Animal studies also found reproductive and developmental effects from exposure to haloacetic acids. However, when researchers followed a group of pregnant women, they found only a weak connection between exposure to haloacetic acids and poor birth outcomes, Vose explained.

“If you are a woman who is pregnant or considering becoming pregnant, you may want to speak to your health care provider,” she said.

The notice which went to residents also contained a warning about compromised immune systems.

Vose said there is no evidence that haloacetic acids have a negative impact on those with compromised immune systems. But because folks with weakened immune systems often react poorly to chemicals, the EPA opted to require the warning, she explained.

Solomon warned that even though the levels of haloacetic acids in the water have dropped, the average number may still be above the limit after the next compliance test in August. That’s because the high number from May will continue to be part of the average used to determine if the system is below the standard of 0.060 milligrams per liter.

In other words, even if the amounts of haloacetic acids in the water remain where they are now, at 0.034 milligrams, the high number from May will skew the average upward through May 2019.

A member of the audience asked that the town provide residents with both the average and the actual test results from August.

Another audience member suggested that the state have water systems provide customers with a pamphlet with information about the chlorine byproducts and suggesting use of filters during times of the year when haloacetic acids are more likely to form in the water.

When asked if he would drink Richford’s water, Montross said he would, adding, “I’d actually like a glass. These lights are hot.”

Vose said she would not. That, she added, is her choice, which is why the state requires people be informed about what’s in their water so they can make that decision for themselves.

 

To subscribe to the Messenger call 802.524.9771 ext. 101.

 

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here