80 units? Try 56; Town housing project meets public opposition

Posted

ST. ALBANS TOWN — “This would probably go a lot faster if we could refrain from all the applause,” board chair Brent Brigham said at the start of last week’s Town of St. Albans development review board meeting. 

An 80-unit housing complex to be located on Parsons Avenue brought out neighbors in opposition. Brigham requested they stop clapping after every public comment was made against the project.

But then, the number of people who came out against the high-density housing project — known as Alton’s Landing — filled the room. They kept clapping united against it.

The developers, however, are still moving forward.

“We’re going back to the drawing board,” Jake Tardiff, an owner under Concordia Holdings, told the Messenger. “We lost some units to try to appease the homeowners, but right now staying with the continuation and may come up with a different plan of development.”

More housing?

Public meetings are rarely so well-attended. But after surrounding neighbors received notice that an 80-unit development was in the works — called Alton’s Landing after the former property owner — 35 individuals signed up to speak publicly against it during the board’s Aug. 28 meeting. 

Even more came out to show their displeasure, sometimes talking over the proceedings, or refusing to hear from development representatives altogether. At the tail end of the meeting — after over an hour of public comments made against the project — a sizable group simply left the meeting as Concordia Holdings owner Bonnie Johnson tried to rebut a few previously-made points.

The neighbor’s concerns ran the gamut, but the biggest worry — shared by the board — was the density of the lot. Plans submitted to the town show an array of 80 units and 160 parking spaces arranged upon a 10-acre piece of land. 

As part of the development review board’s response, they asked the applicant bring that number down to 56 units, arranged in a more amenable way.

Tardiff said they would reexamine the project after the public hearing. As engineer Karl Marchessault explained during the meeting, the development project was moving through the local board approval process as “Step 1” before moving forward with Act 250, and the late August meeting helped developers meet neighbor concerns on such a project. 

One way to deal with the density issue, Tardiff said, is to potentially reduce the number of parking lots. A common complaint he’s heard from people seeking out housing has been a need for more than one parking spot, and developers figured two spots per parcel would have been a benefit for those in the market looking to build equity. 

As Tardiff explained, the intention behind the project is to create high-density housing to try to keep costs low to provide well-made, cheaper units for first-time home buyers, and the target goal was to sell each unit on the development to buyers at the cost of roughly $350,000. 

Those in the audience contended that such a price isn’t affordable, but building a new one-bedroom house for sale at such a cost is near impossible in today’s market, Tardiff said.

“They are built to be affordable,” Johnson said. “Building costs are astronomical right now.”

According to the latest housing market report released by Hickok & Boardman, the median price for a single-family home in Franklin County rose to over $410,000 in the first half of 2025 after increasing 10% year-over-year while home sales slowed.

Meanwhile, Gov. Phil Scott’s administration’s housing needs assessment estimates that Franklin County will need 1,300 to 2,200 new homes by 2029 to equalize housing demands. Two days ago, President Donald Trump’s administration also highlighted the concern, saying the federal government is considering declaring a national emergency on housing affordability this fall.

Without a change in the trend, Vermont homeowners will likely see repeated spikes in property taxes related to health insurance costs, continued increases in statewide healthcare costs and major changes in education thanks to austerity measures and cuts.

More changes

The development review board — as part of its continuance letter — also requested some changes to reduce the project’s visible impact to the neighborhood, requesting developers add some screening to the housing complex and fence-in their dumpsters.

Johnson said they had tried to remove any screening to help make the housing complex feel like it is a part of the community, but the neighboring homeowners requested they bring it back, as a few had concerns on how the people potentially living there would actually be a neighborhood.

One town resident wanted no single people at the location, as only families can partake in the school community, they said. Another said families would add too many children to the school system, increasing costs for everyone. And a third said property taxes would go up if only renters came into the community.

Johnson and project representatives repeated the point was to create affordable units for first-time property buyers.

Neighbors, however, contended there were houses for sale at that price point already. Both phrases “in my backyard,” and “character of the neighborhood” came up as concerns.

At one point, Johnson’s own credentials were called into question, as she had been involved in both the Cadillac Motel and Vista Apartments. The Vista property is now owned by Champlain Housing Trust, after the nonprofit purchased the location for $3.6 million in order to provide housing for people exiting homelessness.

“We were really desperately looking for housing for homeless folks up in the St. Albans area and this was on the market,” Amy Demetrowitz, CHT’s chief operating officer, said at the time.

The final changes requested by the development review board asked that applicants get another traffic study to take a look at the impact to Parsons Avenue and Fairfax Street, as well as provide a breakdown on expected infrastructure costs. An earlier Route 7 traffic study showed limited impact, but neighbors contended that 80 new households would clog up the roads and make it dangerous for people already living in the area.

After taking in all the information during the meeting, Tardiff said they’ll be planning how to tackle the board’s concerns by their next hearing on the matter, scheduled for Oct. 9.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here