50 years later: The '2nd St. Albans Raid' and the story of Paul Lawrence

Posted

ST. ALBANS — On Oct. 24–50 years ago–the St. Albans Police Department took action to eliminate the city’s drug problems.

In one fell swoop, 27 innocent people were arrested, charged and found guilty of various drug crimes, and the NARC officer who arranged the arrests, Paul Lawrence, was celebrated for his efforts. 

Lawrence, however, was lying.

This past Tuesday night, Oct. 24, local historian Jason Barney invited two men involved in the 50-year-old local controversy, James Levy and Randy Brock, to revisit what happened back in 1973 when St. Albans residents supported Lawrence’s efforts to clean up the streets.

In 1973, James Levy represented a number of the arrested men in court. He’s still a practicing attorney, but he spends less time as a criminal litigator after being involved with the cases generated by Paul Lawrence.

“I look at it from the perspective of why did the system fail?” Levy said Tuesday. “Because the system did fail dramatically.” 

As for Randy Brock, he now serves as one of two state senators representing a large portion of Franklin County. During the Paul Lawrence affair, Brock was hired as an outside investigator by the state public defender's office to follow up on inconsistencies recognized by people working closely with Lawrence. His findings mostly went unnoticed at the time.

“I conducted a number of polygraph examinations with the people who were charged with these crimes,” Brock said. “And in a way, I was kind of surprised because the vast majority, in my opinion … When I looked at the questions they were asked, the answers they gave, the results of the examination and the charts, I was convinced they were telling the truth.”

Historic context

As recounted by Barney, the events surrounding Paul Lawrence began when St. Albans City Council – recognizing that drugs were impacting the community – voted to hire a “NARC” to go after the problem. 

As with any historical event, context is important here, Barney said. For those who had spent their lives in Vermont in the decades prior to 1973, a lot was changing.

On the national level, Republican President Richard Nixon was facing allegations of abusing his office for personal gain, and an entire generation had grown disillusioned with public life after watching the U.S. government fight the Vietnam War. Meanwhile, rock music – much of it aligned with  the drug-soaked hippy counterculture –  gained in popularity, and a new brand of movies wrestling with darker themes popped up in the day’s movie theaters, replacing the many popular westerns, musicals and comedies the older generation had experienced in the squeaky-clean 1950s.

Meanwhile in Vermont, long-haired hippies from out-of-state began appearing in the rural hills, organizing communes and challenging social norms around gender, family and socialism. Crime was also on the upswing as Vermont’s population expanded at its fastest rate ever.

The economic picture at the time didn’t help either. Less than a decade after the federal workers completed I-89, global economic influences were already eroding the foundations of their communities.

The ‘60s had been a rough time for the Central Vermont Railroad as ridership numbers and revenues declined, leading its parent company, the Canadian National Railway Company, to start cutting unsuccessful lines, including the one servicing Franklin County’s rural towns. 

The move helped gut the St. Albans economy at a time when the region’s economic backbone – family farms – felt additional market pressures to consolidate, corporatize, or close down.

During this period of rapid societal change, Paul Lawrence entered the picture following a term working as the Vergennes Chief of Police.

When City Council offered him money as the department's narcotics officer in mid-1973, Lawrence jumped at the chance, accepting $8,000 from the council and an extra $12,500 – which was never recovered – to conduct drug buys. Touting his fake credentials, the 28-year-old Lawrence soon served as the St. Albans Police Department drug unit, responsible for ending the illicit drug trade and the threat of heroin before it could taint communal life. 

Three months later, Lawrence made his move. 

Using evidence he had allegedly collected, he filed arrest warrants for 27 long-haired men in St. Albans. Soon after, police raided Tuner’s Place, a local hippy bar, on Oct. 24.

In the subsequent months, all 27 men went through the court system. A few held jury trials. Others took plea deals. Lawrence’s alleged success, however, gained him more jobs across Vermont as he continued filing new drug crimes based on made-up drug sales, leading to 106 arrests in the St. Albans area.

The rest of the story

Attorney James Levy remembers those years as painful ones. Together with Joseph Cahill and Daniel Lynch, he served as a defense attorney for many of the young men arrested by Lawrence. 

“It was like a Russian novel,” Cahill said back in 1976. “Here you had clients you knew were innocent and nobody would listen to you.”

As for Levy, he said he still has a hard time entering a Vermont courtroom after watching how it treated those young men, and while he expects today’s court system wouldn’t repeat the same mistakes as it did in 1973, he still gets angry thinking about the events from those years.

While Lawrence was eventually tried and convicted for what he did, the young men he framed had their lives ripped apart when they were largely ostracized by the community for being alleged drug dealers, he said.

Out of the the 27 men arrested on Oct. 24, two men later died from suicide.

Levy also recalled the case of Gary Burbank, who died less than a decade later ruined and traumatized from the incident. He had believed in the system, Levy said, and it failed him. 

“As a Vietnam War veteran, (Burbank) believed very ardently that if you are innocent of a crime, you will not be convicted. All that needs to be done is tell the truth,” Levy said.

Burbank was convicted of selling methamphetamine. His mother, who used her last retirement funds to pay for his criminal defense, broke down in court after the jury submitted its guilty verdict, and years later Burbank died homeless on the streets of Burlington after drinking himself to death.

“It’s a subjective deep feeling,” Levy emphasized. “But any justice that emerges from a Vermont courtroom is sheer coincidence because the process itself is not conducive, necessarily, to just results. From that point on, I never really wanted to do criminal defense work.”

Families of the men were also affected as social pressures ostracized those related, ending marriages and ripping families apart.

Those in the audience during the Oct 24 event largely agreed with Levy’s account, and a few had witnessed the effects firsthand. Out of the roughly 30 people in attendance, a handful had personal ties to the men arrested on that day in 1973, and for them, they began to be more careful about where they went after recognizing that police could and would arrest anyone falsely maligned by Lawrence.

Lawrence’s end

By 1976, Lawrence’s actions caught up with him. 

A young police officer in Burlington started noticing incongruencies between Lawrence’s words and actions, leading Burlington police to bring in a fake drug dealer with a false history they ended up naming “The Rabbi.”

Soon after, Lawrence had said he conducted a drug buy with The Rabbi. Police surveillance on the plant, however, never saw the two men interact.

Lawrence was arrested soon after and charged with perjury. Despite his appeals, he spent up to a decade in jail, and then moved to New Hampshire upon release. 

While Lawrence was the primary mover in the larger events, Levy was quick to point out that  his arrests were publicly supported, and there were enough court officials that wanted to see him succeed.

For example, a signed affidavit from Lawrence and some bogus lab work was enough to convince the Franklin County State’s Attorney, some state officials, the St. Albans city government and local juries of each man’s guilt. Lawrence also received additional support from Swanton to conduct arrests in the neighboring town.

And even after the young men were pardoned by Gov. Tom Salmon, there were those in the St. Albans community who continued to believe those picked up were guilty of drug dealing.

A New York Times article from 1976 quoted Mayor Melvin Kaye, as he was working in the back of his shoe store.

“We wish that Lawrence had been able to make the arrests legally. We do feel sorry about that. But fearing as we do that he got the right ones, we feel it’s unfortunate the way things turned out,” Kaye had said.

On the other hand, not everyone believed Lawrence, Levy said. Other narcotics officers, for one, had a hard time believing that Lawrence was as prolific as his arrest rate made him out to be, and other state’s attorneys throughout Vermont wouldn’t touch his affidavits with a ten-foot pole out of concerns of falsification. 

Brock, who was eventually pulled into the events surrounding Lawrence as a private investigator operating out of Waterbury, said he sees the Lawrence affair as more of an anomaly, and there’s been moves taken to ensure it doesn’t happen again. 

“I saw something that’s very different from the enforcement of laws and investigations that I see that honest police officers, honest investigators, honest federal agents do. This was very different,” Brock said.

Two people are now legally required to be involved during undercover narcotics operations, and there’s better analysis of evidence. Outside Independent verification is also more robust than when he was involved 50-years-ago, he said. 

The repercussions, however, are still there. While history moves on, some will never forget.

“It is a traumatic thing, if you’re innocent and you’re convicted and no one believes you. And there are untold tragedies, personal tragedies of individuals whose parents, grandparents were ostracized because of the supposed evils done by their kids,” Levy said. “It was a horrific thing.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here