FRANKLIN COUNTY — With the speeches made, the final tallies counted and the results published, Town Meeting Day 2024 has wrapped.
The busiest day for local government featured plenty of contentious issues for voters to consider, but a few themes did end up emerging as voters took the polls this past Tuesday to set up local budgets and projects for the next year.
Here’s three takeaways from Town Meeting Day 2024.
St. Albans Town resident Bill Lotz summed up many people’s feelings on education Tuesday after leaving the polls.
"As a taxpayer I'm like 'Oh my god' but it's got to be done," Lotz said. "I'm surviving on social security, but we got to educate our kids."
Despite the sentiment, roughly one in three school budgets were voted down by Vermont taxpayers. In Franklin County, Missisquoi Valley School District, BFA-Fairfax, Georgia Elementary and Middle School, Northern Mountain Valley UUSD and Enosburg-Richford UUSD saw the same treatment as their budgets failed to pass.
The reason for the problem? Most point to the state’s handling of S.127, a bill passed by the legislature in 2022 that changed the education funding formula on how the state weighs student costs per pupil, as well as how each school approached its budget.
The result inflated 2025’s proposed education tax rate announced back in December. Early estimates released at the time set the expected rate at a 20% increase year-over-year, surprising voters throughout Vermont already worried about affordability.
Now, the legislature is scrambling to fix the problem to keep the state education system working as intended, and school boards with failing budgets have the task of reworking them up until a July 1 deadline.
The change also leaves the exact state education property tax rate up in the air, as the reworks will likely lower tax bills.
A few voters leaving the polls on Tuesday connected the increases in tax rates to the larger affordability crisis affecting Vermonters.
“With the economy the way it is, it’s bad timing,” Swanton resident Tim Menard said.
A town away, St. Albans city resident Dawn Laroe agreed with sentiment as she left the polls.
“We’re headed out of the state in a few years because of the taxes,” she said. They keep going up and up.”
As long as that crunch is felt, local officials will keep facing uphill climbs to push forward on municipal projects.
The biggest example seen this year is the contention that emerged around Swanton Village’s proposed public safety building. When the sticker shock of the $14.8 million project hit taxpayers, they came out in high numbers Tuesday to push back against the increase.
Other examples include both Swanton Town and St. Albans Town. While both municipalities were ultimately successful in getting voters to see the need for the year-over-year increases in proposed police budgets, the votes were much closer than previous years.
Swanton Town, for example, got its new police budget passed with only 12 votes pushing the vote into the affirmative. In Georgia, they denied the budget altogether, with 88 voting no to 33 voting yes.
In the next decade, affordability will likely continue to play an oversized role on budget outcomes, especially among older voters on fixed incomes who are already seeing Vermont’s cost of living outpace savings.
The problem will also affect municipal officials looking to move forward with new projects, as they will likely need to find a way to keep older populations included in future conversations to find the votes needed.
While the public’s participation around Town Meeting Day varies, almost everyone can agree ‘It’s not like it used to be.’
In 2024, fewer and fewer people are partaking in Vermont’s Town Meeting Day outside of contentious issues, leaving the day-to-day municipal operations to a smaller and smaller population.
For example, neither Highgate, St. Albans City or Maple Run Unified School District could find candidates willing to serve on their ruling bodies. Meanwhile, more and more responsibilities typically tackled by locals are being farmed out to professional consultants.
Town Meeting Day itself is also changing, as more and more towns go to Australian ballot.
In Highgate this year, voters approved that change by a 10-vote margin after those on the floor argued for both positions for just under two hours. Generational differences informed the discussion.
After an older resident – one who had been attending Town Meeting for 57 years – pointed out that anyone working has the responsibility to request a day off work to attend Town Meeting, a few younger hands immediately popped up in the audience, including that of Highgate resident Mike Laroche.
“I know there are some strong opinions of people who are of the older generation who want to keep this meeting,” Laroche said. “What is the town going to do when you’re gone? … You’re not going to be replaced by the younger generation. Here’s your chance to start developing a future for us on how this informational meeting is going to work before you're gone.”
In Georgia, however, voters overwhelmingly decided to stick with keeping the budget vote as a floor vote.
The vote that rejected Georgia’s municipal budget – held earlier in the day – had more votes cast than the article moving the vote to the Australian ballot held later. Based on the count, 38 people left between the two vote tallies.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here