DFA and union go to arbitration; Pause lifted on St. Albans plant closure

Posted

This story was updated Friday Aug. 21 at 10:20 a.m. following a statement from Dairy Farmers of America. 

BURLINGTON — Lawyers for Teamsters Local 597 union and Dairy Farmers of America left with an agreement after meeting in the federal courtroom of U.S. District Judge William Sessions Thursday afternoon. 

After hearing both party’s arguments, Judge Sessions lifted the temporary restraining order halting DFA’s efforts to close the plant, but kept the case open for union lawyers to find workers who can’t get healthcare services due to health insurance changes. 

“Aside from removing hazardous material, [DFA] will not change the building, sell the building or do anything to put at risk the arbitrator's ability for remedies," Sessions said in the courtroom.  

Following the court proceedings, DFA and the union are heading to a set 90-day arbitration where a neutral third person will help render a decision around the St. Albans plant, with an option to extend talks for another 60 days.

DFA lawyers told the judge the company will not change anything in the building during arbitration. 

In a statement following the court proceedings DFA said the results of the hearing denying the union's request for an injunction to delay the idling of the plant was expected. 

“After ensuring proper notice to the union and meeting all other requirements under the collective bargaining agreement, it is unfortunate that precious dairy farmer resources had to be expended to fight what was nothing more than an act of harassment for a sound business decision to idle the plant,” the statement said.

Sessions was at first skeptical of the union’s claims of irreparable damage in healthcare, saying it’s the arbitrator's job to find whether workers can get reimbursed from using their healthcare options, which expire Oct. 1.

But union lawyer Alfred Gordon O’Connell said their goal wasn’t to point to financial damage, rather to show how the loss of healthcare coverage for union members would be in violation of the collective bargaining agreement, causing members to skip or be unable to afford needed medical procedures. 

From the union’s point of view, Thursday’s proceedings were meant to prove there would be irreparable harm, if the company wouldn’t agree to take further action. Speaking to reporters following the hearing, union president Curtis Clough said the hearing went well for the Teamsters union and puts them moving in a forward direction. 

“I feel like that was a big win for the Teamsters up there because they agreed to do exactly what we've been looking for,” he said. 

While Sessions told the union the case felt rushed considering DFA’s announcement of the closure months ago, Clough told reporters the union first filed a grievance in July, but the dairy cooperative made no action, leading to the court filing. 

“We did file the grievances, and the company didn't really make any movement on those, didn't take any action on those,” he said. “So we felt like we were kind of compelled to do something more aggressive.”

As for the memo that DFA alleges was made up, Clough and union lawyers said they have reasons to believe the note is legitimate, but they’re holding onto the evidence as it’s not what the claim rested on. 

Clough also said DFA’s statements to the union noted the last milk load was coming in on Aug. 14 — the day of the plant’s planned closure — and the last milk loads were going out the 15th and the 16th. 

“Those were the timelines the company gave us when they announced the closure of the plant. They hadn’t remediated their timelines. Those were the timelines,” he said. “The plant was supposed to be processing milk through the weekend.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here