Swanton Wind opponents share ideas

Fair Saturday draws those against new turbines

Guest Authors

By Matthew Preedom, Messenger Correspondent

Messenger Contributor

The Facts

Owned by

SWANTON – About 150 Swantonians flocked to Rocky Ridge Road Saturday to hear from several people who have lived with and oppose wind energy projects throughout Vermont.

The presenters came to Swanton at the request of Christine Lang, the organizer of the event, who reached out to Annette Smith of Vermonters for a Clean Environment for help in raising awareness about what she believes are the potentially harmful effect Swanton Wind may have on its neighbors and the environment.

“We really wanted to get the word out,” said Lang, who has made the rounds to town selectboards and the planning commission in an attempt to stave off development of a 20 megawatt wind project on the ridge overlooking her home.

“People really need to realize what these turbines are like and what they can do to people’s health. I really didn’t know until I did the research.”

Lang said that the event was intended to bring people together to hear from those who live near similar projects in Sheffield, Georgia, and Lowell, Vt. Those speakers said Saturday that they have been living with, and fighting against, wind turbine development for years.

“This project is ridiculous,” Lang said. “It’s closer to homes than any other in the state. The turbines are bigger than any others in the state. There are wetlands and critical animal habitats on that ridge. If Travis [Belisle] is smart, he won’t submit the application.”

The Wind Fair was sponsored and organized exclusively by opponents of the project. Swanton Wind was not invited to bring its own experts to speak to these subjects.

“The truth is, they didn’t invite us or our experts,” said Anthony Iarrapino, a member of the Swanton Wind Project team. “We think that there is a lot of misinformation out there and that people should have all the facts before making up their minds about this project. We’ll be holding a public forum at the Swanton Village offices to address the public’s concerns on September 10 and we hope everyone who is at Saturday’s Wind Fair will come.”

Iarrapino also noted that at www.swantonwindvt.com/permitting, there are links to a number of independent studies and factual information about the proposed project.

“I didn’t invite anybody other than Annette [Smith] to come here and speak today,” Lang said. “This is a public event, if they wanted to come, they could have come.”

Of the 11 homes on Rocky Ridge Road, seven have for sale signs on their lawn. Only two of those are actively marketed however. Lang and her remaining neighbor’s have “For Sale by Owner” signs on their lawn.

“If somebody offers me a good price, I’ll take it,” said Ed Ferguson, one of Lang’s neighbors and an opponent of the project. “No, I don’t have [the house] listed with a realtor. Who’s going to buy it now anyway? Besides, we built our home here because it is where we want to live, we don’t want to move away. What we want is for [Swanton Wind] to stop this project.”

The Speakers

Several tables were set up under a large tent on the lawn of one of the homes on Rocky Ridge Road. At the tables sat people from various organizations and neighbor groups that have vociferously opposed the development of Wind Projects.

Beneath signs stating “GMP: Braking the Heart of Vermont” and “Sacrifice Water Parks Not Mountains!” sat Robbin Clark and Carol Irons of Lowell, Vt.

Irons was one of 12 arrested for trespass during protests at the Lowell Mountain site, but the prosecutor later dropped the charges.

“We’re here to show support to the people of Swanton,” Clark said. “We are all going to be supporting each other from now on, not going to fight these on our own. There are people here from Grafton and Windham, Sheffield, Lowell and Irasburg. “

Others spotted at the fair included former Republican gubernatorial candidates Randy Brock and Brian Dubie, Swanton Representative Marianna Gamache and Annette Smith, a controversial figure in the debate surrounding Vermont’s energy policy.

Smith is from Danby, Vt. where she lives “off the grid” getting all of her electricity from solar panels on her property. Smith states that she is not an opponent of renewable energy, but has not yet seen a wind or solar project done “the right way.”

“What we’re seeing in Vermont with the rush to develop renewable energy is pure, unadulterated greed. These projects neither create or protect a healthy environment and they are forced into our communities over our objections,” she said.

Smith said that she will not support any wind development outside the small, net metered projects that may be seen on farms and homes. But even those, she said, present many problems for neighbors.

“The technology is not good enough,” Smith said. “We are simply throwing people away, sacrificing them, as we figure out how to do this. The Public Service Board knows that it is not using the right standards to evaluate the safety of these projects, it ignores intra-sound which is the drumming that really disrupts people, and sets up bogus assumptions about noise levels inside homes.

“Our government and our legislatures are captured by the industry and are promoting projects that do nothing to protect our environment.”

Smith said that the intermittent nature of wind and solar generation, coupled with the human costs inflicted on neighbors, and the sale of the project’s renewable energy credits (RECs) out of state, does harm to Vermonters without solving any of the problems the projects are supposed to solve.

“Vermont’s energy generation is already very clean,” Smith said. “But the utilities sell these RECs to utilities in Massachusetts and Connecticut so that they can claim to be using green energy but in fact are as dirty as ever.”

According to Smith, the intermittent nature of wind generation means that utilities have to keep “an entirely redundant system” of gas and coal generators to turn on whenever the wind isn’t blowing.

“The emphasis on carbon dioxide pollution is distracting from the larger pollution problems in our world,” Smith said. “Chemicals pollute the ground and our water. These windmills will create noise pollution and light flicker. We have much bigger problems than emissions from power plants.”

Smith said she advocates an energy strategy that focuses on Vermont only and would use small solar and hydro generation to meet the state’s needs.

John Lewandowski, a selectman from Newark, Vt., is retired from an electrical generation plant in New York State. He declined to name his former employer. Lewandowski said that his town was “invaded by Seneca Mountain Wind three years ago.”

Lewandowski said that these renewable facilities really miss the point and will do nothing to reduce carbon dioxide emissions.

“In Vermont, home heating and transportation are the biggest polluters,” he said. “Vermont’s electricity is already very clean, coming mostly from hydro, nuclear, and the renewable projects already in place. Unless there is a change in technology that solves home heating and transportation pollution, this is not going to fix the problem.”

Brian Dubie lives on the eastern side of Rocky Ridge on Fairfield Pond where his family has lived for generations. He came to the Wind Fair to learn about how the project might affect his family, and what he can do about it.

Dubie said, “The wetlands on the top of that ridge are the headwater for Fairfield Pond which drains into the Missisquoi River. Both are impaired waterways and the blasting and water runoff from these turbines could do even more damage to the pond.”

“No one would let someone put these turbines in Yosemite or on Mount Mansfield,” Dubie continued. “Well this is our Yosemite and this is our Mount Mansfield and what they’re planning to do will forever change it.”

“What we’re hoping for is that Swanton Wind will decide not to move forward with this project,” Annette Smith said. “If Travis [Belisle] does this, these poor peoples’ whole lives will be disrupted for years. That is no way to be a good neighbor.”

  • Jeff

    We need to fight this nonsense before it destroys more of our beautiful mountains.

  • Native Vermonter

    I look forward to seeing them from my house!